Free Essay

To Fight for What We Are


Submitted By jordanmx631
Words 1679
Pages 7
"To Fight For What We Are Or What We Need?"

People have always had a deep violent nature in their roots as human beings. Although modern American culture tends to suppress this trait, under the right conditions this aggression can be harnessed with positive results. However, before this can happen, eyes must be opened to the realization that life, core values, and everything society has conditioned us to believe is not necessarily the best way to take on the world in which we live. Though its content is both graphic and highly controversial, the film Fight Club is a film that every American man and woman should see. The film tells the story of how “a ticking-time bomb insomniac... and a slippery soap salesman... channel primal male aggression into a shocking new form of therapy.” (FIGHT CLUB) The film is arguably one of the best examples of masterful film making coupled with deep philosophical content and key concepts which analyze modern American society giving new insight to ways of finding purpose and meaning in everyday life.

Without a doubt, Fight Club’s name can easily be misinterpreted to many who hear or read it. While it is easy to assume that the film has nothing more to it than men simply fighting each other, in reality “Fight Club presents an overload of thought-provoking material that works on so many levels as to offer grist for the mills of thousands of reviews, feature articles, and post-screening conversations.” (Review: Fight Club) The film was directed by David Fincher, one of the brightest of modern directors. Rather than filming the movie in a traditional manner, Fincher takes on a “gritty, restless style [turning] it into a visual masterpiece [...] that unfolds in an eerie alternate universe where the melodies of life have the same rhythm as in ours but are in a different key.” (Berardinelli, James) This alternate universe begins in the everyday modern world, as we know it, and evolves into one man’s world of mayhem.

A strong point of the film is that from the moment it begins, the audience is literally “inside” the head of the main character, played by Edward Norton, hearing his thoughts and seeing his imaginations. For the majority of the film he remains nameless, known as the Narrator. After a series of unlucky events supplementing his insomnia, he finds himself living with his new soap-making friend Tyler, played by Brad Pitt. Over the next few months “Tyler teaches [him] lessons about freedom and empowerment, and the two begin to physically fight each other as a means of release and rebirth. Soon, others find out about this unique form of therapy, and Fight Club is born.” (Berardinelli, James) The purpose of Fight Club was liberation, not victory. During one of the fights the Narrator states, “Fight Club wasn't about winning or losing. It wasn't about words. The hysterical shouting was in tongues, like a Pentecostal church... When the fight was over, nothing was solved, but nothing mattered... Afterwards we all felt saved.” (FIGHT CLUB) Fight Club demands that members leave any pride at the door, and often when it is over the members willingly do not bother to pick it back up. This is an example of the arguably controversial, yet incredibly relevant philosophical content of the film.

“According to [Tyler], [Fight Club] is about freeing yourself from the shackles of modern life, which imprisons and emasculates men. By being willing to give and receive pain and risk death, Fight Club members find freedom.” (Ebert, Roger) In order to accept the risk of pain and suffering, one must be free from fear in all its forms. The greatest hindrance, especially in modern times, to the progression of the human race is fear; fear of failure, rejection, pain, losing. The key to abandoning fear is to not fight the inevitable. In order to be free, Tyler says that “First you have to give up. First you have to know, not fear, know that someday you're gonna die... It's only after we've lost everything that we're free to do anything.” (FIGHT CLUB) If one is not afraid to give up everything, than he or she has nothing to lose. To have nothing leaves everything to be gained, while having everything leaves only the fear of losing it all. The single most valuable component of human nature, is the ability to have and cherish dreams. Yet, even these dreams must be evaluated in a “Tyler” manner.

The single most powerful monologue in the film can be applied to modern day life. It pierces deep into individuality and triggers thoughts that many would rather not believe. Tyler opens one of the meetings of Fight Club saying,
Man, I see in Fight Club the strongest and smartest men who've ever lived. I see all this potential. And I see squandering. God damn it. An entire generation pumping gas... waiting tables... slaves with white collars. Advertising has its taste in cars and cloths... working jobs we hate so we can buy shit we don't need. We're the middle children of history, man. No purpose of place. We have no Great War... no Great Depression. Our Great War's a spiritual war. Our Great Depression is our lives. We've all been raised on television to believe that one day we'd all be millionaires and movie gods and rock stars. But we won't. We're slowly learning that fact. And we're very, very pissed off.
Is there a better alternative to fighting? Perhaps for some, but certainly not all. This anger Tyler refers to is the reason that the Fight Clubs thrive. Fighting gives the members a method of releasing this anger that is more potent than any other means. Fincher does an excellent job conveying this brutal reality with some of the most graphic aggressive action ever filmed.

