Distinguishing Fantasy from Reality: Comparison Essay Between the Things They Carried and Fight Club

In: English and Literature

Submitted By kurokaze
Words 1904
Pages 8
Don DeLillo’s book, White Noise, tells the story of Jack Gladney and his family. Throughout the book, Jack takes on a professional, fictional persona resembling that of Hitler, being the Chairman of Hitler Studies at the College-on-the-Hill (DeLillo 4). Jack turns his professional persona into this fictional character, something he could transform himself into, as if he was filling a Hitler mold. Jack relies on this Hitler-esque persona to sustain his own personal identity and self-worth, although in his mind, this fake persona is only subsidiary to his own personality. Jack struggles with ascertaining the importance of himself as compared to the importance of his own made-up persona and this notion of fabricated reality becoming more important that actual reality is offered throughout White Noise.
While in his role of Chairman of Hitler Studies, he refers to himself as J.A.K. Gladney and dresses in sweeping, dramatic robes while teaching. Jack also takes into consideration the advice of the chancellor, “He wanted me to “grow out” into Hitler. He himself was tall, paunchy, ruddy, jowly, big-footed and dull. A formidable combination. I had the advantages of substantial height, big hands, big feet, but badly needed bulk” (DeLillo 16). This impression of J.A.K. Gladney differed greatly from Jack’s own character, and the fact that he does not know German only adds to the plasticity of his fabricated self.
The idea of false reality overtaking actual reality is shown by Jack and Murray’s visit to The Most Photographed Barn in America. During their visit, Murray states that the tourists are “taking pictures of taking pictures…We can’t get outside the aura. We’re part of the aura. We’re here, we’re now (DeLillo 12). Murray is stating that the tourists and Murray and Jack themselves are only there because of the aura in which the title of the barn, along with all the…...

Similar Documents

Fight at Inv Club

... getting booted out of the club, but because people had been so inhumane," he says. "No one stood up and said, 'Hey, this is unfair to David." The handwriting was on the wall: When the ballots went out in March, they carried only one line: "Do you favor having David Korn terminated from the club -- yes or no?" The vote was 17 to 6 in favor of tossing Kom, with three abstentions.  Korn -- who says he never received a ballot -- felt a strange sense of relief when he heard the news. At last, it was over. "It wasn't like I was going to get on my hands and knees and beg for forgiveness," he says. "Lenn invited me into the club and he invited me out. That's that." Korn himself has found solace in his new career: He's now a stockbroker. It's a balmy evening in late April, a year after Korn's ouster. Twelve members of the Golden Years club have gathered in Margaret McManus's tiny living room, sitting knee-to-knee on folding chairs, as plates of homemade chocolate-chip and sugar cookies are passed around. Width is back in control, and there hasn't been an argument in ages. Though members have been punished for buying Amgen -- it has tumbled by nearly 50 percent since they bought in -- they're certainly glad to have stuck with McDonald's. At $58.88, it's up some 38 percent since Korn dismissed it as "stagnant."  But not everyone is thrilled with the way things are going. Frustrated with the club's meager returns, Ball, who is once again president, has thought about quitting...

Words: 3828 - Pages: 16

Distinguishing Fantasy from Reality: Comparison Essay Between the Things They Carried and Fight Club

... with her, a world Nina is completely foreign to but the Black Swan would be more at home in, it shows that Nina is cracking under the pressure and is becoming more compliant to letting her other persona take over. In the conclusion of the film, Nina takes the stage as the White Swan and dances beautifully, but in between acts, the Black Swan once again projects itself in the image of Lily and torments Nina, ultimately leading to Nina stabbing what appears to be Lily with a shard of a broken mirror and hiding the body in the dressing room. During the second act, Nina lets the Black Swan take over. She delivers a magnificent performance but once the curtains close it becomes evident that Nina had stabbed herself in order to free herself from the pressure. This situation is much like how Norton’s character shoots himself in the mouth in order to kill his Tyler Durden personality and regain dominance over his own identity, but Nina stabs herself in order to let her inhibitions free and to escape the pressure, fully transforming into the Black Swan and putting her “good girl” personality aside. Norton killing his fake persona, Tyler Durden, shows him ascertaining reality’s dominance over the fabricated reality, whereas Nina stabbing herself shows her shedding her Swan Queen personality, or her “pure” self, and letting the Black Swan take over. Both of these examples show how these characters struggle with their inability to distinguish reality from the fabricated, much like how......

