Free Essay

Increase Mental Health Care Funding

In:

Submitted By ashleytopp
Words 1630
Pages 7
United States Department of Health and Human Services: As our country struggles through tough times there is no doubt we, as a whole nation, have had to make some compromises. One of the biggest, broadest issues our country has been facing is the recent budget cuts in numerous different categories including mental health care. Mental health care has gotten the short end of the stick in the last few years, and it has become a spiraling problem in the United States. Between 2009 and 2011 the United States witnessed some of the largest state budget cuts in history, and we are still suffering from the consequences of doing so. Where does a majority of homelessness, suicide, substance abuse and jail overcrowding stem from? If you take a closer look it will become very clear that cutting the funding for mental health research and treatment has left these mentally ill patients with very few options suitable enough for their varying conditions. Due to the lack of appropriate facilities needed to properly diagnose and treat mentally ill patients, jails are becoming overcrowded and homelessness is at an all-time high. The importance of mental health care is being put on the back burner while, instead, it needs to be a priority and that is why President Obama’s proposition to increase funding to aid the mentally ill in 2014 is extremely necessary. As states cut mental health care funding, prisons are becoming an asylum. There is a very common misconception among the general public that mentally ill individuals are extremely violent, however, this statement has proven to be very false. The unfortunate truth is that this stigma blossoms from the fact that, these days, jails have become one of the few places that will take the mentally ill patients in. As the economy dries up funding to make professional help and proper medication easily accessible, patients have become the responsibility of law enforcement. Los Angeles county sheriff, Lee Baca says that “more and more mentally ill people end up in jail when they’re not getting the help they need.” Police logs in many cities support Sheriff Baca’s statement by reporting that mental health crisis calls have increased an average of 34.5% in the last four years. As a result of funding cuts, an estimated 15 to 20 percent of inmates have a serious mental illness. Long story short: These patients should not be put in prisons and jail cells. Guards are not doctors and bars and restraints are not medicine. President Obama’s proposition to increase funding for the mentally ill is an essential stepping stone to not only provide these people with proper treatment, but also relieve a lot of problems including the overcrowding of jails. Not to mention, cut the costs substantially of the utilities used to treat these patients in the prisons. Why is it so important to keep the mentally ill out of jail cells? As individuals, somebody with a serious mental illness needs to be properly diagnosed and treated. Without doing so, the person’s condition will only escalate and it will become a dangerous cycle. From a sociological viewpoint, the funding going towards jails and prisons could be reduced significantly if we can remove the mentally ill “prisoners” and put them in a hospital where they need to be. Why are we overfilling the cells with sick people instead of keeping room for the true criminals? President Obama’s proposition to increase funding to mental health will provide patients with access to professional help and clinics and medication rather than ignoring the core issues of a mental illness and just keeping them behind bars. Homelessness is another factor that becomes a part of the “dangerous cycle” that occurs when an individual doesn’t have access to the proper facilities and treatments. Between 2009 and 2012, states cut a total of $4.35 billion in public mental health spending. What do all of these budget cuts result in? States are being forced to close a majority of their psychiatric hospitals and clinics due to lack of funding. Similarly, the clinics that still exist have become so expensive in order to compensate for the lack of funding that they are essentially inaccessible to a huge majority of lower and middle class patients. Where do adults with mental illnesses go who don’t have money for medication and therefore can’t possibly manage a household or a high stress job? If they aren’t in jail, they are most likely on the streets living as homeless individuals. Studies show that one in three homeless people have untreated mental illnesses. The National Coalition for the Homeless states that “Serious mental illnesses disrupt a person’s ability to carry out essential aspects of daily life such as self-care and household management… As a result, people with an untreated mental illness are much more likely to become homeless than the general population.” In states like Hawaii and Virginia, 60-70% of homeless people also have a mental illness. The most interesting thing about the budget cuts that left these sick people on the streets is that they have actually backfired. In the long run, it costs less to treat people appropriately than to pay for the public services that homeless people with mental illnesses use such as shelters and emergency room services. With President Obama’s proposition to provide more funding to mental health care, the nation can establish “supportive housing” and mental health services that will get people off the streets and actually save money. Supportive housing is the idea of affordable housing, medication and treatment facilities made available to people with mental illnesses. In Portland, Oregon 35 chronically homeless people with mental disabilities used roughly $42 thousand each in publicly funded resources per year. After put into a supportive housing program, the city saved $16 thousand dollars per participant. On a larger scale, New York studied ten thousand homeless individuals with mental illnesses and found that each person used $40,449 per year in publicly funded services such as emergency rooms, hospitals, prisons, shelters and incarceration. After being placed in supportive housing there was an 86% drop in the number of homeless shelter days per person. There was also a 60% drop in state hospital use and 80% drop in public hospital inpatients per day. Similarly, the rate for incarceration was cut in half. With more funding going towards mental health care, our nation can save money, save resources and give these patients a chance to be successful members of society instead of sitting on the streets without any help. I understand that money doesn’t appear out of nowhere, and when funding towards mental health care is proposed it means that other resources’ funding are cut. One could argue that pulling money out of America’s homeless shelters, emergency rooms, prisons and hospitals would be unthinkable. The mentally ill are not the only ones in hospitals and jails. What about the little kids that break their ankles at soccer practice, wouldn’t their emergency room trip suffer because there isn’t enough money? Homeless shelters put a roof over the head of thousands of people who aren’t necessarily sick, but are going through some of the hardest struggles they have ever faced in this tough economy. The wonderful thing about the proposition to increase funding to mental health care is that it would be a win-win for all of these different categories. Once a sturdy foundation is built for mentally ill patients to attain affordable housing and treatment, the nation will no longer need to put so much money into hospitals, jails and shelters for them to continue to operate successfully. In the New York study of ten thousand homeless individuals, the number of emergency room patients and shelter days dropped so significantly that, if supportive housing was put into place on a national level, those public resources would be left with an excess of funding. The money is already there for mental health care, it is just being poured into prisons and shelters and other safety nets because of the increasing number of mentally ill people using those resources. If the money that mentally ill individuals use on publicly funded resources is directed specifically to mental health care, no other resources will struggle. Instead, our nation will find the balance it has been looking for in the cases of overcrowded jails, emergency rooms and homeless shelters. Preventative treatment and care to keep the mentally ill out of shelters and jails would save the nation money. Supportive housing would help these individuals make a better life for themselves and become a contributing member of society. Lastly, support, treatment and medication will be easily accessible even for those who are in the lower class. For these reasons, President Obama’s proposition to significantly increase funding for mental health in 2014 would help the nation get back on its feet.
Sincerely,
Ashley

