Premium Essay

Can a Child Commit a Crime with Criminal Intent?

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By cwhargrave
Words 891
Pages 4
RUNNING HEADER Can a Child Commit a Crime with Criminal Intent?

Can a Child Commit a Crime with Criminal Intent?

Edward W. Hargrave
Forum 3 Case Study
Liberty University
PSYC 210

Can a Child Commit a Crime with Criminal Intent?
Criminal intent by definition means, the intent to do something wrong or forbidden by law…intent refers to the state of mind accompanying an act…it is the outline of the mental pattern which is necessary to do the crime” (Criminal Intent). The question in this situation is whether it is or it is not possible for a child to commit a crime with criminal intent. I believe the answer to this particular question can be found in the argumentation within several of the factors that we have studied thus far in this course. These factors mentioned being biosocial, cognitive, and psychosocial growth.
Introduction
This particular little boy is considered to be in the stage of the ‘play years’, which is when children are between the ages of 2 and 6 years. As a 6-year-old child, his brain has not fully developed. The process of lateralization, which is when both the right and the left sides of the brain are being connected, has not yet been completed. The right hemisphere of the brain is engaged in reasoning, analyzing, and logical thinking and the left hemisphere of the brain is responsible for emotions, constant, and communication. According to the PowerPoint presentation, a child within this stage has insufficient muscle control along with lacking patience and the judgment in certain situations. In this particular case, injury control/harm reduction practices should have been set in motion so that the child would not have had access to the weapon in the first place.
Piaget said that children between the ages of 2 and 6 years were considered to have preoperational intelligence, which means that the child is not ready for logical…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Child Abuse and Neglect to Juvenile Crime

...Child abuse and Neglect to Juvenile Crime TESST College of Technology Juvenile Delinquency September 5, 2012 I believe that maltreatment does influence a juvenile in becoming a delinquent. The juvenile learns that this is acceptable behavior from the people that have the most influence in their lives. Once they realize that this is not a tolerated behavior they tend to act out in all sorts of forms, upon themselves and others. They now hold no fear in defying society.  Maltreatment does have an influence upon delinquent behaviors. "Maltreatment is referred to as the parental behaviors that are considered acts intended to inflict physical or psychological harm and that reflect a lack of concern for the adolescent's well-being, sense of self and social competence." (Kilpatrick, Saunders, Benjamin & Smith, 2003). Maltreatment causes neurological damage, deficits in cognitive socio-emotional functioning, and learning of antisocial problem solving and failure in school. Today's society seems out to punish the delinquents for their behavior. Life at home, their morals and values learned through their parents should also be examined as well. Children are like clay, what is molded and pounded into them hardens and is that way until it is melted and restructured. People need to take into consideration how they were raised and what was taught to them their whole life. Yet, there are exceptions to this. Some children just have problems brought about on their......

Words: 1306 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Can Financial Crimes Be Punished

...Can Financial Crimes be Punished? Throughout the course of the “Great Recession,” there have been numerous calls for more transparency and accountability for financial institutions. The question that has arisen in the past, and must be seriously considered, is how to make financial crimes less enticing to potential white-collar criminals. Whether through more severe punishments or stricter regulations, the country must understand that there is no clear solution in the short-term. Recent calls for stricter punishments of white-collar crimes may not result in less financial crimes. Throughout history, financial crimes have been punished with severity, at times including capital punishment. The Code of Hammurabi, utilized 3700 years ago, called for anyone who violated a financial contract “shall be put to death as a thief” whereas in Medieval Catalonia, a failed banker was required to live on bread and water until they paid back their depositors. Despite this, financial crimes of varying degrees still occurred. In today’s financial world, it is increasingly difficult to prosecute financial crimes. The issue that routinely arises is whether or not the suspect’s conduct was illegal as opposed to simply greedy. Federal prosecutors have consistently explained that they need to prove intent in order to convict financial crimes. In order to facilitate a more consistent prosecution rate of financial criminals, it is essential that federal attorneys utilize creative thinking in......

Words: 613 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Crime and the Affecting Factors of the Criminal Behavior

...Crime and the affecting factors of the criminal behavior Prof. Dr. Ayman Elzeiny First : - Introduction to crime : The information about the crime reaches to the public may be through the newspapers , television programs, films, and novels . Some of us have accumulated experience with crime by having ourselves been victims or knowing others who have been victims, some by being offenders (or at least defendants), or knowing such individuals, and others by being occupationally concerned with prevention of crime or supervision of people found guilty of violating the law . There's many difficulties to offer a wholly satisfactory definition of the crime, a word frequently used and a phenomenon often encountered . For the purposes of scholarly study specifically, the amassing of reliable statistics, development of explanations and theories, and preparation of sound public policy a definition more exact than the mental images held by the public is essential . Crime is a by-product of civilization. Most civilized members of society obey authority and conform to the norms prevailing in their culture. Their obedience and compliance may vary in degree, but law-abiding citizens remain within the limits of tolerance. Crime then is a sociopolitical event subject to the definitions of the society in which it occurs. The social response to crime in terms of treatment of offenders is dependent upon the advance of the civilization and the affluence of the......