Words: 1904 - Pages: 8

Fight Club

...Fight Club In the book Fight Club, by Chuck Palahniuk, the narrator is an employee for a travelling car company, who suffers from insomnia. When he asks his doctor for medication the doctor refuses and advises him to visit a support group to witness what suffering really is. The first group the narrator attends is for testicular cancer victims. He finds an emotional release that relieves his insomnia and becomes addicted to support groups. After a flight home from a business trip, the narrator realizes that his apartment was destroyed by a homemade explosion. He calls Tyler Durden, a man who he met on the flight. Tyler and the narrator meet at a bar, and start to fight. They continue to fight, and they start to attract crowds of men. Then they come to an idea to start “Fight Club.” The narrator believes that Tyler Durden is the manifestation of the protagonists attempt to exert control over his own life. The Formation of Fight Club, Project Mayhem, the relationship with Marla Singer, and killing Tyler at the end make him realize what he had become and make him come back into full control of himself. The formation of fight club is the physical aspect of why the narrator has lost control of himself. Fight Club. Fight Club was formed when Tyler and the narrator engaged in a fist fight outside the bar. At the starts of fight club, the narrator could gain control of himself because he could release all of his emotions while in a fight. When the narrator can...

Words: 1195 - Pages: 5

Fight at Investment Club Analysis

... it may all way lead to favor that individual if conflicts happen. Theory: With this case it seems that the one theory that seems to relate to this analysis the best overall is McClelland’s need theory. This is a theory that can be broke down into three areas achievement, affiliation and power. I feel that the achievement of power is the one that relates the most overall for the fact it is the personal power that Width has that lead to things happening the way that they do. As with that theory I feel that there is also conflict between people within the club for initial fact that there were no set in stone rules and regulation in the determination of how things are done. There were no appointed officers or ‘regulations’ to govern its members and with that happening Width was able to become a dictator; ruling over the decisions of his club members and demanding his club members to follow him and his decisions which matches the achievement of power from McClelland’s need theory. I feel for the company not to allow for that and the equal power between everyone would be with a form of organization structure in the choices that were to be made. The Business dictionary defines organizational structure as a “hierarchical arrangement of lines of authority, communications...determines how the roles, power, and responsibilities are assigned, controlled, and coordinated.” Now with that happening it would not have allowed for Lenn Width to take overall control in the way that the...

Words: 1299 - Pages: 6

Fight Club Paper

...Dustin Wallace 3/1/10 ENC 1102 Robinson Fincher’s Interpretation of Consumerism’s Grasp on Identity “Advertising has us chasing cars and clothes, working jobs we hate so we can buy stuff we don't need.” This quote directly from David Fincher’s film The Fight Club perfectly sums up the message of the film. In Fincher’s film, the main character, played by Edward Norton, is an automobile company employee who suffers from insomnia. His life seems to be controlled by material goods and he works a white collar job in American society. This nameless character is meant to represent the average male who leads a boring life and is obsessed with his own material possessions. As the movie progresses this character, the narrator, seeks a more exciting life after meeting Tyler Durden and having his apartment destroyed. Together Tyler and the narrator create the fight club which seems to give them an identity that they never before had. As the fight club grows it becomes Project Mayhem; a rogue project with a goal to erase debt by destroying buildings that records of credit card companys. In his film, The Fight Club, David Fincher attempts to send many different underlying messages to his viewers. However, the main purpose of the film is to encourage the audience to break free from the hold of consumerism and to develop their own identity. In particular, this message is geared towards middle aged men living a sedentary life trying to be something that they...

