Premium Essay

Gender Pay Argument

Submitted By
Words 1711
Pages 7
Most people in the United States have heard of the gender wage gap. The gap argument is that women get paid less than men (Lips). Feminist movements in the past have helped women gain rights they did not have, such as the right to vote. Other movements like wars have pushed women into the job market and the creation of Rosie the Riveter when they were previously housewives and caretakers. When hearing that there is a gender wage gap, the most obvious solution is for there to be another feminist movement. However, one must question whether a gender wage gap actually exists. Most people have an opinion on the topic of a gender wage gap. The studies and literature someone reads can point them in different directions on whether the gap exists or …show more content…
For example, Mark J. Perry from American Enterprise Institute points out there “is no gender wage gap, rather there’s a gender earnings gap.” An earnings gap is different from a wage gap in that an earnings gap means that women do tend to make less than men, but it has nothing to do with men and women doing the same exact work or job (Perry). Moreover, “there is almost no evidence that men and women working in the same position with the same background, education and qualifications are paid differently” (Perry). Previous studies did not take into consideration background, education, and other factors that would make a difference in someone’s wage. On the other hand, it is women’s choices such as what they do for a career, that contribute to them making less money. In the article “Facts and Fallacies about Paycheck Fairness” (2014) by Phyllis Schlafly points out that “there are no gender separations in courses of study, and students can freely choose their major” (196). People choose their majors, which in turn contributes to what careers they may have. As it turns out “women generally choose college courses that pay less in the labor market” (Schlafly 196). If women are picking lower-paying careers it explains why there is gender earnings gap. However, it is not a pay gap since there is not a comparison between men and women working the exact same job. Different jobs pay different amounts, and the amount can differ from location to location. On top of it all in the Time article “6 Feminist Myths That Will Not Die” (2016) it says, “American women are among the best informed and most self-determining human beings in the world” (Hoff Sommers). If American women are so informed one must question why so many women buy into the idea that women are paid less than men. The problem lies in studies that do not take into account critical factors that contribute to women making

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Media Bias: Article Analysis

...However, society is negatively affected when media portrays bias and non-credible information through technology and published articles. There have been several resources on the problem regarding wage gaps due to ethnicity and genders. In the article, It’s Time We Talked About the Ethnicity Pay Gap, Sadiq Khan uses her personal experiences to prove that blacks and women have a more difficult time trying to...

Words: 2404 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Gender Discrimination In The Workplace Essay

...Employee right against gender discrimination is traced back in the 1970s when the Women Rights movements demanded equality. These women, pressed for equal opportunity to the workplace, access to all occupations, to equal pay not just for similar work, but for comparable work. In 1979, the UN adopted the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW).” Despite the fact that the UN World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna confirmed that women’s rights were human rights.” Most people still think that there is gender discrimination in the workplace, and the employees have no right when it comes to these injustices such as gender-based discrimination on pay rise/payment, promotions, professionalism and assigned...

Words: 819 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Silicon Valley's Gender Pay Gap

...it was only after the feminist movement in the 1960s that women really started enjoying equality in law, family life and work environment. Nonetheless, gender discrimination still exists in different forms and it is arguably a very sensitive issue in our society. One piece of writing that tackles this subject is an editorial called “Silicon Valley's Gender Pay Gap Is Actually A Gender Segregation Gap” published on Forbes Magazine website on April 2nd 2015. Tim Worstall, the author, is making a rhetorical argument on why the employment of men and women in Silicon Valley is divided into different sets of occupations, in order to find alternatives that might help solving the issue. At first sight the editorial seems persuasive and well written; nonetheless, at a closer look it evinces several flaws (such as unfounded arguments and instances of hasty generalization) that affect the overall credibility and cogency. The first factual argument of the writing, namely a report showing a significant gender pay gap both in general and specifically within the tech companies (para 1) aims at consolidating Worstall’s thesis; however, since he fails to cite the source, the reliability of his claim cannot be proven and the argument loses its strength. This specific, epideictic piece of evidence is then extrapolated into a deliberative argument when Worstall states that the report might actually depict a segregation of employment fields between men and women: while men are usually found in the...