Roger Ebert’s caustic review of Fight Club represents many people’s negative opinion of the film by focusing on its violent nature. Although his review begins by describing the film as being “smart and savage and witty” (Ebert, Roger), he quickly turns calling it “some of the most brutal, unremitting, nonstop violence ever filmed.” (Ebert, Roger) He also does not go for the philosophical undertones of the film. He makes it blatantly clear that he does not care for Tyler or those who join Fight Club. Ebert states,
Is Tyler Durden in fact a leader of men with a useful philosophy? In my opinion, he has no useful truths. [...] None of the Fight Club members grows stronger or freer because of their membership; they're reduced to pathetic cultists. [...] Whether Durden represents hidden aspects of the male psyche is a question the movie uses as a loophole--but is not able to escape through... Of course, "Fight Club" itself does not advocate Durden's philosophy. It is a warning against it, I guess”
Ebert then goes out of line by bashing on a fellow critic’s opinion of the film’s violence:
“ critic I like says it makes "a telling point about the bestial nature of man and what can happen when the numbing effects of day-to-day drudgery cause people to go a little crazy." I think it's the numbing effects of movies like this that cause people go to a little crazy.”
Ebert’s review does hit on the key points, yet I argue that his opinions focus too much on the surface and are unenlightened to the deeper content of the film.

The critic Ebert makes reference to in his review is by James Berardinelli. Ebrert does Berardinelli’s review an injustice by not quoting the whole paragraph from which the excerpt was taken. The actual review reads,
There's no denying that Fight Club is a violent movie. [...] But the purpose of showing all this bloody pummeling is to make a telling point about the bestial nature of man and what can happen when the numbing effects of day-to-day drudgery cause people to go a little crazy. The men who become members of Fight Club are victims of the dehumanizing and desensitizing power of modern-day society. [...] The only way they can regain a sense of individuality is by getting in touch with the primal, barbaric instincts of pain and violence.
If the film had no sound what so ever, then it could be argued that the violent content was a bit extreme. But as Berardinelli points out, the “combined [...] satire, violence, and unpredictable narrative make a lasting and forceful statement about modern-day society.“ (Berardinelli, James) Ultimately, this is the goal of the film and the underlining reason why every American should see it. So if America’s society is so corrupted, what would a “Tyler Durden” world be like? In the film he can be quoted saying:
In the world I see, you're stalking elk through the damp canyon forest, around the ruins of Rockefeller Center. You'll wear leather cloths that will last you the rest of your life. You'll climb the vines that wrap the Sears Tower. And when you look down, you'll see tiny figures pounding corn, laying strips of venison on the empty carpool land of some abandoned superhighway.
Tyler’s goal was to bring humanity back to its roots, back to a time where life was about survival instead of luxury.

I believe that Fight Club is one of the greatest films ever made. Its visual presentation is impressive on many levels and the script strikes encourages the viewer to evaluate his or her own life as well as the society in which he or she lives. While some views expressed in the film will always be debated, the majority of them are undoubtably relevant. At the same time, Fight Club’s graphic content gives Americans a bold and detailed depiction of what can happen when society begins to strip its population of its freedom and identity. With a nation now at war, Fight Club forces us all to take a step back and see just what we as individuals and as a country are truly standing and fighting for.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Port Chicago 50: An Oral History

...Why would someone fight if he knows he is going to lose? Why would someone fight if he knows he is not going to make a change? Why would someone fight if he knows he is going to die in the fight? For black sailors during World War II, this fight was worth it. Courage under fire is what they didn’t need because they had more than enough. Courage under fire means having courage, no matter what. That is what Small and his squad had in the book The Port Chicago 50 by Steve Sheinkin and in the audio recording, “The Port Chicago 50: An Oral History.” These sources describe the events that happen before and after the explosion at Port Chicago. The book is a more effective source for showing the fight for African American’s rights that seemed that they couldn’t win. In the long run they were willing to fight even to the cost of their lives, but to be heroes or to free their...

Words: 680 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Valley Forge Dbq Analysis

... In December of 1777 General Washington of the Continental Army brought me, you, and all of our comrades. We set up camp here in Valley Forge to fight in the American Revolution. You are a soldier at Valley Forge will you quit? Do you want go home and not re-enlist? Do you want to re-enlist and stay to fight? Don’t desert the general if you don’t re-enlist he’ll understand. He is a good man. Listen to what I have to say or listen to Paine to decide. I have decided to not re-enlist for three reasons which are death and sickness,...

