Premium Essay

Fairness Opinion

In: Business and Management

Submitted By asdf100
Words 14271
Pages 58
Citation: 1989 Duke L.J. 27 1989 Content downloaded/printed from HeinOnline (http://heinonline.org) Mon Dec 3 16:27:50 2012 -- Your use of this HeinOnline PDF indicates your acceptance of HeinOnline's Terms and Conditions of the license agreement available at http://heinonline.org/HOL/License -- The search text of this PDF is generated from uncorrected OCR text. -- To obtain permission to use this article beyond the scope of your HeinOnline license, please use: https://www.copyright.com/ccc/basicSearch.do? &operation=go&searchType=0 &lastSearch=simple&all=on&titleOrStdNo=0012-7086

FAIRNESS OPINIONS: HOW FAIR ARE THEY AND WHAT CAN BE DONE ABOUT IT?
LucIAN ARYE BEBCHUKt
AND MARCEL KAHAN*

INTRODUCTION

Fairness opinions have become a regular feature of every major corporate control transaction. Whether in negotiated mergers,1 freeze-out mergers, 2 hostile tender offers, 3 friendly tender offers,4 self-tenders, 5 leveraged buyouts, 6 negotiated share repurchases, 7 or negotiated sales of treasury stock,8 directors seek the blessing of investment banks before approving transactions or adopting defensive measures. These banks give their blessings in the form of fairness opinions, which usually consist of short letters that state an opinion about whether a proposed transaction is "fair" or "adequate." 9 In addition, the banks often give presentat Professor of Law, Harvard Law Schaool; Faculty Research Fellow, National Bureau of Economic Research. * Visiting John M. Olin Scholar, fall 1988, Harvard aw School; Associate, Kramer, Levin, Nessen, Kamin & Franke. For financial support, both authors are grateful to the Harvard Law School Program in Law and Economics, which is funded by the John M. Olin Foundation. Lucian Bebchuk's work was also supported by the National Science Foundation. The authors thank Irene Khaitman for her helpful research assistance and Andrew…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Fairness Opinion

...FAIRNESS OPINIONS IN MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS Anil K. Makhija* The Ohio State University Rajesh P. Narayanan Ohio University April 11, 2007 ____________________________________________________________ __________________ Abstract Fairness opinions provided by investment banks advising on mergers and acquisitions have been criticized for being conflicted in aiding bankers further their goal of completing the deal as opposed to aiding boards (and shareholders) by providing an honest appraisal of deal value. We find empirical support for this criticism. We find that shareholders on both sides of the deal, aware of the conflict of interest facing advisors, rationally discount deals where advisors provide fairness opinions. The reputation of the advisor serves to mitigate this discount, while the contingent nature of advisory fees appears to have no impact. We also find support for allegations that fairness opinions are sought by boards for the legal cover they provide against shareholders unhappy with the deal’s terms. JEL Classification: G34, G24 Keywords: Fairness Opinions, Mergers and Acquisitions, Investment Banking ____________________________________________________________ __________________ *Corresponding author: Anil K. Makhija, 700 E. Fisher Hall, Fisher College of Business, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210. Tel: (614) 292-1899. E-Mail: Makhija.1@osu.edu. We are grateful for comments from Angie Low, Brian Nocco, Robert Rosholt, and René Stulz,...

Words: 14214 - Pages: 57

Premium Essay

Freedom of Speech

...prevent. It is a question of proximity and degree” (Moyers, UNC TV) So we have to ask ourselves, is talk radio Hate speech? Well Patricia Williams, a columnist for “The Nation” seems to think so. “The Nation” is a self proclaimed political left wing champion publication. So it does not surprise me to hear that Williams thinks that the right wing conservative talk radio shows like Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, or the countless others are “putting nothing less than hate onto the airwaves, into the marketplace, electing it to office, teaching it in schools, and exalting it as freedom” (Choices, 236). The plain and simple truth is Williams has an agenda of her own that she has to push. Under the freedom of speech, she is allowed to voice those opinions. Well this raises some interesting ideas. Are the political view talk shows, both left and right wing, going too far in their free speech, is it really considered hate speech, and is it creating an injustice or inequality for one side or the other? Well hate speech is defined by Dictionary.com as “speech that attacks a person or group on the basis of race, religion, gender, or sexual orientation.” Well by this definition, the idea that Williams is suggesting that these political talk shows are nothing but hate speech is wrong. If you spend any amount of time listening or paying attention, the attacks that most of these talk shows do are based on perceived ignorance or political ideology, and not on any of the defined terms of what......

