Premium Essay

Managing Deviant Behavior and Resistance to Change

In:

Submitted By bmfazekas
Words 3588
Pages 15
I. INTRODUCTION

Constructive deviance is becoming increasingly important in businesses today. What some people may not know is that it can bring about positive changes. Unlike much of the literature on workplace deviance which focuses on dysfunctional behavior such as antisocial behavior and workplace aggression, constructive deviants are employees who break the rules and norms but intend to benefit the organization. These individuals can play a key role in creating an organizational change and serve as future change agents. Given the increasing discussion on health care reforms, this paper explores the factors that relate to constructive deviance among physicians. Finally, practical implications and future research directions are discussed.

II. Introduction

Workplace deviance has generally been used to describe the following behaviors: antisocial behavior (Giacalone & Greenberg, 1997), workplace aggression (O’Leary-Kelly, Griffin & Glew, 1996), organizational retaliation (Skarlicki & Folger, 1997), and employee deviance (Robinson & Bennett, 1995). Although previous research has increased our understanding of the harmful effects of deviance within organizations, little research has examined the positive aspects of deviance. Constructive workplace deviance encompasses behaviors that violate significant organizational norms in order to contribute to the well-being of the organization (Galperin, 2003).

Constructive deviance is becoming increasingly important in businesses today because constructive deviants can bring about positive changes. Unlike much of the field of organizational behavior which focuses on managerial dysfunctions, such as resistance to change (Luthans, 2002), constructive deviants can play a central role in facilitating organizational change. Given the increased interest in healthcare reforms in the United States, we

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Postmodernism

...organizations. Postmodernist built their structure of organization on a horizontal level of hierarchy and they perceive power and control are integrated in everyday social relationships and organizational practices (Hatch & Cunliffe, 2006). Postmodernist applies the concept of disciplinary power that was developed by Michael Foucault, a French philosopher. According to Foucault (1980), the concept of disciplinary power causes employees to engage in a self-surveillance behavior due to the anticipation of control and the self-disciplinary behavior which is view by the postmodernist as a discourse of power within the organization. He believes that disciplinary power is constantly moving and asymmetrical as a group or a person getting advantages position in the process. Information technology has introduced new form of surveillance that allows individuals to exercise discretion and at the same time intensify on control (Swell & Wilkinson 1992). These technologies control the individual’s bodies, identities, performance and behavior. They seek to ensure that...

Words: 379 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Individual Report

...Feinstein Graduate School Managing Resistance to Change in Leadership Individual Report Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the MBA Degree Course: MGMT 5800 Effective Leadership Dr. Ron A. DiBattista Maheshwari Vansadia January 7, 2013 Summary In today's continuously changing environment organizations are subject to multiple changes that can be related to the organization's strategy, its structure, the employed technology and even more its employees (Desler 2007). Traditionally, managers and individuals with relatively higher positions in the organization are the ones who initiate change. They perceive it as being an opportunity to better serve the organization interest, enforces its mission and enable gaining competitive advantage over its competitors. However not all changes are successful. Managers with a traditional approach to change usually link change failure to “change recipients” resistance to that particular change (Ford, Ford & D'Amelio 2008). As defined in the online Oxford Dictionary « resistance is the refusal to accept or comply with something ».Thus, resisting to change implies stopping this change and preventing the organization from a forward progress. Change implies moving from known to unknown. The fear from losing its benefits, position, status is the main reason beyond resistance to it. Individuals would only accept and comply with an initiated change if it has a positive effect on...

Words: 1332 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Litzky, Eddleston & Kidder, 2006

...Managers Inadvertently Encourage Deviant Behaviors by Barrie E. Litzky, Kimberly A. Eddleston, and Deborah L. Kidder* Executive Overview Recent estimates of the costs associated with deviant behavior in the workplace are staggering. While part of the managerial function requires the establishment of rules and policies that promote good customer service and product consistency, managers who lead with a firm hand or place too much pressure on sales quotas, may be unknowingly contributing to their employees’ deviant behaviors. Managers must learn to identify the role that they play in triggering employee deviance. Once recognized, there is much that managers can do to ameliorate the triggers that encourage otherwise honest employees to engage in deviant behavior. M “I wouldn’t say what I did was unethical. Rather, it was more, say, questionable. But hey, my manager says, ‘The customer is always right.’ So basically, I was following her orders.” “Come on – everybody does it. It’s almost expected. I bet even my manager did it when he had my job.” “Considering how much money I bring into this place, I deserve it. They should be paying me more anyway.” anagers often face employees like these who try to justify their actions after being caught behaving inappropriately. Some managers may terminate these employees in an attempt to rid the organization of such unscrupulous individuals. But personality alone is a rather poor predictor of deviant behavior.1 In fact, 60 percent of all...