Words: 851 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Entering The Other Wes Moore Analysis

...from you is for you to fight for it. The only things that success denies you of are the things you aren’t willing to fight for. Attending The Other Wes Moore: One Name, Two Fate Event, made me realize something that is bigger than I. Mr. Wes said, “in order to be successful in life you have to fight for something that is worth the fight”. Fighting is not something a wise person would recommend doing, but in life, there are some things that are worth the fight no matter what the cost of the battle is. One is going to have to remember, fights don’t really have to be physical. In my life there are a few things-that are worth fighting for, my God, my life, my family, and my education. The most important thing to fight for is my God. My Father usually tells me,...

Words: 561 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

A Fight for Rights

...Sha-Dasha Poe Heather Lowry English 1101 7 November 2013 A Fight for Rights Standing up and fighting for rights within the community is worthless if there are not supporters who believe in the fight as well. Within Tommie Shelby’s “Social Identity and Group Solidarity” he discusses how African Americans must come together and stand up against racial and social injustice. Shelby implies that black solidarity needs to be emphasized more towards the community on how we should be treated equally because we are human and should not be judged based off our race and culture. Race should not limit anyone’s role within the community or deprive them from who they are. K. Anthony Appiah’s “Race, Culture, Identity: Misunderstood Connections” is a perfect example as to why race should not define people as a whole. Appiah believes that we should not be catergozired in these racial groups because it takes away from our nation sticking together as a one. Both authors make it clear that race should not deprive anyone of human rights because every human deserves to have equal rights. Shelby discusses that in order to eliminate the black stereotypical image; African Americans must unite and call upon each other to fight towards racial injustice. Shelby states “Blacks are a people whose members need to work together to bring about their collective self- realization as a people” (585). This statement shows that Shelby strongly believes that African Americans should utilize black solidarity...

Words: 1104 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Hb Jgyujtuyvtuytyugjh

...Chapter 1: Marines Marines and troops have always fought strong and hard. An alien alliance has begun a war with the UNSC. We have fought strong so far, but with the covenant, that can change in about 1 month. We must fight strong and hard in order to min this war. A alien commander called the Prophecy of Truth has been sending a lot of Arbiters and Grunts to the planet Reach in order to collect the materials and items in order to create his most power full weapon ever yet. He has succeeded, but they will not activate the weapon again. We will not let them. The covenant will not last, we will fight until only one alliance is left. The Grunts are annoying messy little things that fight for freedom what the Truth promised them. The Jackals fight for money what the Truth has promised them. The Arbiters fight for help and food and shelter and protection. The Hunters fight for power. The Brutes fight for power and to torture. But we fight, for peace and order. The Arbiters and Brutes have not ever liked each other. The Brutes have always wanted to torture the Arbiters and to kill them. The Jackals carry plasma shields and a lot of them carry Covenant sniper rifles. But there is 1 last surviving sparten after a giant war on a planet. The sparten is called the master chief, sparten 117. The UNSC with the master chief must deffeat the covenant, the Prophecy of Truth, and his ultimate weapon called,...

Words: 260 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Fight the Power

...removed from the "I Have a Dream" Idealism of the 1960s. This movement was pioneered by Spike Lee's film Do the Right Thing, and the civil rights themed song Fight the Power composed by Public Enemy. In the Fight the Power music video, which was also directed by Spike Lee, Chuck D denounces the marches and speeches of the 60s and calls for more radical action, promising that "the young black America... ain't goin' out like that '63 nonsense." The clip documents a large rally in Brooklyn’s, Bed-Stuy against the racially motivated violence that had plagued the city. This landmark song and video are widely considered hip-hop greatest, and helped to mobilize a new youth culture with a civil rights movement of their own. The song became more than just a feature in a movie. Fight the Power means something big, refusing to let racism keep Black African Americans down. Furthermore, it's about not just talking the talk, but also walking the walk (Shmoop). In our dissertation, we will concentrate on why Spike Lee wanted to write Do the Right Thing and the message he wanted to send to America. Then, we’ll move into Public Enemy rising as civil rights leaders for black youth and their aggressive approach for equality along with their composition of Fight the Power. We’ll then shift into text and the meaning behind the lyrics of Fight the Power. In addition, we’ll also focus on the civil rights movement that followed after the song and movie were released and how it became an anthem for black...