Words: 2457 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Legal Ethics

... Compensation of attorneys; agreement as to fees. -  An attorney shall be entitled to have and recover from his client no more than a reasonable compensation for his services, with a view to the importance of the subject matter of the controversy, the extent of the services rendered, and the professional standing of the attorney. No court shall be bound by the opinion of attorneys as expert witnesses as to the proper compensation, but may disregard such testimony and base its conclusion on its own professional knowledge. A written contract for services shall control the amount to be paid therefor unless found by the court to be unconscionable or unreasonable. F. Discuss the Moral and Legail Issues Involved CANON 15 - A LAWYER SHALL OBSERVE CANDOR, FAIRNESS AND LOYALTY IN ALL HIS DEALINGS AND TRANSACTIONS WITH HIS CLIENTS. Rule 15.05. - A lawyer when advising his client, shall give a candid and honest opinion on the merits and probable results of the client's case, neither overstating nor understating the prospects of the case. Rule 15.07. - A lawyer shall impress upon his client compliance with the laws and the principles of fairness. CANON 17 - A LAWYER OWES FIDELITY TO THE CAUSE OF HIS CLIENT AND HE SHALL BE MINDFUL OF THE TRUST AND CONFIDENCE REPOSED IN HIM. F.1. Moral Issue. The moral issue in the case is that Evie accepts the case even she knows that there is a little chance of winning because of the fact that it could boost her She just accepted the case......

Words: 752 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Survey Paper

...MLB. This survey will be used as a tool that is designed to have survey-takers contribute opinions and suggestions so that a collection of data can be reviewed to determine whether the survey-takers are in agreement with the factors mentioned above is the result to higher salaries in the MLB. Specific variables will be used in the survey questions and the results will show how effective each question within the survey is. There will also be ethically constructed questions to assure there is a good quality survey. The Purpose The main purpose of the survey is to increase knowledge in whether higher paid salaries in the MLB correlates and has a relationship with a player's skills and the number of wins accomplished by the team. Arrangement and structure of the survey will provide a vast amount of information for survey takers as well as for the surver creator. The survey creator will gather knowledge along with important information on the survey takers opinions on this matter as well as ways to improve the effectiveness of the survey. Design This survey will contain 10 questions to help the creator of the survey, have a better understanding on how the survey takers think about the MLB players and games. The first question will introduce the baseball game, followed by a question on the importance of the game, and the third question will ask the survey taker how important is fairness on the salaries offered to the players. Question four will ask if the survey taker is......

Words: 994 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Defense Mechanism & Psychographic Segmentation in Term of Bangladeshi Advertisement

...Psychographic segmentation: The psychographic profile of a consumer segment can be thought of as a composite of consumers measured activities interest & opinions (AIOs). In term of Psychographic segmentation, Consumer responses to a large number of statements those measures…… Activities: how the family spending time? Example: golfing, volunteering to a local blood bank. Interest: the consumer’s family preferences & priorities. Example: Ecstasy for cloth & Pizza hut for party. Opinions: how the consumers fell about a wide variety of events & political issues, the state of the economy AIO Psychographic segmentation use a battery of statements designed to identify relevant aspects of a consumer’s personality, buying motives, interest, attitudes, beliefs & values. Three advertisements that are targeted at a particular Psychographic segment…….. Bata [pic] In these advertise, It is trying to capture the market by highlighting Bangla culture & tradition; It promoting that consumer should buy sandal & shoes from bata for celebrating Bangla New Year. In term of segmentation, these advertise shows & promotes Consumers activities: celebrating pohela boishakh , Consumer’s interest: trying to capture the family preference by showing several of sandals that they have. Frutika juice [pic] In these advertise, It is trying to capture the market by promoting that their juices have extra pureness In term of segmentation,......