"NAMI - The National Alliance on Mental Illness." NAMI. National Alliance on Mental Illness, n.d. Web. 18 May 2013.
Hoffman, Piper. "More Mentally Ill Becoming Homeless Because States Won't Help." Truth-out.Org. Truthout, 06 May 2013. Web.
Mukher, Jee. "As States Cut Mental Health Care Funding, Prisons Are Becoming Asylums." ThinkProgress RSS. ThinkProgress, 07 Mar. 2013. Web. 18 May 2013.
Clarke, Toni. "Health Budget Spends on Mental Health; Cuts Medicare." Reuters. Thomson Reuters, 10 Apr. 2013. Web. 18 May 2013.

Questions:
1. How is my organization? I combined the opposing argument and the “rebuttle,” does this work?
2. Does my work seem credible? Any grammatical mistakes, spelling errors or work cited problems?
3. Is there anything I can add? A specific point from an outside view? My word count is okay, but I feel like another body paragraph would be helpful I’m just not sure what it would be.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Funding Health Care Services

...Assignment 4: Funding Health Care Service Strayer University HSA 500 November, 2013 Introduction The essential business of the health care industry is the delivery of health care services. In the U.S., the health care industry is considered to be the largest service employer. Funding for the U.S. health care services consists of a mix of public and private payment sources. Medicare and Medicaid represent the two major health programs. Funding for Ambulatory Services The use of Ambulatory Care Services is common amongst most people. It has become an important element in the delivery of health care. For many, it has been viewed as the primary source of health care; offering an extensive range of services that don’t require overnight hospitalization. The services offered can be as complex as tests to and therapies or as simple as a minor cut. Traditionally in the U.S., ambulatory care services were provided in the offices of medical practitioners and in the homes of the patients. Presently, these services are performed in outpatient clinics, emergency rooms, and same day surgery centers. Ambulatory care has expanded within the health care system. This is due to the fact that it is less expensive than inpatient stays and less time consuming for patients. In comparison to inpatient patient procedures, outpatient procedures have been estimated to be 30% to 60% less in costs. Funding for Ambulatory care services began when the first surgical care center opened in...