Words: 12519 - Pages: 51

Premium Essay

Criminal Law and Cyber Crime

...Criminal Law and Cyber Crimes Sara Bakerink Kaplan University LS311-03RP1 In law there can be different classifications of the same crime, theft for example. The classifications vary state to state as the section code is based on the state. For example in Iowa we do not have a state section code for Larceny. Robbery can be found under 711.1 and burglary can be found under 713.1. However, in other states larceny is listed in the state section code. For this assignment in Unit 3 there are three situations that involve Makoto's laptop computer being stolen. How the theft occurs is the factor that determines the type of crime that is committed. The classifications of theft crimes are larceny, robbery, or burglary. In situation one Sarah sees a laptop unattended on a porch and steals it. Sarah proceeds to show everyone the laptop calling it her own. This type of theft is known as larceny which is a property crime. Larceny is "the unlawful taking and carrying away of someone else's personal property with the intent to permanently deprive the owner of possession." (Miller & Jentz, 2008, p.128) "Note that a person who commits larceny generally can also be sued under tort law because the act of taking possession of another's property involves a trespass to personal property." (Miller & Jentz, 2008, p.128) In situation two Sarah sees Makoto outside with a laptop computer. Sarah holds Makoto at gunpoint and steals Makoto's......

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Limit to Punishment of Children Who Commit Violent Crimes

...Children Who Commit Violent Crimes The numbers of violent crimes committed by children have greatly increased in the last 7 years. “According to the U.S. Department of Justice, approximately 10 percent of the murders that occurred in the United States in 2006 were committed by juvenile offenders. The Department of Justice also reports that the older the juvenile, the more likely he is to commit a violent crime; juveniles aged 16-17 are most likely to commit a violent crime. While the number of male juvenile violent offenders continues to outnumber that of female juvenile offenders, the number of female juvenile offenders is on the rise” (Baker). Children who commit violent crime have common characteristics such as “Narcissism, (the feeling that you are special and superior to everyone else and that other people have no rights), a history of animal cruelty and cruelty to other children, social isolation, repeated defiance of authority and a history of minor juvenile offenses, and unhealthy obsessions with death, violence and starting fires’” (Baker). However, when dealing with minors, it must be taken into account if children should be punished as adults. While many people think that children who commit violent crimes should be punished as adult, I disagree. Jessica Reaves, writer for the Times US, states, “Harsh sentencing acts as a deterrent to kids who are considering committing crimes. Trying children as adults has coincided with lower rates of juvenile crimes. Light......

Words: 919 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Child Criminals

...Child Criminals: Is Punishment or Rehabilitation The Answer? Lisa Perdew Prof. H. Mathers Ivy Tech Community College With the growing number of crimes being committed by juveniles the question of whether punishment as adults or rehabilitation in a youth facility is the better option has never been more relevant. Some say that if a child commits a heinous crime, such as murder, they should be punished just as an adult would be. Others say child criminals are children first and criminals second and that they should receive counseling and rehabilitation in order to give them a chance at a normal adult life. Most states in this country do not have set laws concerning the prosecution and punishment of juveniles involved in serious criminal acts and thus the punishment is determined by the judge of each case. This can, and has, led to some juveniles being punished too severely and others getting entirely too light a punishment. The debate has come to the point of whether there should be a blanket law where in all juveniles guilty of terrible crimes are treated as adults no matter their age or if because of their age, under 18, they should all be treated as children no matter the severity of their crime. Social workers have long been at the forefront of this debate and have very strong opinions concerning these children. Most of them think rehabilitation, or even early intervention, is the better option for these children. Many of......

Words: 1672 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Crime and Criminal Justice

...Crime and the Criminal Justice System Alicia Gilbert CJA/204 October 16, 2012 Bill Keller Crime and the Criminal Justice System Crime is conduct in violation of criminal laws set by the federal government, state, or local jurisdiction for which there is no legal justification or excuse (Criminal Justice Today, 2011, p. 7). In order for society to distinguish criminal acts, two different models are considered: crime control and due process. Crime control oversees the efficient arrest and conviction of criminal offenders, and due process emphasizes individual’s rights through all stages of the justice system. Criminal justice fails society when it fails in either of these two perspectives. There are three different branches of government: legislative, which passes laws; executive, which enforces laws, and judicial which interprets and explains laws. The legislative branch for the federal government is Congress, which is broken down into the Senate and House of Representatives, at the state level, the state senate, and state house of representatives pass the laws, and on the local level, city council passes the laws. The President of the United States is the executive over federal law, the governor is the executive for state law, and the mayor is the executive for local law. Judicial law is interpreted by the Supreme Court at the federal level; states Supreme Court at the state level, and district courts at the local level. There are several components......