Words: 1302 - Pages: 6

Minimalist Connotations in 'Fight Club'

... action is useless – to protest is to waste one’s breath; to fight is to waste one’s energies, “better to say nothing and do even less”; (7) a recognition that words are useless, for most things are unsayable; (8) a perception that time passes without resistance and that the characters exist as audience rather than as participants in their own world and lives, especially since it would seem that nothing they do or say can make a difference; (9) a universe in which no one thing appears innately important, so all worth is artificially conferred, decided by individual values. (Hallett 25) I suggest that Palahniuk’s fiction grows out of the frustration early minimalist fiction in general depicts (points 5-8), and that the most obvious connection between his “transgressive” novels (Sartain 2005, 40) and authors like Hempel, one of his key references, is the use and development of special narrative techniques and style (elaborations on points 1-3). Palahniuk’s contribution to the minimalist tradition, then, is that, within a broader narrative frame, he successfully adopts the techniques having been developed in the short story by others. That his point of departure is the short story can be supported by the fact that in many cases, including Fight Club, he develops the narrative thread based on experimental short stories of his own. Two chapters from Fight Club (chapter 6 and 16), one from Invisible Monsters (chapter 3), one from Survivor (chapter 31), two from Choke (chapter 20......

Words: 7514 - Pages: 31

Fantasy Essay

... is a good example of fantasy. The ad targets youth by giving the impression that drinking red bull gives wings. Similar is the case with this ad. The hypothesis presented in this ad is also fantasizing the product. If practiced by someone the consequences can be imagined. The two ads discussed give a clear picture that how marketers use concept of fantasy and exaggeration in their promotional campaigns. The problem is not usage of fantastic idea but the problem lies in associated results to it. If an idea is too far from reality, it may appeal to many but ultimately has no practicality. The fantastic ideas used by marketers are very creative and appealing in nature but in some cases are far from reality and results in customer resentment as they don’t get what they were perceiving. So, fantasy should be used in marketing and promotions but it should be close to reality. References: JoAnn, V.K. 2005, "Fantasy", School Library Media Activites Monthly, vol. 21, no.7, pp. 38-39. Laetz, B. & Johnston, J.J. 2008, "What is fantasy ", Philosophy and Literature, vol.32, no.1, pp. 161-172....

Words: 432 - Pages: 2

Fight Club

... attacks on specific individuals or things. For example, whenever an authority stands between the spacemonkeys and their missions, they simply castrate the opposition. In another example, spacemonkeys threaten to murder an individual at gunpoint if they do not pursue their true aspirations in life. However, small petty acts of violence escalade into much more violent, terrorist-like attacks. In fact, Tyler wants to literally destroy every by-product of the consumer culture; he states, “We wanted to blast the world free of history. You'll hunt elk through the damp canyon forests around the ruins of Rockefeller Center, and dig clams next to the skeleton of the Space Needle leaning at a forty-five degree angle” (116). These visions become realities; the novel culminates in Project Mayhem attempting, although unsuccessfully, to explode world's tallest building. Both the Narrator and Tyler use violence as a form of escape. Beginning with the Narrator casually stating, “I just don't want to die without a few scars” (49), and fight club evolves into a support group aiming to escape frustrations and release built-up emotions. Fight club allows any ordinary man to become someone else and to remove themselves from the real world; the Narrator further explains, stating, “Even if you told the kid in the copy center that he had a good fight, you wouldn't be talking to the same man. Who I am in fight club is not someone my boss knows” (40...