Words: 1863 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Fight Club Definition Of Consumerism

...We are a nation gripped by consumerism. We want we we do not need and can ill afford. We are taught that we must attain, the American Dream, gaining things we do not need nor want to build a façade to but on display for others. We want the house, the car, the clothes, the education and more so we force ourselves into debt. While the rich have the ability to play this game, the vast majority of us do not. We must buy these things with a credit card. You want to go to school, go get a loan. You want a house, go get a loan. What about a car, go and get a loan. We keep diving further and further into debt for these things, some of which are necessary for society but, there are many things that we truly don’t need but to keep up with the Jones’...

Words: 1186 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Fight Club Analysis

...Fight Club "There is enough on earth for everybody's need, but not for everyone's greed.” Mahatma Gandhi This quote fits perfectly on me. Even though I have enough clothes to last an entire lifetime, yet I keep finding myself at the mall, buying things I simple do not need at all. And I am not the only one, millions of people is doing the same thing. It is because we need certain things: we desire different certain things. Now what is that problem called? Consumerism. Modern society is based on different things. But one of those things, consumerism, has been growing majorly over the past couple of decades, mainly in America. Americans consume exponentially more than any other country in the world and are the leaders in waste production and It’s not only depression - that is harming the over consumers, it’s also creates lifestyles disease. In many people lives it’s controlling their lives. For a lot of people their main concern is how other people seen. “The things you, end up owning you” – that is a quote from fight club. Fight club is a book/film who shows consumerism at its worst form. The main character is first in the film, completely controlled of consumerism, which is described later in the essay. The book Fight Club is written by Chuck Palahniuk, it was later turned into a film. The Film/book is about a nameless narrator who works for a major car manufacture how can’t sleep. He has insomnia. He stumbles across different types of support groups. They make the...

Words: 1753 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Cesar Chavez Movement Research Paper

...Cesar Chavez, an NFWA leader and civil right activist, who experienced the horrendous condition of Mexican-American farm workers, and determined to fight against the injustices. Cesar devoted his life to Community Service Organization to improve lives of Mexican-Americans along with Dolores Huerta. He planned to form farm workers union, but not until 1964, after the end of the bracero program that the union or NFWA gained more supports. However, multiple strikes formed by the union going nowhere, so he came up with the idea of a pilgrimage to Sacramento to prove the state that they worth more than what they deserved to be. This movement achieved higher wages, no child labor, and safer working condition, but most important was that it gave not only hope but the motivation for all the next generations to stand for what is right. Chavez movement helps us realize the importance of responsibility by taking actions for our future. He strongly believes in human nature of help others when need and not back down by any forces of injustices. He knew the farm growers treated them like trash and it's up to him to take actions against...

Words: 504 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Fight Club Essay

...Fight Club In “Fight Club” by Chuck Palahniuk we follow The Narrator in his problem-riddled everyday life, and his attempt to escape it by fabricating an alternate identity. The essay focuses on themes such as masculinity vs. emasculation, violence and the connection inbetween. Secondly, the essay includes references to the theoretical text “The Crisis of Manliness”. In the text “Fight Club” we follow the unnamed narrator or The Narrator in his daily life at Microsoft. Suffering from relationship problems, self-esteems problems and an insufferable boss, The Narrator has a hard time suffering from insomnia because of this. To handle his problems, he starts a fight club with his alter ego, also known as Tyler Durden. The text uses first person narration, as we see through The Narrators eyes, but also the thought of Tyler Durden, as they are the same person, even though he is written as an independent character in chapter 6. The Narrator and Tyler Durden start fight club as a way to regain their masculinity. This violence begins in the parking lot behind a bar, where Tyler tells the Narrator to hit him. The Narrator is reluctant at first, but gives in. In return he receives a punch to the chest by Tyler. This is the beginning of The Narrators self-realization. The Narrator agrees with Tyler that self-destruction is the way to self-improvement. The Narrator mentions the fight club as not being a solution to his problem, but rather a way to escape from the problems, as mentioned...

Words: 562 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


...about life and how their clans were doing and somehow got onto the topic of merging Awaken and Hostile and seeing what the outcome out be. They named all the positives and negatives of the situation and the merge seemed to look like it was all positive outcomes. After having a pk trip together and hunting some smaller clans in the wilderness, the leaders figured the pk trip went very well and decided to finalize the merge. Two top 20 clans came together to make a clan able to compete with the best, and looking like we were going to be top 5 within the first week of merging. Violent Resolution Leaders - General Shop, Drew Koskey, Viper1500 and Stephen22288 Officers - Cera S6, Jerminator12, Tyler11, Billybagz, Deadmanbjd81 and Lancer 3000 Warlords - Runechamp812, Exp Hog, Dogflogger, Prinz Jao Advisors - Diegosage, Sweetbritt69 The starting officials of the newly merged clan looked to be very experienced to help Violent Resolution’s quest to the top. The first week of being merged was a layed back one, with everyone just getting to know everyone and setting up the forums, IRC channel, teamspeak and a memberlist, which was estimated to be 150+ members (90 hostile, 60 Awaken) but turned out to be at around 110 members. After setting all that up, we decided to start getting some wars to get some experience working as a unit. Our first opponent, Mystic Knights. We had very little experience going into...