Words: 777 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Gender Inequality

...December 10, 2012 Gender Inequality: How Women get the Short Stick Gender equality and gender roles go hand in hand in today’s economy. These two concepts complement each other to the extent in which one must know about both to fully understand the capacity of either. Gender roles are roles each sex is given. These are stereotypical things. For example, things like women cook and males work. In todays economy men and women are not equal. Gender inequality and gender roles are one of our countries biggest issues. Gender is how people are seen by society. This is imprinted in the brain at a young age and is formed and molded through childhood, adolescence, adulthood, and late adulthood. Each stage comes with different ideas about gender and power. Childhood is the point in life where the environment most influences the formation of gender schemas and stereotypes. Gender schemas are an important part of understanding how a person sees the opposite sex. Gender Schemas are “the generalizations that children develop about the differences between boys and girls” (Stevenson 3). On the other hand there is stereotyping. Stereotyping is also process that begins during childhood. Young children know that male stereotypes are high in power whereas female stereotypes convey fear and helplessness. Children are influenced by information about gender from family, peers, and the media (Stevenson 3). This justifies the argument that men and women aren’t treated equal. Gender Roles are evident...

Words: 1780 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Law Review

...worked as an administrator for the New Public School District No. Eight (the District). She brought suit against the District alleging gender discrimination for (1) unequal pay, and (2) the non-renewal of her contract. The district court granted summary judgment to the District based upon res judicata and a lack of evidence supporting her claim. We reverse the district court's judgment and remand the case for further proceedings. I. Background 2 Simmons worked as an administrator for the District from 1991 to 1996. On April 20, 1996, after a lengthy hearing, the District voted not to renew her contract for the next school year. Simmons sued the District in state court alleging various claims, including violations of her North Dakota statutory rights as an educator. The state trial court rejected her claims. On appeal, the North Dakota State Supreme Court reversed. See Simmons v. New Public School Dist. No. Eight, 574 N.W.2d 561 (N.D. 1998). On remand, the parties stipulated to an agreement to settle the claims. The settlement, however, specifically gave Simmons the right to pursue the claims listed in the EEOC complaint she had filed against the District. 3 Simmons eventually received a "right to sue" letter from the EEOC, and filed this action in federal district court. She initially alleged1 that her contract was not renewed because of gender discrimination. Before the district court, she...

Words: 2946 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Women's Quota in Norway a Good Pioneer for Germany?

...WOMEN’S QUOTA IN NORWAY - A GOOD PIONEER FOR GERMANY? | Table of Contents 1. Introduction 3 2. Definition Women’s/ Gender Quota 3 3. Gender quota in Norway 4 3.1 The road to the quota 4 3.2 Impacts and Changes 5 4. Gender pay gap in Germany 7 4.1 Causes for the Gender pay gap 7 4.2 gender quota in germany 8 5.Conclusion 9 List of Literature 9 Books/magazines 9 Internet Sources 10 Illustrations 10 1. Introduction The situation for women in every kind of different sectors has changed over the last centuries and decades. Nevertheless the result of an UNO- analysis in the mid 1990’s states that women have not the same chances as men in any society in the world even though that there has been made a huge progress. As Paragraph 1 of Article 3 of the German Basic Law declares, “All persons shall be equal before the law.“ In addition Paragraph 2 of the same article states, “Men and women shall have equal rights. The state shall 
promote the actual implementation of equal rights for women and men and take steps to eliminate disadvantages that now exist.“ In contrast to this Article of the Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) describes that after a study made in 2012 Germany has one of the biggest wage gap between men and women among all countries in Europe. The study says as well that there are fewer women in management positions. This arouses the question “What are the...

Words: 2899 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Racial Pay Bias

...media often acts as a gateway to communicate or gain perspective on different ideas and information. However, media is often misinterpreted, giving the reader a different understanding on the topic then is portrayed. Bias plays a significant part in this misconception, which is why it is important to recognize when reading articles that address problems such as discrimination based on unequal pay in the workplace. For instance, Shafi Musaddique is the author of, “We Need to Address Our Ethnic Pay Gap with Mandatory Reporting – Just as We're Doing with Gender”, an article in which they advocate that the racial pay gap should be equally as emphasized as the gender pay gap. This article can be seen as biased due to the...