Words: 8340 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Reviewer for Soc Sci 1

...Reviewer for Social Science 1 A. Introduction Behavior * manner of conducting one’s self * action and response to stimulation * response to the environment Behavioral Sciences * deals with human action and seeks to generalize human behavior in society Psychology * Science of mind and behavior * Behavior and mental process are interwoven Sociology * Science of the society, social institutions and social relationships * Study of human society and social interaction Anthropology * Study of human beings and their ancestors through time and space and in relation to physical character, society and culture. * Cultural anthropologist [culture] * Linguistic anthropologist [language] * Archeologist [material artifacts] * Biological anthropologist [origin and evolution] Science * System of knowledge covering general truths [scientific method] Scientific Method * Procedure for the systematic pursuit of knowledge Social Research * Done to gain a body of information which helps us understand behavior and society Quantitative Research * Numeric data and precise statistical analysis Qualitative Research * Nonnumeric information is used to describe * Done as they happen Experiments * Research situation designed to elicit some sort of behavior Field Research * Observe events as they occur * Non-participant observation [without interaction] * Participant observation [with interaction] Surveys ...

Words: 4372 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Conceptual Interests and Analytical Shifts in Research on Rave Culture

...and transformed dramatically. Consequently, their many cultural traits and behaviors have garnered much sociological interest, which mostly falls into two competing perspectives: cultural studies and public health. In this paper, we review what raves look like today compared to their high point in the 1990s. We then discuss how the cultural studies and public health perspectives define raves and have studied them over time, focusing on the “pet” sociological concepts each has sought to advance. Our analysis of these literatures reveals important differences in rave research by country and over time. We end by discussing the politics associated with the shift in rave research. Introduction Society has been greatly influenced by many alternative scenes, subcultures, or lifestyles oriented around music, youth and young adults (Epstein 1998). Some of the more notable ones include the English punk scene in the 1970s- 1980s, the U.S. jazz (1930s-1940s) and hippie scenes (1970s), and the 1990s rave scenes in the U.K. and U.S. From them have come musical innovation, social identity, fashion and other aesthetic nuances, and mainstream and alternative cultural production. Increasingly, sociology has used scenes and lifestyles to investigate and clarify many of the discipline’s fundamental concepts and ideas. For example, Becker (1963) used the 1940s U.S. jazz scene to elucidate notions of deviant identity, subculture, and social control. In the U.K., scholars from the Birmingham...

Words: 9746 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

This Is for Management and Business

...Unit I – Introduction to Organizational Behavior Topics Covered in this Unit: ------------------------------------------------- 1. Definition of Organizational Behavior - Slide ------------------------------------------------- 2. What Managers Do? (Functions of Management, Henry Mintzberg’s 10 Managerial Roles, Katz’s Essential Management Skills) – Slides ------------------------------------------------- 3. Contributing Disciplines to the field of OB - Notes ------------------------------------------------- 4. Challenges and Opportunities for OB - Notes Supplementary Material Contributing Disciplines to the Field of OB Organizational behavior is an applied behavioral science that is built on contributions from a number of behavioral disciplines. The predominant areas are psychology and social psychology, sociology, and anthropology. Psychology’s contributions have been mainly at the individual or micro level of analysis, while other disciplines have contributed to our understanding of macro concepts such as group processes and organization. Psychology: It is the science that seeks to measure, explain and sometimes change the behavior of humans and other animals. Psychologists concern themselves with studying and attempting to understand individual behavior. Those who have contributed and continue to add to the knowledge of OB are learning theorists, personality theorists, counseling psychologists, and most important, industrial and organizational psychologists. ...

Words: 2920 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Intersect Investment Problem Solution

...This new vision has not been realized yet and therefore, the Executive Vice President of Marketing and Sales has been released of his duties and was replaced by Janet Angelo as new Executive VP of Marketing and Sales. A number of reasons contribute to the fact that why the transformation of IIS was not successful and these reasons are (1) no clear communication about how the change should take place, (2) no explaining and reinforcing on why the change should take place, (3) resistance to the change of key personnel, and (4) the goals to achieve were not aligned with the new strategy. No clear communication has been identified by Kreitner and Kinicki (2004) as one of the main reasons why organizational change initiatives fail. The communication of organizational change and no explaining and reinforcing on why the change should take place are critical success factors for organizational change (University of Phoenix, 2008). The resistance to change of key personnel is the result of the different expectations the key personnel has about the outcome of the customer-intimacy model. The urgency of the change has not been communicated clearly and effectively....