Words: 781 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Didgital

...Fairever Fruit Fairness Cream Date: April 18th, 2008 ( Submitted in partial fulfilment of the II semester course Requirements of MBA 2008-2010 batch) Submitted by Group No:10 K. ASWINI NAIR (CB.BU.P2MBA08043) NANDAGOPAL N (CB.BU.P2MBA08059) SINDHUJA DURGA R (CB.BU.P2MBA08099) SOORYA SOMAN (CB.BU.P2MBA08101) SOUMIA S (CB.BU.P2MBA08103) SREEDEVI AJITKUMAR (CB.BU.P2MBA08105) 1 CERTIFICATE This is to certify that we, the students of Amrita School of Business, are submitting the following document as part of the partial fulfilment of the Marketing Management course requirements of second semester MBA for the batch of 2008-10. The report stands genuine to the best of our knowledge and a tool to be used, only with the objective of academic reference. Any deviation from the above stated, is liable to be termed unethical malpractice and subject to forfeiture of the acknowledgement of the efforts of the students responsible. The following work has been carried on under the able guidance of our Professor Dr. Deepak Gupta. Date: April 18th, 2008 Students, Amrita School of Business Attested by (Signature) Prof. Dr. Deepak Gupta Professor (Marketing) Amrita School of Business 2 ACKNOWLEDGMENT We have a great pleasure in thanking prof.Deepak Gupta for giving us an opportunity to do a project on Market Reasearch.We would also thank our mentor, Mr.Karthikeyan for his sustained and adequate guidance. We would like to thank staffmembers for their support We thank them for their......

Words: 12251 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay

Perceived Fairness of Yield Management. Case Study

...Reference: Kimes, S.E. (2002). Perceived fairness of yield management. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 43, 21-30. doi: 10.1177/0010880402431002 Kimes investigated yield management and whether customers perceive it fair. The first objective was to determine if customers believe maintenance of a profit through raising the price to be fair. The second objective was to discover if increase in prices that leads to increase in profit identified by customers as unreasonable. The third objective of the research was to find out whether the same price with decreased costs is considered reasonable from customers prospective. When implementing yield management, managers should consider long-term profits as well as short-term profits. Otherwise, the consequences can be disastrous (Hayes & Abernathy, 1980 in Kimes, 2002). The previous researches also have found that perceived fairness is very important in managing long-term profits (Thaler, 1985 in Kimes, 2002). To better understand the definition of fairness the author discussed the concept of a “reference transaction” (Kahneman, Knetsch & Thaler in Kimes,2002). This concept implies that customer have a clear vision of how the transaction should be conducted and how much it should cost. Also, to understand the position of a customer in a transaction, the researcher mentioned the position of a customer where the value to one should equal to the value to the firm (Kahneman, et al., in......

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Fairness in Reward Allocation

...Fairness in Reward Allocation Name of the student: Name of the University: Course ID: Author’s note: Introduction The discussion of the essay is associated with the fairness in reward allocation that depends on various processes. Most of the organizations are facing the problem to implement the transparent process during the reward allocation because of the individual perception. The theory regarding the fairness also suggest to implement a structured way that will adhere to the policy of the organization so that no employees remain with the dilemma that justice is coming in the proper way. The theory is used to understand the behavioral aspect of the employees and their superior where researchers have given several feedbacks that influence the process (Lund, Scheer and Kozlenkova 2013). The argument is structured in such a way that helps to understand the several aspects of the importance of the organizational fairness in the compensation management, role of organizational fairness in reward allocation, factors that are influencing fairness in reward allocation, impact of reward distribution on employees and how fairness can be achieved within the process. All the processes are discussed with the view of several researches that establish the fact of issues and solutions of the reward allocation. At the end of the essay, every topic is summarized with the findings that could help to enhance the reward allocation. Discussion Operating an organization always needs......