Words: 951 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Changes in Approach to Mental Health/Illness Within Australia

...changes in approach to mental health/illness within Australia from the 1970’s to the 1990’s. You will need to include at least three (3) government enquiries/investigations which have helped shape government direction in the provision of mental health services. A Federal Government Inquiry released in the same year as the 1955 State Grants (Mental Institutions) Act provided large amounts money to institutions for capital works, was damning of the ‘inadequate’ mental health system, highlighting low standards of care, abuse and overcrowding (Stoller, 1955). As a result of this, there was a wider general interest in mental health. In what could be the beginnings of deinstitutionalisation in Australia, as the report also called for an increase in community services. Funding provided by the government in the seventies was pivotal to the establishment of community mental health services being more assessable with outreach and after care programs being setup in hospitals. This also heralded the beginnings of many Non government and independent services. * In 1983, the Richmond Report, release in New South Wales, advocated strongly for further deinstitutionalisation and an increase in community services for people with psychiatric disabilities. It suggested a change in funding arrangements from hospitals to community based care services, the expansion of integrated community based services, the separation of developmental disability services from mental health services and a decrease...

Words: 646 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The American Healthcare System and Access to Mental Health Services

...Access to Mental Health Services Abstract Within the American Healthcare system there are three key components. The key components include access, cost, and quality. Access to healthcare is the ability to obtain healthcare services in a timely manner when one needs it. Cost refers to many things in healthcare. It depends upon the individual, national, or provider’s perspective of costs. Quality is the desired healthcare outcomes of an individual or the healthcare outcomes of the population. Access to mental health services is a major issue in the United States. Children are greatly affected by this and often fall through the cracks in the system. Less than half of all children receive the mental health services they need. The Affordable Care Act initiated by President Obama is setting strides to improve the availability of mental health services within communities. This law requires that all health insurance providers cover mental health services. Congress has also increased funding to improve access of child mental health services. Improvements with access include, but are not limited to, integrating primary care physicians with mental health providers and the expansion of child mental health services. These improvements will educate primary care physicians on the available mental health services in their surrounding communities, allowing them to refer their patients as needed while providing a continuum of care. The expansion of child mental health services...

Words: 2439 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Healthy People 2020

...PLANNING BETTER HEALTH FOR THE FUTURE Margaret Carriger Grand Canyon University Trends and Issues in Health Care HLT-418v Georgeana Lass Drew, Instructor July 12, 2014 In 2010, Healthy People 2020 was started by the Department of Human Health Services. Health programs and research topics were instituted to help Americans live healthier and longer lives (CDC, 2014). The 42 topics presented are all very important in maintaining the goals set by Healthy People 2020. If these programs were to be cut or budget restraints imposed on them, the impact would be felt by all Americans. There would be more unhealthy people, preventable chronic diseases would be more prevalent, and education and health associated programs would be affected. In reading the 42 topics, and after much consideration, I chose the 10 most important that I felt would be impacted. 1. Access to Health Services- The need for accessible health care is vital for the success of health equality and for expanding the well-being of a healthier life for Americans. 2. Cancer- Research and advancements in cancer treatment have seen a decrease in both occurrence and morbidity. Healthy People 2020 advocate the development in cancer research to assess the advances made in decreasing cancer in the United States. 3. Diabetes- One of the most prevalent chronic diseases in the United States. More than 57 million Americans have a high glucose reading or levels that can increase the chances of Diabetes Mellitus...