Words: 5805 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Managing Change

...1. Introduction The aim for this report is to address the recent issues that happening with Lion Air Indonesia, and how they change by using internal and external drivers that influenced the change intervention. Also, this report will discuss about the change of strategy and tools that Lion Air Indonesia used. As well as the recommendation that the company may consider. 2. Company Background PT Lion Mentari Airlines, also as know as Lion air, is Indonesia’s largest private airline company. Lion air started to operate in 2000 with only one borrowed plane. Furthermore, by stick to the “no-frills”, low-fare flights for underserved and remote destinations, recent years lion air become as indonesia’s largest private airline company, with more than 36 destinations (more than 36 cities in Indonesia and few overseas) Lion air had a bad record of safety flight; recently Lion Air Indonesia places a massive order amount in planes to reduce the rate of accident. In addition, recently Lion Air confronted with drug use among the pilots. 2.1 Situational analysis Based on problems that the company have, the management teams have to look into the importance key areas, such as: Lion Air Indonesia ordered 230 Boeing The Lion air management has reacted regarding bad record of flight safety in domestic flight (6 airplane crashes within 2002 – 2010) because of system of the machine failure. Therefore Lion air finalise 230 Boeing order with Boeing. Co (A. Jeziorsky, 2012). By buying massively...

Words: 2635 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Behavior

...ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR in Greek town Bank Final Course Project GM591: Leadership and Organizational Behavior INTRODUCTION The leadership’s role in an organization is specific in that they should demonstrate four leadership responsibilities directing, coaching, supporting and delegating. These specific responsibilities will not only lead a team but will be effective in the results the teamwork will display. Good leadership practice is a process that is learned and applied. The leader becomes to be more effective and productive as they work to direct and guide their staff towards the mutual accomplishment of goals and objectives. Greek town bank is well known amongst the regular customers for being friendly and personal the atmosphere is always upbeat and relaxed. The employees make the professional setting fun casual and inviting to everyone. At the bank I’m the teller supervisor. I oversea the operational issues and interact with daily customer transactions. I’ve been working in this position for 2 years. Within the last 8 months new management has come on board and changed the entire dynamics of the setting. The environment is cold and quiet, we work in silence and the interaction that customers enjoyed and became familiar with changed when employees left after new management came on board. David J. Prottas in “Relationships Among Employee Perception of Their Manager’s Behavioral Integrity, Moral Distress, and Employee Attitudes and Well-Being”...

Words: 2636 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Michael Foucault

...finishing at École, he held a handful of different positions throughout the 1960s, at French Universities. Later in 1969, he received the upmost and highly respected position of professor of History of Systems of Thought. He worked this position up until he fell victim to AIDS and later died in 1984 (Gutting). One of Michael Foucault's later and most famous writings are Discipline and Punishment: The Birth of the Prison. Published in 1976, this book looks at and studies the genealogy of the modern penal system implemented. That is, prison is the heart of the modern discourse of punishment. Foucault socially analyzes punishment and how changes in power affect punishment. One of the first things this theory focuses on and most essential to his theory is power and the relationship between power and knowledge. Power is essentially a way of managing and controlling people. A set of instruments, techniques, procedures, levels of application, targets, ideas and arguments, are all used to generate...

Words: 1582 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Case Study

...provides examples of faux change and superfluous change. Within this discussion, these areas of change context are considered and evaluated with regard to how they may be identified and resisted. The report also defines and evaluates organisational change and the frameworks within which it may be undertaken. The impact of change is discussed and is followed by an analysis of resistance to change and the factors that may enhance or weaken it. The report then focuses on force field analysis before concluding with the point that although change may be seen as being inevitable, it must be carefully considered and strategically planned and justified before being implemented. Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction 1 2.0 What is Organisational Change? 2 2.1 Definitions of organisational change 2 2.2 Frameworks in which organisational change can be undertaken 3 3.0 Faux Change and Superfluous Change 4 3.1 Faux change 4 3.2 Superfluous change 4 3.3 Case study examples 5 4.0 Impact of Change 6 4.1 Organisational culture and change suitability 7 4.2 Resistance to change 8 Conclusion 9 References 9 1.0 Introduction This report is concerned firstly with organisational change and then with the extent to which a change may be necessary and whose interests may be served by a change process. The case study which provides the background and scenario for the report has two examples where change is instigated by an incoming manager but this change is either not necessary...