Words: 2540 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Hr 434 Week 3 Homework

...reward system that will maximize employee performance alignment with Polo’s objective and promote fairness to the employees. Therefore, its reward system promotes implementation of organizational goals and compromises personal interests. It leads to motivation of active employees because they are rewarded higher than inactive employees. Clients argue that Ralph Lauren Polo employees possess customers’ relation’s skills because they are trained on selling clothes hence they are rewarded appropriately. Therefore, this system is effective and may lead to expansion of market share and retention of its employees (Spitzer, 2009). Ralph Lauren Polo Business environment The system delivers the value of performance to employees through aligning their goals to the reward system in order to center employees on organizational culture, perceptions and values. This involves positive feedback given by clients, which are compensated as bonuses or rewards. Polo’s reward system is consistent to the organizational culture to promote excellent reputation in the community because human resource is a feature of rewards system (Spitzer, 2009). This reward system equips Polo’s management with tools and strategies to reward employees according to the desired organizational culture. The organization culture of Polo is performance based to promote effectiveness of their reward system and fairness to the employees. This promotes alignment of employee performance to the objectives of Polo......

Words: 743 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gleim Q&a

...expressed in the report The report shall identify the assertion being reported on and state the character of the engagement The work shall be adequately planned, and assistants, if any, shall be properly supervised Which of the following professional services is considered an attest engagement An engagement to report on compliance with statutory requirements The primary reason for an audit by an independent, external firm is to Provide increased assurance to users as to the fairness of the financial statements Independent CPAs perform audits on the financial statements of issuers. This type of auditing can best be described as A discipline that attests to financial information presented by management Users of an issuers financial statements demand independent audits because Management may not be objective in reporting An audit of the financial statements of Camden Corporation is being conducted by an external auditor. The eternal auditor is expected to Express an opinion as to the fairness of Camden’s financial statements Notes (payable) that are included with financial statements are the responsibility of the Company’s management Brand-new company is going public, and its stock will be listed on a stock exchange. Audited financial statements are required to be filed with the SEC. Who is expected to be the primary user of the audited financial statements? Brand-new company’s investors When congress passed the Sarbanes Oxley act of 2002, it imposed greater......

Words: 2708 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Personal Reaction to Article

...Informal Writing #4: Personal Reactions to “Facts and Fallacies about Paycheck Fairness” After reading the article, titled “Facts and Fallacies about Paycheck Fairness,” written by Phyllis Schlafly, I felt that the tone of the text was more on the angry side. I was surprised that a woman wrote the article since it talks heavily about how women vary from men in the workplace, as well as their salaries, in more negative ways than positive. In my opinion, this article is very biased and only talks about the fallacies the author believes that related to paycheck fairness. Yet, while reading, I wondered what sources the author was getting her evidence from and how reliable it was. Persuasive,credible statics would have helped the author prove her points even more to the reader. Even though the author makes several great points, such as working woman dealing with raising children and hypergamy, I feel that the negative sides of the story were being discussed more. The opening two paragraphs were a great introduction that captured my attention, but after that I feel that the author was just ranting about women's’ life choices and their negative effects. Also, towards the end of the reading, I feel that the details of marriage rates falling could have been eliminated, mainly because it’s misleading and too late to introduce into the article. The topic of work pay fairness and gender role in the workforce is an interesting social issues at this time, and this article would have......

Words: 259 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Final Exam Cas Study

...Abstract Smith Barney (now part of Citigroup Global Markets) was ordered by the court to evaluate the climate for personal development and advancement through promotion in not only Smith Barney but, as a comparative, in other financial services firms. The case describes the methodology used to sample both men’s and women’s beliefs and attitudes, as well as revealing some of the basic findings. 2. The Scenario In 1996 Pamela K. Martens, Judith P. Mione, Roberta O’Brien, and 22 others filed a class action suit in U.S. District Court, New York, against Smith Barney and former Garden City, New York, office manager Nicholas Cuneo, citing a rash of complaints. These included “intimidation, retaliation, and humiliation,” as well as lack of fairness in pay, denial of promotion, demotion due to maternity leave, unfairness in distribution of accounts and discharge without cause. Initially Cuneo was discharged, but when the plaintiffs did not drop their suit, he was reinstated as a sales agent. In May of 1998, Judge Constance Baker-Motley approved a settlement, which had been accepted by 23 of the 25 plaintiffs. As part of the settlement in Martens, et. al. v. Smith Barney (S.D.N.Y., 96 Civ3779), Smith Barney was charged with paying for a study of the issues underlying the suit. The female judge ordered a research project done by “Catalyst or other similar firm,” one which understood the issues under study. “Catalyst is a nonprofit research and advisory organization......