Words: 969 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Mental Health Care Disparities: Consequences of Ineffectiveness and Lack of Access for Minorities

...Mental Health Care Disparities: Consequences of Ineffectiveness and Lack of Access for Minorities Ebony Marinnie RN Rowan University Mental Health Care Disparities: Consequences of ineffectiveness and lack of access for minorities For ages mental illness has been seen as the ultimate curse. The mentally ill were seen as possessed, hidden from society, and never talked about. In America, it is estimated that 26.2 percent of people ages 18 and older suffer from a diagnosed mental disorder in a given year (Kessler,Chiu, Walters, & Demler, 2005). The aforementioned statistics reflect those that have sought or been forced into treatment. There are many left uncounted due to lack of access and ineffective treatment secondary to a number of reasons. Considering history, discrimination, personal perception, socioeconomic status, educational backgrounds and a host of other reasons many minority groups are reluctant to seek out treatment in what many may consider a system of mental health created and sustained primarily for the middle and upper-class White America. In fact, 60 percent of people with mental illnesses do not receive treatment (Kessler et al., 2005). The purpose of this paper is to discuss mental health care disparities in minority populations within American society, and to suggest some needed changes to close the gap in America. One quarter of all Americans meet the criteria for having a mental illness and a quarter of those have a disorder that significantly...

Words: 2360 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Risks of Mental Health Drugs

...Risks of Mental Health Drugs for Our Youth Rapa Barsel Prof. Stephen Webber ENG 215048VA016-1142-001 February 15, 2014   Although there is a considerable amount of children with mental health disorders, more research and stricter regulations are necessary to investigate the diagnoses and the overuse of prescribing mental health drugs to our children. In our current age of advanced technology, medicine is also advancing. Although, these advances can detect many illnesses earlier on, they may not be an accurate diagnosis for minors. Thousands of children are prescribed antipsychotic drugs without proper medical assessments. I have a two and half year old son and I would not be willing to put him on any mental health drug unless I was absolutely certain it was necessary. These mental health drugs can cause suicidal thinking and behavior. It can also lead to an altered personality, or lack thereof. These drugs can be harmful to brain and physical development in younger children. According to the U.S. Surgeon General (2000), as many as 1 in 10 American children and adolescents a year have “significant functional impairment” as a result of a mental health disorder. The trends in administering psychotropic medication to young children are on a rise in the U.S. Since psychotropic medications are substances that affect brain chemicals related to mood and behavior (NIMH, 2009). These trends have caused a great deal of debate. All parties without an economic agenda agree...

Words: 2127 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

8892

...Analysis of Factors Influencing Adequate Funding of Social Health Care in the Tower Hamlets, London DECLARATION I declare that this is my original work and has not been submitted in any other university or institution for examination. Signature Date Student no: Stud - This is to confirm that the work this proposal was done by the student under our supervision. SignatureDate Supervisor 1: For and behalf of (Name of institution) Signature Date Chairperson, Department of ( ) DEDICATION This work is dedicated to my family members for their enduring support they gave for the whole time I was pursuing this project. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT First, I would like to thank my supervisor .................... who has guided me in writing this project. More particularly my special thanks go to my lecturers for taking me through the whole course. I am also greatly indebted to my fellow students who were with me throughout the course work. OPERATIONAL DEFINITION OF TERMS Class A drugs- drugs deemed by the government to cause the most lethal harm when consumed. They attract heavy jail terms including life in prison. Community care- a term used in healthcare policies to mean looking after people with particular needs in the community. Local strategic partnership- a single non-statutory body, aligned with local authority boundaries that bring together at a local level the different parts of the public sector as well as the...

Words: 17371 - Pages: 70

Premium Essay

Foster Care System Analysis

...Children and adolescents in the foster care system are at a higher risk for psychopathology than other children in the general population in our country. In February of 2015, Senator Tammy Baldwin (D-Wisconsin) and Rob Portman (R-Ohio) introduced the bipartisan legislation to improve foster care services for thousands of vulnerable youth in America. This bill would improve health care and mental health services to children and young people in the foster care system to ensure that effective community-based options are available for them and their families. “Therapeutic foster care, often referred to as treatment foster care (TFC), is the evidenced-informed trauma-informed and highly effective placement of children and youth with serious medical,...