Words: 878 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Criminal Law and Cyber Crime

...* Chapter 10: Criminal Law and Cyber Crime * Section 1: Civil Law and Criminal Law * Crime- A wrong against society set forth in a statute and punishable by a fine and/or imprisonment—or in some cases, death * Key Differences Between Civil Law and Criminal Law * Burden of Proof * Civil Case * Plaintiff must prove his or her case by a preponderance of the evidence and must convince the court that based on the evidence presented by both parties; it is more likely than not that the plaintiff’s allegation is true. * Criminal Case * The state must prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt. The prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant has committed every essential element of the offense with which she or he is charged * Criminal Sanctions * Much harsher than civil * Involve fines, imprisonment, probation, and sometimes the death penalty * Civil Liability for Criminal Acts * Some torts, such as assault and battery, provide a basis for a criminal prosecution as well as a civil action in tort, * Classification of Crimes * Felonies * Serious crimes punishable by death or by imprisonment for more than one year * Misdemeanors * Less serious crimes punishable by a fine or by confinement for up to a year *......

Words: 2272 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Should Minors Who Commit Violent Crimes Be Sentenced as Adults?

...(including our children) has the basic civil rights. One of those rights is the right to an equal education. By not enforcing regulations on homeschooling are the rights of the child being violated? While some states regulate homeschool parents by requiring the parent to obtain a state teaching certification, there are still many that don’t require any regulation. Without regulation of schools, whether they be public, private or in the home, we are risking our risking our future to a generation that has little adaptability to our ever changing society. Credible sources expected to use: (Kreager, 2010); (Waddell, 2010) Topic 2: Should minors who commit violent crimes be tried as adults? I have chosen this topic because it holds the future of our children and the future of our country within its laws and courtrooms. The audience for this paper will be Professor Eric Thompson and peers. By treating our children as adults for crimes they commit are we holding them accountable or are we creating “super-predators” out of our troubled youth? Not only are we creating our future criminals, but we are arming them with experience and an education that far exceeds that of a classroom or book. The end result will be a future of violence that will only escalate and end with more deaths, heinous crimes, and an increase in mental health issues, drug and alcohol addiction and eventually the deterioration of our society. Parents, policy makers, mental health professionals and......

Words: 610 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The State Has the Power to Commit Crime and to Legitimate Its Crime. Do You Agree?

...“The State has the power to commit crime and to legitimate its crime” True or False? Green and Ward define State Crime as illegal or deviant activities either undertaken by the state or supported by the state. It includes genocide, war crimes, torture and state assassination, even more so McLoughlin and others identify four categories of state crime; political crimes like censorship, security crimes such as genocide, economic crimes such as violating safety laws and social crimes such as institutionalised racism. Whilst some may claim that the State definitely has the power to not only commit crime but also legitimate it, others such as Stanley Cohen and Zygmunt Bauman argue that this is not the case, stating arguments such as the spiral of denial and neutralisation theory to justify this outlook. Firstly in favour of the statement, the actual scale which state crime can take the form of highly suggests that it has the absolute power to commit and legitimate its crimes. Between 1975 and 1978, the Khmer Rouge Regime in Cambodia under the leadership of Pol Pot murdered over two million people, almost a fifth of the country’s population. Similarly, since 2012, the Assad Regime in Syria has systematically been slaughtering its own people who hold the beliefs against Assad’s leadership. In both examples, the states’ monopoly of violence allows them to potentially have infinite power and resource in committing state crime. Kramer in 2006 notes that there is an......

Words: 1138 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Crime and the Criminal Justice System

...Crime and the Criminal Justice System Victoria Munoz Introduction to criminal justice CJS/201 April 6, 2015 Brenda Barney A society needs law to uphold fairness and to prevent the victimization of innocents. The definition of crime is any conduct in violation of the criminal law of the state, the federal government or local jurisdiction for which there is no legally acceptable justification or excuse. How law in relations to crime, is there is no crime unless a law is written, then broken to become a crime. The most common model of how socialite determines which acts are criminal is Due process and Crime control. Due process is one person’s Miranda rights, crime control arrest as many criminals to get them off the streets to reduce crime rates. The federal, state and the local government make up the government structure of criminal justice system. These three branches make the laws, make them official and decide what is constitutional and what is not. Some believe that crime is on the rise due to economic conditions, family conditions (divorces, family cohesiveness) and the lack of law enforcement help. Some believe that the system is bias and not punishment goes unjustified. The police ensures community safety, they also enforce the law. The courts decide criminal cases and pass down sentence and the corrections carry out the sentences, rehabilitate if needed. The goals of the criminal justice system are deterrence, to inhibit criminal behavior through the fear of...