Words: 1681 - Pages: 7

Essay on Fight Club

... sisters of Dionysus mother Semele whom the young deity has come to punish for her role in the besmirching of his mother’s name. She is portrayed as one of loose moral as she bears false witness of her sister having had an affair with an earthly lover and that her sisters claim that the child who came of the union was not the fruit of Zeus. Her and her brood of sister’s spread this lie at the urging of their father Cadmus and it’s for this reason that Dionysus made them go mad and run into the forest: ; “since my mother's sisters, who least of all should have done it, denied that Dionysus was the son of Zeus, saying that Semele, when she became a mother by some mortal lover, tried to foist her sin on Zeus-a clever ruse of Cadmus, which, they boldly asserted, caused Zeus to slay her for the falsehood about the marriage”( Euripides, 410 BC) Marla is one of the supporting characters in the film Fight Club” she is an enigma that Ed Norton feels he has to solve as there is some similarity between him and her. He first notices her in the weekly meetings he goes to and calls her out on her addiction to the meets only for her to show her teeth in return and accuse him of the same. She steals from the laundry mart, dares death by standing in the middle of traffic and smokes. All very unsafe behavior’s that Ed Norton doesn’t subscribe to, this intrigues him and after they have divvied up the meetings each is to attend he gathers enough courage to ask her for her number, she and...

Words: 1979 - Pages: 8

Fight Club and Identity

... men to get man on man contact without it being seen as strange in society or being judged for it. The fact one of the rules of fight club is no shirts and in many scenes throughout the film, men are seen to be rolling around with each other shirtless and, more hugging than fighting, back up this point. Tyler and Jack living together also gives many examples to support this idea. Tyler and Jack are seen to have a lot of parallels in being a couple throughout living together. Tyler bathes in front of Jack whilst he reads a book, not a very masculine act and one many men may find strange, Jack straightens Tyler’s bowtie before heading off to work and they also spend a lot of time together, if not all their free time together after meeting. The film can be seen as a media text that inspires moral panics, specifically in America. The male audience, if perceived in the correct way, will begin to question their routines and their masculinity feeling the need for change. The film was classed as an 18 for this reason and banned in some part of the USA due to the leaders of society worrying about fight clubs starting up in the underground area of America. Consumerism is also a large topic looked at in the film and it focuses on moving away from big brands and causing a downfall, something that would cause a ripple in the public and possibly an uprising, just like Project Mayhem. These are examples of how media can change and alter identity. Hamley’s “media saturated” world provides......

Words: 1099 - Pages: 5

Fight Club

...Konstantina INQ 101 Fight Club is a film with a setting that is bleak and degraded. The unnamed main character lives in a city that is dark and rundown. The film makes has a strong message about the effects of society norms and the pursuit of happiness and it uses the main character suffering from insomnia and identify disorder to do so. The main character, like many others in the world, is seeking fulfillment in life, but tries to obtain it in unusual obsessions. He has an obsession with his furniture collection, as it helps him deal with his meaningless life and stale job position. His second obsession is going to therapy sessions to find acceptance from others, by lying about having cancer. He later on meets a guy named Tyler on an airplane, who becomes a huge influence on his life but viewers later learn is only a character of the main characters imagination. Tyler introduces “fight club,” which evolves around individuals determined to dismantle society and self-destruction. They start random fights with strangers to get a reaction out of them and blow up credit card companies, with the main idea that it would set everyone’s debt to zero to create global chaos. They fight with members of the fight club, with the idea that self made scars and inflicted pain is a form of healing. His three major obsessions I believe classifies him as having an identity disorder, as he has insomnia, memory loss and blackouts. This film I believe gives a message that......

Words: 367 - Pages: 2

Fight Club

... failed to do this because of an encoding failure. When he began to tell me my tasks I focused on the first one and, did not hear what he said after. I was thinking about what I had to do for that task that I didn’t listen to the other tasks. I was unable to remember what else he said so I had to go ask him to repeat himself. I thought about this project in hopes that it would help me find a way to remember what else he had said. Sunday, February 8, 12 p.m. When I ran into a friend I knew from high school, I embarrassedly forgot their name. I forgot their name due to retrieval failure because I had not seen them in three years. The only way I remembered because of priming when they gave me a hint to what their name started with. When I couldn’t remember I thought of this assignment and the different retrieval clues I could use to remember their name and save me from embarrassment. Monday, February 9, 1 p.m. While doing homework I got stuck on a problem and got up to go ask a friend. Walking into their room we began to talk about something else and I forgot about my question. Due to absent-mindedness I wasn’t paying attention to what I had to ask, but I was paying attention to the conversation. When I returned to my room and saw my homework I remembered about my question because of context-dependent memory. I saw my homework and I remembered I had a question. I realized that I was forgetting something because of this project, but it didn’t help me remember what it was....