Words: 1283 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Garling Report

...The implications of the Garling Report In order to provide quality of patient care, delivering efficient care is important but also recognising the factors affecting patient care is also significantly important. By identifying the implications of the Garling Report (2008), it enables to recognise problems related with health care system and to have better understandings and abilities to effectively deal with the problems. Accordingly, there are also significant issues affecting mental health, which should be investigated. The major findings and recommendations of the Garling Report will be overviewed and also the nursing and workforce issues will be explored. Furthermore, drug and alcohol abuse and lack of resources will be explored and recommendation for a new Registered Nurse will be drawn. Garling Report (2008) indicates that New South Wales (NSW) public hospitals have one of the better health care systems in the developed world, because they have well-trained, skilled and dedicated doctors, nurses and clinical staffs. On the other hand, NSW health care systems are too often unable to cope with the increasing cost of treatment, sudden increase in patients, and the pressures on a skilled workforce (Garling Report, 2008). Notably, there is a serious shortage of workforce including medical, nursing, and allied health professionals (Garling Report, 2008). Furthermore, there are insufficient experienced clinical staffs who can supervise and guide inexperienced...

Words: 2450 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Mental Health Awareness

...Introduction Mental health is one of components to enhance healthy lives among individuals. According to WHO (2014), mental health can be defined as a state of well-being in which every individual realizes his or her own potential can cope with the normal stresses of life. As Hong Kong is a fast-moving city, people easily feel stressful. In recent years, there are more suicidal incidents occurred in Hong Kong and within Wah Fu Estate. Most of causes of the incidents were related to mental health e.g A 35-years-old man who has mental problem stabbed his wife to unconscious and then jumped from Wah Lok House (鄺福強2014). Therefore, enhancing metal health awareness of individual is important. In the following community assessment report, the focus...

Words: 1804 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

London: a National Healthcare Prospective

...provides an overall impression of the United Kingdom’s health service, inception of the National Health Service, challenges the NHS faces regarding financial sustainability, providing effective and efficient care, and the move towards more privatization . Comparisons are made between the National Health Service and heathcare in the United States across multiple sectors that include acute care settings, skilled nursing facilities, primary care providers and regualtions governing nursing practice and the challenges faced by both systems. Table of Contents Introduction 4 Background 4 Impression of the NHS 5 Mr. John Smith Director, Civil Eyes Research 7 Mr. Andrew Cheesbrough, CEO Orders of St. John Care Trust 8 Mr. Robert Creighton, Transition Director and Government Advisor on Public Health 9 Dr. Elizabeth Fellows-Smith. Senior Policy Advisor, Mental Health 10 Dr. Rodney Taylor, Former Medial Director NHS Hospital 12 Professor Simon de Lusignan, Primary Care 12 Mr. Bernell Bussue, Director of London Region,Royal College of Nursing 12 Mr. Paul Holdom, CEO The London Clinic 14 Professor Duncan Empy, Group Medical Director of BMI Healthcare 14 Shirley Kramer, Chief Executive Institute of Healthcare Management 16 Strengths and Weaknesses 16 Summary 17 References 19 Introduction Since its inception in 1948, the United Kingdom’s National Health Service (NHS) formed an ideology that gave birth...

Words: 4846 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Hoarding and Squalor

...of ‘Hoarding and Squalor’ so as to bring awareness on the impact of this condition on the individual, families and the wider community. I analyse the issue of ‘Hoarding and Squalor’ by using existing evidence anecdotal evidence through studies on the impact and consequences this issue at micro and macro level. Further I will demonstrate the associated current social policies around this problem by incorporating a combination of techniques with the aim of advocating for better supports and systems. My overall aim is to bring about a change, in particular around three goals. These goals are inclusive of Social Policy review, multi-agency approach and trans-disciplinary delivery, funding request from the State Government in particular Families and Communities Services (FACs) and Mental Health in order to work with families in a person [spelling error] cent[e]red, strength based manner to ensure sustainable results. I incorporate Jansson’s steps of, diagnosing the context to identify contextual constraints and opportunities, softening the context to make it more amenable to a specific policy initiative and lastly activating change to get a decision maker or legislator to put an issue on the agenda of the other decision makers in the agency, community or legislative setting. (Jansson, 2003, pp. 148-165). Diagnosing Context What is Hoarding and Squalor In May 2013, for the first time ‘Hoarding Disorder’ was defined, and included in a new chapter of the Diagnostic and Statistical...