Words: 397 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why People Commit Crime

...search for an answer to is why people commit crime. Conflict theories such as peacemaking, radical, and left realist criminology all provide adequate answers and solutions to crime. Peacemaking criminology is defined as a movement against oppression, social injustice, and violence. Peacemaking criminology focuses on not only the victim, but the perpetrator. The practice of this theory involves working with the perpetrator, better known as “criminal” in more popular theories, in order to understand the individual’s problems so they can work through them rather than let these issues cause deviant behavior. This theory emphasizes the idea that the American criminal justice system is solely based on violence and oppression, however needs to be based on eliminating social injustices. The theory links crime with suffering, whether it be psychological suffering, or suffering society inflicts upon an individual, or group of individuals. Overall, it is evident that the main objective of peacemaking criminology is to attain peace on the macro level of society. Instead of fighting back to crime, society should go deeper into the underlying factors of crime to understand the cause of deviant behavior in order to prevent it. Radical criminology is a theory that explains the cause of crime stems from socioeconomic forces of society. This theory focuses on society functioning on a micro level, that being the ruling class, rather than society as a whole. Crime and laws are defined and......

Words: 606 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Child on Crime

... Children in crime: Cracks in the country's juvenile justice system By: Annie Ruth C. Sabangan, InterAksyon.com Oct.9, 2011..www.interaksyon.com/article/14780/children-in-crime-cracks-in-the-countrys-juvenile-justice-system MANILA, Philippines – How do you make criminals out of children? Put them in areas where they won’t be able to meet their basic needs for food, water, shelter, health care, education and sanitation. Strip them of their rights to develop and maintain a life of dignity so that they’ll grow up uneducated and unemployed. Mire them in places where there is no solution to despair and destitution. In the Philippines, where the plight of majority of the poor remains largely unaddressed, many places become breeding grounds for youth offenders. While many of these children were able to rise from the rut---proving that poverty isn’t a justifiable excuse for committing crime--thousands of other juveniles have failed to get out of the trap and are forced to break the law primarily to survive. At the Center for Restorative Activities Development and Learning Experiences (CRADLE) in Camp Bagong Diwa, Bicutan, Taguig City, most of the 74 male children aged 15 and above who are accused of crimes come from poor families, mostly from depressed areas in Paranaque, Pasig, Muntinlupa, Valenzuela, San Juan, and Malabon. The place is run by the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) and the Bureau of Jail Management and Penology. “Pinakamaraming kaso ng......

Words: 2120 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Why People Commit Crime

...Bonane, Wini Lhor C. BSCRIM-IV Why do people commit Crime? Crime is an act or omission in violation of public law forbidding or commanding it. Crime occurs every now and then in our society. According to Emile Durkheim, a society is abnormal without the presence of crime. Crime is needed in order for a society to grow. But why do people really commit the crime? What are the factors that affect a person from committing a crime? Some people tend to say that crime exists because of the unending need of a person. Some people do commit crime for survival and some commit because of the influence of several factors. These factors are poverty, peer influence, discontentment, greed and motives. There are several theories that explain why a person commit a crime. Rational choice theory: People generally act in their self-interest and make decisions to commit crime after weighing the potential risks (including getting caught and punished) against the rewards. Social disorganization theory: A person’s physical and social environments are primarily responsible for the behavioral choices that person makes. In particular, a neighborhood that has fraying social structures is more likely to have high crime rates. Such a neighborhood may have poor schools, vacant and vandalized buildings, high unemployment, and a mix of commercial and residential property. Strain theory: Most people have similar aspirations, but they don’t all have the same opportunities or abilities. When......

Words: 381 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Crime and the Criminal Justice System

...Crime and the Criminal Justice System The criminal justice system and the process have molded the laws of the United States to its current existence. The judicial system is designed to punish those who commit crimes against one another and for those who break the laws in other ways. According to Pearson (2012), crime can be defined as conduct in violation of the state, the federal government, or a local jurisdiction for which there is no legally acceptable justification or excuse. Pearson (2012) also states, that “crime” depends on where you are, which means it is a daily routine for society and directly affects a person, place, and any witnesses associated with it. The American criminal justice system has many elements with crime as the major one. In essence, if there were no crime, there would be no need for a criminal justice system. The intention of this paper is to describe the elements of the criminal justice system and the process it goes through to prosecute a criminal. The research conducted will also describe the government structure and its relevance to the criminal justice system, the diverse elements, and the role law enforcement has with aiding society in maintaining social order and guidance. Law enforcement has many levels in America. There are federal, state, local police agencies, with the same goal of stopping crime, arresting suspects, and completing investigations when crimes are committed. Nevertheless, police are accountable for so much more than......

Words: 1118 - Pages: 5