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

The Movie Fight Club

...Student's Name Instructor's Name Course Date The movie fight club Different peevish acts may accompany specific cultures that may at one point result to both good and bard aspects of the society. In addition, different authors and scholars have made it real to discuss such aspects of life in their productions to enhance a pass of information to the general public. David Fincher in his work on Fight Club film touches on social commentary as well as consumerist culture on feminization and how it influences masculinity as demonstrated hereinafter. Consumer culture provides the source to the grief and fight in the society. This political rebellion facilitates anger and fight among the characters. The values of advertisement are highly critiqued in the film with consideration of aspects such as wealth, power, beauty, and youth. As much as people could do jobs in the society to attain physical sustainability, they are no longer satisfied spiritually. The society continues to buy marketed goods to provide better feeling since they do not feel like there is sensible person to talk to about their grievances. Class isolation is another important aspect as per Fincher’s argument in the film. The character Jack suffers from lack of satisfaction as well as insomnia since he has no friend whom he can share his problems with. He could not get someone to share with openly the sad and dark-natured feelings. In addition, jack could not find reasons why he experience...

Words: 1115 - Pages: 5

Fight Club Essay

...Alan Badel English 100/Major Essay #2 Professor Raymond Morris 23 October 2015 The Fight Club Aims to Free Individuals from Society’s Emasculating Shackles Chuck Palahniuk’s Fight Club is an exciting fictional novel that will hold the audience captive following three revolving main characters in Marla Singer, Tyler Durden, and the narrator himself as they take the reader through confusing twists and perspectives, while providing a most revealing closure. Although the title suggests an exclusive organization focused on violence, the novel describes the emasculation of man in today’s modern age of consumerism, societal associations and family structure along with the main and sub-characters’ exercising of power and submission to power as evident throughout the novel. Chuck Palahniuk’s values illustrate in the novel how humanity is being enslaved by the power of consumerism, brought to general awareness a new mental disorder, and how he portrayed the narrator having experienced or enacted numerous anarchistic efforts in the hopes of being freed from the confines of an industrialized and necessity-driven society. It should also be noted that several rebellious acts were performed by the fight club members and subsequently members of Project Mayhem in order to gain notoriety and power in response to being economically and socially subdued. To understand the novel’s numerous projection of emasculation, masculinity will need to be established. Man’s foundation of...

Words: 2859 - Pages: 12

Fight Club Essay

...Fight Club In “Fight Club” by Chuck Palahniuk we follow The Narrator in his problem-riddled everyday life, and his attempt to escape it by fabricating an alternate identity. The essay focuses on themes such as masculinity vs. emasculation, violence and the connection inbetween. Secondly, the essay includes references to the theoretical text “The Crisis of Manliness”. In the text “Fight Club” we follow the unnamed narrator or The Narrator in his daily life at Microsoft. Suffering from relationship problems, self-esteems problems and an insufferable boss, The Narrator has a hard time suffering from insomnia because of this. To handle his problems, he starts a fight club with his alter ego, also known as Tyler Durden. The text uses first person narration, as we see through The Narrators eyes, but also the thought of Tyler Durden, as they are the same person, even though he is written as an independent character in chapter 6. The Narrator and Tyler Durden start fight club as a way to regain their masculinity. This violence begins in the parking lot behind a bar, where Tyler tells the Narrator to hit him. The Narrator is reluctant at first, but gives in. In return he receives a punch to the chest by Tyler. This is the beginning of The Narrators self-realization. The Narrator agrees with Tyler that self-destruction is the way to self-improvement. The Narrator mentions the fight club as not being a solution to his problem, but rather a way to escape from the problems, as...

Words: 562 - Pages: 3