Words: 3054 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Document

...QUESTION 1 WHAT DO YOU UNDERSTAND BY STRESS? DISCUSS THE SOURCES OF STRESS FROM THE INDIVIDUAL, GROUP AND ORGANISATIONAL POINTS OF VIEW. Work stress is recognised world-wide as a major challenge to workers health and the healthiness of their organization. Workers who are stressed are also more likely to be unhealthy, poor motivated, less productive and less safe at work. Their organisations are less likely to be successful in a competitive market. Stress can be brought about by pressures at home and at work. Employers cannot usually protect workers from stress arising outside of work, but they can protect them from that which arises from work. Stress may be defined as "a state of psychological and / or physiological imbalance resulting from the disparity between situational demand and the individual's ability and / or motivation to meet those demands." Dr. Hans Selye, one of the leading authorities on the concept of stress, described stress as "the rate of all wear and tear caused by life." Stress in an organisation can also be refer to us the response people or workers may have when presented work work demands and pressures the are not matched to their knowledge and abilities and which challenges their ability to cope Sources of Stress, Factors that cause stress are called "Stressors." The following are the sources or causes of an organisational and non-organisational stress. 1. Causes of an Organisational Stress The main sources or causes of an organisational...

Words: 13286 - Pages: 54

Free Essay

Getting

...International Relations Theory The new edition of International Relations Theory: A critical introduction introduces students to the main theories in international relations. It explains and analyzes each theory, allowing students to understand and critically engage with the myths and assumptions behind each theory. Key features of this textbook include: • discussion of all of the main theories: realism and (neo)realism, idealism and (neo)idealism, liberalism, constructivism, postmodernism, gender, and globalization two new chapters on the “clash of civilizations” and Hardt and Negri’s Empire innovative use of narratives from films that students will be familiar with: Lord of the Flies, Independence Day, Wag the Dog, Fatal Attraction, The Truman Show, East is East, and Memento an accessible and exciting writing style which is well-illustrated with boxed key concepts and guides to further reading. • • • This breakthrough textbook has been designed to unravel the complexities of international relations theory in a way that allows students a clearer idea of how the theories work and the myths that are associated with them. Cynthia Weber is Professor of International Studies at the University of Lancaster. She is the author of several books and numerous articles in the field of international relations. International Relations Theory A critical introduction Second edition Cynthia Weber First published 2001 by Routledge Second edition published 2005 by Routledge...

Words: 74303 - Pages: 298

Premium Essay

Ldr 531 Final Exam Prep

...Managers no longer need technical skills in subjects such as economics and accounting to succeed. B. Managers need to understand human behavior if they are to be effective. C. These skills enable managers to effectively lead human resources departments. D. A manager with good interpersonal skills can help create a pleasant workplace 3) Which of the following is best defined as a consciously coordinated social unit, composed of two or more people, which functions on a relatively continuous basis to achieve a common goal or set of goals? A. Party B. Unit C. Community D. Organization 4) Which of the following is not one of the four primary management functions? A) controlling  B) planning  C) staffing  D) organizing  E) leading 5) Determining how tasks are to be grouped is part of which management function? A. Leading B. Planning C. Controlling D. Organizing E. Contemplating 6) Which of the following is least likely to be considered a manager? A. A lieutenant leading an infantry platoon B. An administrator in charge of fund-raising activities in a nonprofit organization C. A doctor who acts as head of the physiotherapy department at a public hospital D. The mayor of a large city E. An IT technician who enables communication between all of a company’s Employees 7) Which of the following is a reason that the study of organizational behavior is useful? A. Human...

Words: 96939 - Pages: 388

Premium Essay

Resistance to Bulleying in Workplace

...Communication Monographs Vol. 73, No. 4, December 2006, pp. 406 Á433 Take This Job and . . . : Quitting and Other Forms of Resistance to Workplace Bullying Pamela Lutgen-Sandvik Adult bullying at work is an unbelievable and, at times, shattering experience, both for those targeted as well as for witnessing colleagues. This study examines the narratives of 30 workers, some of whom where targeted and all of whom saw others bullied. Their responses paint a complex picture of power in bullying situations that reframe the ‘‘power-deficient target’’ into agents who galvanize a variety of resources on their own or others’ behalf but also place them at considerable risk. In some cases, employees evaluate the abusive situation and quickly resign. Others protest but, if resistance fails to stop abuse, they also leave organizations. The paths of resistance, case outcomes, and dialectic nature of resistance and control are discussed. Keywords: Workplace Bullying; Verbal Aggression; Organizational Communication; Resistance; Power Adult bullying at work is a shocking, frightening, and at times shattering experience, both for those targeted and for onlookers. Workplace bullying, mobbing, and emotional abuse*essentially synonymous phenomena*are persistent, verbal, and nonverbal aggression at work that include personal attacks, social ostracism, and a multitude of other painful messages and hostile interactions. Because this phenomenon is perpetrated by and through communication, and because...

Words: 13535 - Pages: 55