Premium Essay

Electoral College Dbq Analysis

Submitted By
Words 819
Pages 4
In the 1787 Constitutional Convention, the members debated on methods on how to pick the President of the United States. Finally the Committee of Eleven proposed an indirect election, which is the Electoral College. The voters elect the electoral college which then elects the President. However there is much room for mistakes through this process. Therefore, due to the corruption and inequality, the Electoral College is not a fair and equitable way to elect the President of the United States. Over the years, there have been times when the Electoral College elects a candidate that did not win the popular vote. For example in the election of 1824, Andrew Jackson won the popular vote with 152,933 votes but John Quincy Adams became president …show more content…
As written in Federalist #68, “A small number of persons, selected by their fellow citizens from the general mass” (Doc 1). The Federalist Papers were written by multiple people under the name “Publius” and they were distributed out to everybody. Federalist #68 was written by Alexander Hamilton who was a middle aged, white male. He was part of the Continental Congress and led the Federalist party. He favored a strong national government but wanted a loose interpretation of the Constitution. He also advocated for “rule by the best people. Hamilton wrote this to show people the reasons for why the executive branch works the way it does. Hamilton discusses how the electoral college will lower the amount of corruption. He also believed that the population of people would make the wrong decision. However if people are not smart enough to vote for their own president without an Electoral College who is to say that people will pick the right senators and representatives to represent them. People might pick tyrannical people to represent their state. The Electoral College can still be corrupted, all it takes is one evil person to be …show more content…
Voting has changed a lot over the years. It first started off with only being white men and now all races and women can vote in the elections. Although more people are given the freedom of voting now, they are still restricted by the Electoral College, since that has the ultimate power in who becomes the President. The Electoral college gives smaller states an advantage over the bigger states. Also the Electoral College holds a great deal of power on determining who becomes president, therefore suppressing the voice of the people. Additionally the Electoral College can still be corrupted if people elect the wrong person to represent them. This makes it even worse because the Senators and Representative already have more power than the common person, so it is worse if members of the Electoral College are corrupted rather than one person voting for the wrong person in an election. As a nation of the people, by the people, and for the people, the United States should formulate a better plan for electing the

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Electoral College Dbq Analysis

...Did you know the electoral college is the way we as a country select our president and has 435 votes in total? The electoral college was established in 1787 to consider many methods to elect the president and was originally called the Constitutional Convention. The electoral college should be changed even though many people think it’s a successful method of how we pick our president. The main reasons are that it causes confusion in the ballots and it is corrupt, there’s an unfair amount or representation in the number of votes per state, and if there is no majority then the House of Representatives decides the leader of our country instead of the people. The primary reason the electoral college is due to the confusion of the ballots in some polling stations or corruption within a state’s voting. In the 2000 election, George W. Bush won the election because he won Florida in a 5-4 U.S. Supreme Court case decision (Document 6). This decision could show the corruption due to the party affiliation of the judges or who they voted for in the election. The reason that this case went to...

Words: 629 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Electoral College Dbq Analysis

...In 1776 when our nation was founded we only had about 2.5 million people. Now 241 years later we have over 326 million people. We are closer and more connected to politics now. This is why we need a good fair way to see who will lead us. We need some sort of system that is fair and reliable for our country. The Electoral College is an unfair and unreliable system chose our President. Some people believe that the Electoral College shows good government and legislation. This is not true because if it was to show this we need an understandable and efficient system(Document C). The Electoral College is inefficient and hard to understand, which shows we need a new and better system in its place. It is true that some states can have a much...

Words: 412 - Pages: 2