Words: 3657 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Improvement Health Care in Australia

...Australian Health Care system is a continuous process and the system change will affect all consumers from all background as well all health professional. Rural and remote areas health care: The shortage of healthcare professionals in rural communities is a global problem that poses a serious challenge to equitable healthcare delivery. In Australia rural areas are underdeveloped in most of these areas (rural and remote areas). About one-third 32 per cent of Australians live in rural and remote areas 29 per cent in regional areas and 3 per cent in remote areas (AIHW, 2008a). Persons in rural communities can suffer more chronic health due to the lack of health care services in rural areas. My review discusses an overview of and the lack of services within these communities. As stated in the a discussion papers on Primary Health Care (www.health.gov.au), geographical location accessibility to and availability of appropriate health services and rural and remote environments including socioeconomic status, lifestyles, and are undoubtedly the hallmark characteristics of rural and remote Australia. The lack of distance and transport are major problems to accessing health care for many rural Australians. Health care systems servicing the needs of rural and remote Australians cannot be seen apart from the transport system that either takes services to the people or brings patients to those services. Health transport may be required at different points within the health care system...

Words: 1270 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Argyle Diamonds

...Michelle Ainsworth There are calls for more funding to be put into the mental health system. Mental health advocates fear more lives will be lost if more support is not given to the sector. Transcript LEIGH SALES: The battle over scarce government dollars is in its final weeks ahead of the Federal Budget on May 10th. The Cabinet met today to discuss what's in and out and tomorrow night, the Prime Minister will set out her framework for what's already being sold as a tough budget. Mental health advocates are concerned that promises to support their sector might not materialise. They say more lives will be lost unless billions of dollars in extra funding goes to mental health. Michelle Ainsworth reports from Canberra. DR ELIZABETH SCOTT, CLINICAL PSYCHIATRIST: I think the mental health system in Australia at the moment is really at a crisis point. PAULA KNOWLES, MOTHER: It is a parent's worst nightmare. PROF. IAN HICKIE, BRAIN & MIND RESEARCH INSTITUTE: We know what to do, largely when to do it, but our shambolic system fails to deliver that for people in the greatest need. BRONTE O'BRIEN: Life was incredibly confusing and incredibly overwhelming and I found myself trying to mask my feelings through using drugs. KEVIN RUDD, FORMER PRIME MINISTER: We need as a nation to live our game. JULIA GILLARD, PRIME MINISTER: I want to be absolutely clear about this. Mental health will be a second term priority for the Government...

Words: 3080 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Obamacare Disparities

...determine what parts of the Affordable Care Act can apply to Puerto Rico and the impacting the Medicare, Medicare patient services and employees. Most of the people in the island think that the Affordable Care Act is giving more security and help to address the existing disparities in the healthcare system. With the new Patient Protection & Affordable Care Act, the insurance companies can no longer drop the coverage if one becomes sick, bill individual into bankruptcy because of an annual or lifetime limit, and they will not be able to discriminate against anyone with a pre existing condition. Most of the Medicare and Medicaid community suffers do to the imbalance in our healthcare system this situation affects the quality of care and places a financial strain on the government, individuals and families, employers and employees, and public and private providers. Most of the Medicare beneficiaries have to enroll in the MA program to help them to succeed and receive the adequate treatments without MA to help the disadvantaged seniors on the island, Puerto Rico's elderly citizens will be forced to turn to Mi Salud in larger numbers. Although Mi Salud is scheduled to receive an average of $690 million annually during the next five years, the widening deficit in MA funding is likely to create a net negative impact on federal funding for healthcare in Puerto Rico. The Health care Policies and Issues Ethical concerns and issues The Affordable Care Act (ACA) policies are intended...

Words: 10927 - Pages: 44