Words: 587 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethic

...rules and the same treatment no favoritism. My blind spot in this lens is I have a habit of trying to fix and control everything even when it is unnecessary. My strengths are that I believe that everyone should be treated fairly, able to problem solve for fairness and loyal. My weaknesses are I can be a judgmental, over ambitious, guilty if I can’t fix the situation and bossy. My values and behavior tend to conflict causing a personal confusion. (Ethic Game, 2013) I researched the definition of personal ethic is basic principles and values govern interactions among individuals. (Business Dictionary, 2013) My definition of personal ethics is my value and beliefs that help me decide my actions in moral situations. When particular situations occur I have the ability to make sound and fair decisions. If I feel that my point is correct that I will fight for my opinion or to get my point across. My overall definition is to give everyone a chance, consider all ideas and voice my opinion. My personal ethics could be helpful asset to determine proper reaction to situations. My ability to think, analyze and solve the problem. To make overall decisions in ethical situations I use rational decisions, self -awareness and fairness. There will be situations that my personal ethics cannot solve the problem which is a value that causes conflict for me. The ethical game activity help identify my personal ethical statement. It identified my ethical lens, blind spots, strengths and......

Words: 348 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cultural Norms, Fair & Lovely and Advertising

...to make you find a husband or get a job. Every woman just wants to look better. If Indian women feel better with lighter skin (like most Americans feel more confident with tanner skin) then let them decide what they want to do to feel beautiful. 3. I believe HLL’s Fair & Lovely Foundation is a great step to receiving forgiveness and regaining lost customers, however some opinions cannot be changed. 4. After AIDWAS’s charges Fair & Lovely should promote without getting too deep, there is no reason culture and family issues need to be used to get a point across about a product. They can simply advertise fair skin without making fair skin seem better. 5. Now that males are using fairness cream the arguments against Fair & Lovely seem irrelevant, however there were aspects of the advertisements that were not just sexist, the fact that they put down working women is still an arguable factor or their advertisements. 6. Using Shakti Ammas to expand fairness cream to the masses is a great idea, it makes it more affordable and accessible to underprivileged and people with lower incomes. Since fairness is associated with wealth in India this will make more people feel equal....

Words: 360 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Isllc Standard 5

...administrator is an educational leader who promotes the success of all students by acting with integrity, fairness, and in an ethical manner. Knowledge Skills Enduring Understandings Essential Questions Administrator will know… Administrator will be able to … Administrator will understand that… Up to date leadership Improve educational programs concentrating on assisting students and the community (ISLLC 2008:5B) Principles of the community Cultivate a concerned school atmosphere focusing on all stakeholder and students. (ISLLC 2008:5E) System of beliefs Develop a program based on professional ethics held by the school stakeholders. (ISLLC 2008:5B) Structure of beliefs Show fairness throughout the decision-making procedure to expedite equality. (ISLLC 2008:5B) Values of learning Make certain all students have the right to a free education. (ISLLC 2008:5D) Ability to be taught Preserve the significance of a indiscriminate school environment. (ISLLC 2008:5E) Beliefs in resolutions Observe the difference between students defined by culture. (ISLLC 2008:5D) Build Compassionate community Respect the input of all stakeholders to ensure equality. (ISLLC 2008:5A) Investigate the ones beliefs Restrict their own opinion and adhere to professionalism (ISLLC 2008:5B) Set example Model their goals and administrative performances to ensure fairness and equality. (ISLLC 2008:5A) Held accountable Accept the duties of the position held. (ISLLC......

Words: 267 - Pages: 2