Words: 1750 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Dennis Baron's Essay 'How To Be A Woman Programmer'

...essay titled "Facebook Multiplies Genders, but Offers Users the same Three Tired Pronouns" complies of the fact that Facebook has 58 different kinds of genders to choose from, yet the social media site only allows three pronouns: she, he, it. The thesis of "How to Be a 'Woman Programmer’" written by Ellen Ullman is the struggles of a woman becoming a computer programmer and enduring the sexual prejudice of man in the workplace. 2. How do their arguments differ? How are they similar? What are some of the major argumentative points each piece makes? The arguments differ in the way that Baron's essay was merely just nagging about not having more pronouns to identify others, while Ullman's argument is giving first hand stories and experiences to support her claims. The only thing similar about the arguments is that both essays are somewhat about gender issues. An argumentative point that Baron makes in her essay is that Facebook users can now identify as 58 different genders, but their friends can only wish him,l her, them a happy birthday. I love the point that Ullman makes when she states that when she was working as a computer programmer, women stood out in...

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Income and Gender Inequality in Todays World

...INCOME AND GENDER INEQUALITY IN TODAYS WORLD In President Obama 2012 State of the Union, he called it "the defining issue of our time." (CNN). Income inequality is the extent to which there is a distribution of revenue unevenly among the population. Unfortunate this creates a gap between the rich and everyone. It also gives the idea whether income distribution is fair or unfair. Income inequality is growing in the market day by day, and it is calculated based on the population present in the economy. The United States has a comparatively high level of income inequality results from labor market changes, changes in household composition, the shift from industrialized employment to high paying technical services jobs, and lower paying retail trade jobs. The argument has deliberated by some who say that in one way, income inequality can fuel economic growth. According to their argument, a greater portion of the rich's income is not spent on consumables, but instead, they are likely to save and invest more (AAUW). As a result of this, there is predictable economic growth due to the increased investment made by those with high incomes over the years. Income inequality is viewed by most people to be a result of government policies that impact the distribution of revenue among its population (AAUW). Gender income inequality is the gap between the income of men and women among the people in the economy. It is the average difference between male and females aggregate hourly income. Through...

Words: 820 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

30 Mark Paper- Sociology

...Social Inequality essay plans for Part b) 30 mark question Evaluate the usefulness of sociological explanations of ethnic inequalities.(30) Evaluate the view that society is institutionally racist (30) Adapt according to question given Introduction Ethnic inequalities are still significant in the UK – give a few examples. Suggest some explanations e.g Racism, Institutional racism, social class of ethnic minorities (Marxism), welfare dependency (New Right). This essay will identify and assess these explanations. AO1 Define types of Racism e.g Barker and new racism, institutional racism – McPhearson report on murder of stephen lawrence – racism in met police. Jenkins suggests recruitment to jobs is more word of mouth and disadvantages ethnic minorities. Modood 1994 28% of african caribbean people surveyed said they felt they had been refused a job on grounds of race. AO2 There are many government acts such as Race relations acts which should prevent discrimination AO2 However because racism is implicit (hidden) now it can be difficult to prove in court. AO1 Marxists such as Westergaard and Resler argue that race is a distraction from the real issue which is social class. It is capitalism which disadvantages certain groups and ethnic minorities are more likely to be in lower classes. AO2 However this ignores the existence of racism in society e.g in education where black boys have the highest exclusion rates in school. AO1 Another marxist explanation by Castles...

Words: 5292 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Should Audits for Pay Gender Be Required of Eeoc

...Should EEOC Audits be required for Gender Pay Equality for Employers with more than 100 Employees? The year 2012 statistics show that full-time employed women earned just 80.9% of the salaries of their male counterparts in the United States. The number for 2011 was 82%. The pay gap is now as wide as it has been since 2005, following on the heels of six years of progress. The figures look even worse for some workers. In management professions, men earn $1,328.00 each week while women earn $951.00– A 71.6% gap, for financial professions, it’s 74% and in legal occupations it is 53.7%, (Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2012). Based on this information, a man would make $100.00 compared with a woman making just $80.90... The financial services employed male would make $100.00 compared to only $74.00 for the female (based on Bureau of Labor Statistics)... Employers are not complying with the current EEOC laws as the pay gap is becoming wider, especially in some professions. The EEOC law should be changed to require them to conduct audits of employers with more than 100 employees, to assure compliance with the law. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 was updated in 1963 when congress passed the Equal Pay Act, clearly stating that employers cannot discriminate on the basis of sex by paying wages for equal work less than wages paid to the opposite sex. The problem is that the EEOC who administers the law is a reactive rather than proactive body. They...