Words: 4480 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Creative Writing: Marco's Mistake

...We all run towards Marco. He lies there lifeless. I reach down and close his eyes. Lily sits on her knees crying and Jeremiah sits on the ground, leaning against the wall with his head in his knees. “We are all done. We are going to die in three hours tops,” he says with a shaky voice. I kneel down “What happened?” I ask with tears in my eyes from Marco’s death. “The images. Me and Marco saw images of what’s going to happen. The monster that’s been giving us nightmares. It’s not a giant, it’s not a god, it’s not a titan, and it’s not a regular monster. I can’t describe it. It’s more than evil,” Jeremiah says with tears coming down his face, then he continues “It took five millennia for them to defeat it. It took the gods, giants, and titans five millennia to defeat it. The artifact wasn’t what we thought it was. The artifact holds what the gods, titans, and giants did to defeat it. Now it’s gone,” he says...

Words: 603 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

To What Extent Do You Agree That Fight Club Is an Updated Version of the Great Gatsby That Captures the Zeitgeist of Modernism?

...To what extent do you agree that Fight Club is an updated version of The Great Gatsby that captures the zeitgeist of modernism? The extent to which Palahniuk’s Fight Club bears resemblance to Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby is debatable despite the fact that there are numerous similarities between the two texts in terms of its narrative structure dominant themes and the presentation of characters thus their respective zeitgeist of modernism, both texts have clearly their own mark that make them truly unique. Clearly the extent of the similarities between the two texts cannot be overlooked when Palahniuk stated himself in the Afterword that ‘’Gatsby’s updated a little’’, as both novels have apostolic narratives it can be seen that both reveal the hollow superficial nature that existed within society in both the 1920’s and 1990’s. Fight Club and The Great Gatsby can be contrasted as, Fitzgerald describes Gatsby’s lavish parties, flamboyant suits and mansion to be a template for the narrator’s own existence in ‘Fight Club’. His life is dominated by his IKEA ‘’condo’’ and his own job, which he then finds that he has nothing to live for and is empty inside. He is someone who has ‘’ lost everything’’ and is ‘’ Lost in oblivion. Dark and silent and complete.’’, which also illustrates the impossibility of the American Dream of both novels. ‘’Fight Club’’ thrusts the idea of conspicuous consumption even further as the narrator describes the destruction of material possessions no longer...

Words: 1904 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Why I Am Proud To Be An American Essay That's not America. We are known as people that are fat and lazy and like get things handed to them. We should not be proud of that; we should be seen as the proud, hardworking Americans that our Founding Fathers taught us to...

Words: 562 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


...Robert Jordan- Well the day has come, we have been waiting for this day for a while now. And now that I have a reason to come back alive, it makes this day even more important. Anselmo- We are ready. Pilar- Good luck. Maria- Come back safe. Robert Jordan- Well the day has come, we have been waiting for this day for a while now. And now that I have a reason to come back alive, it makes this day even more important. Anselmo- We are ready. Pilar- Good luck. Maria- Come back safe. Robert Jordan- Don’t you hate when you plan so hard for something and then someone comes along and ruins those plans in an instant? Pilar- What happened?!?! Robert Jordan- Pablo stole the dynamite and detonators! Anselmo- I knew that horse lover couldn’t be trusted! Robert Jordan- Don’t you hate when you plan so hard for something and then someone comes along and ruins those plans in an instant? Pilar- What happened?!?! Robert Jordan- Pablo stole the dynamite and detonators! Anselmo- I knew that horse lover couldn’t be trusted! Pablo Pablo Work: Spanish Professor Born: April 1st Relationship Status: Single Work: Spanish Professor Born: April 1st Relationship Status: Single Anselmo- When are we going to blow up this bridge? Robert Jordan- Patience! We still have planning to do. Anselmo- I suppose… But you’re such a great leader, so I trust your judgment. Anselmo- When are we going to blow up this bridge? Robert Jordan- Patience! We still have planning to do. Anselmo-...

Words: 511 - Pages: 3