Words: 1857 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...this because of the high staff turnover, the inconsistent pay rates compared to the market, because of the different pay rates for male and female workers, and also because there is no mechanism of communication to address employees’ problems regarding wages and salary. They need this formal salary structure because there is no employee involvement in setting up salary structure, and there is no job evaluation committee. Also, this structure is necessary to be able to evaluate the relative worth of each job compared to key jobs, to categorize, rank jobs into rate ranges, to ensure there’s no discrimination in terms or gender, race and religion, and to make sure that the salary is related to the employees’ performance and capability. 2. Paying 10% more attracts more applicants to this job. Jack believes that it provides employee loyalty and reduces turnover. The problem with this is that it makes employees loyal to high pay rate and it reduces the turnover for only those employees who only concern about the salary rate, however indirect financial payments and other factors also influence the employee’s turnover. 3. Carter’s male-female differential is not wise in my opinion. The salary should be based on performance, and not gender. This disobeys the Equal Pay Act, and it doesn’t maintain individual equity. It is discrimination against female workers. His pay plan is inefficient. It can create conflict and arguments between female and male workers, since it’s not fair....

Words: 377 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Introduction to Management

...in a modern economy. Because traditionally thought that in terms of their technical aspects in many front line service job is low skilled , then actually suggest as form of skilled work since they require their employers to perform skilled emotional labor in their dealing with customers ( Bolton, 2004, Korczynski ,2005). Thus , According to Payne, he seeks to open up a critical discussion of the opinions and the key arguments of those authors who look a view the emotional labour as a form of skilled works in his article “ Emotional Labour and Skill : A Reappraisal “ was published by 2009 . Transfer to another aspects between gender and work, Leidner (1988) feels that the gender typed interaction is an expression of workers in their occupation. So, he did analysis of two highly routinized interactive services job “Serving Hamburgers and Selling Insurance”. This article explores the interrelationship of work, gender and identity. In this paper, we will have a critique in the main points of the two articles about emotional labor and skills, and the difference gender in the routinized interaction. Firstly, According to Payne (2009), the ability of front –line staff to perform emotional work, whether it takes the forms of enthusiasm, politeness or remaining calm under pressure, is seen as making a vital contribution to customer satisfaction and competitive advantage ( Heskett ,1997) .As a evidence, the readers also permit that today, for many front-line service employees such...

Words: 1457 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Discrimination

...Job Discrimination: Its Nature * Discrimination in its root meaning refers to the act of distinguishing one object from another. * In modern usage, the term refers to "wrongful discrimination," or distinguishing among people on the basis of prejudice instead of individual merit. * Discrimination in employment involves three basic elements: * It must be a decision not based on individual merit. * The decision must derive from racial or sexual prejudice. * The decision must have a harmful impact on the interest of employees Forms of Discrimination: Intentional and Institutional Aspects * Discriminatory acts can be categorized according to the extent to which they are intentional and institutionalized. * An act may be part of the isolated behavior of an individual:  * Intentionally discriminates based on personal prejudice. * An act may be part of the routine, institutionalized behavior of a group. * The act must intentionally discriminate out of personal prejudice. * An act may be part of the isolated behavior of a single individual who unintentionally discriminates because he or she uncritically adopts the practices and stereotypes of his or her society * An act may be part of the systematic routine of a group that unintentionally discriminates because group members uncritically incorporate the discriminatory practices of society. Discrimination: Its Extent * Discrimination exists when a...

Words: 1388 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Random Article

...Article The economic arguments for gender equality are overwhelming - but stereotypes keep getting in the way of progress. Women have never been in a stronger position to lead, change and shape the economic, social and political landscape. The 21st century has seen a dramatic shift in "traditional" family dynamics and greater recognition of gender in legislation has helped pull apart gender-role divisions. As a result women are far more economically independent and socially autonomous, representing 42% of the UK workforce and 55% of university graduates. Yet women are still less likely than men to be associated with leadership positions in the UK: they account for 22% of MPs and peers, 20% of university professors, 6.1% of FTSE 100 executive positions, and 3% of board chairpersons. This stark inequality is consistently reflected in pay gaps, despite the introduction of the Equal Pay Act in 1975. Income inequality has risen faster in the UK than any other OCED country and today women earn on average £140,000 less than men over their working careers.  In recent reports 2.4 million unemployed women said that they want to find employment, and nine out of 10 people want to see men and women equally represented in leadership positions. If the intention to change is there, and basic social and political frameworks support women in the workforce, then we need to look beyond facts and figures to establish what other factors contribute to the gaping hole in gender equality. While statistics...

Words: 794 - Pages: 4