Free Essay

Montana 1989

In: Novels

Submitted By z727629029
Words 1013
Pages 5
Hennessey 1
David Hennessey
Profesor Trump
Writing 130
7 December 2015
Analysis of Racism in Montana 1948
Racism, a mental state that is derived from the divergence of groups, has impacted history through centuries, even in the contemporary world. Racism is a power that can decide the fate of a whole race, or the life of a person. In Montana 1948, Marie, an Indian girl, is a tragedy caused by racism of white people who show prejudice in different levels against Native
Americans. Racism is a theme that the author clearly wants to present in his novel. In this paper I will explore racism and analyze its influence to the plot and characters of the novel.
This novel shows how racism affects individual's behaviors. Among the three people who show racism—Wesley, Julian, Frank—-their prejudice influences the plot in different ways.
Wesley's prejudice to Native is much like an inherent discrimination from a high-status person to a low-status person, which contains less malice compared to the other two characters. Wesley's racism actually does not have significant impact on advancing the plot; however, Julian's discrimination distorts his judgment to the abusive behaviors of his son, Frank. For his prejudice to Native Americans and preference to Frank, he weakens the severity of his son's crime and send his employee to release Frank from the basement of Wesley's house with violence. Last,
Frank' racism is more like a contempt of Native Americans's social status and human rights, and results in his abusive behaviors toward Indian girls and the ignorance of their human rights. His

Hennessey 2 discrimination is not depicted expressly but causes the struggle that derived from divergent attitudes to Frank's crime among family members.
Although Wesley is generally depicted as a positive character, he shows racial behaviors in the first chapter in both explicit and implicit ways. He stereotypes Native Americans as an ignorant, lazy, superstitious and irresponsible race (22); from this explicit discrimination, he considers himself as superior whereas the Native American as inferior. Also, Marie must sleep in a small servant’s bedroom (15), even though there is a empty bedroom at the second floor. This discrimination is not described explicitly, but still reveals that Wesley does not treat Marie in a fair way. His prejudice causes him to consider Marie's unwillingness of seeing a doctor as a
"Indian superstition" (22), and doubts if she ever was seen by a “real” doctor. His "superior" viewpoint causes Marie's encounter with Frank as well as her death. Wesley' s prejudice to native
Americans causes him to stand on his brother’s side initially and thinks Marie probably doesn't know what's supposed to go on in the examination (34), but Wesley is not a deep racism, and most of his racism is presented in the first chapter. Later Wesley abandons his prejudice and reacts to the case from a fair viewpoint.
Compared to his brother, Frank shows intensive racism, though the racism is not specifically depicted in the novel compared to his brother and father. Frank is a blatant racist, which is revealed by his brother who believes that Frank thinks less of Marie than of a dog (144).
Frank' s distorted preference to Native Americans is much more than a mere "preference". This prejudice makes him to overlook the human rights of Indian girl. When he sexually assaults them in the name of diagnose (34), he actually does not consider Native Americans as an equal race to

Hennessey 3
Whites. His reckless criminal behaviors show that his prejudice to Native Americans is much seriously than his brother's, even his is disclosed by Marie indirectly.
The final character who shows racism is Julian. Julian's impression is a stubborn old man who sticks to his racial views. He uses "red meat" (62) as a insulting metaphor of Indian girls and shows extreme antipathy to the fact the Frank is partial to Indian girls (66), also he tolerates his son's behaviors forward to Native Americans, which fuels Frank to commit those crimes.
Even after Julian has been informed of the crimes that are committed by Frank from Wesley, he still dismisses the abuse of Native Americans as unimportant and thinks Frank is supposed to have beaten up some Indians (110). He holds the viewpoint that the assault and victimization of
Native Americans is not a crime worthy of punishment, so he ignores the crime committed by
Frank and send his employee to release Frank from the basement in Wesley' s house. (125).
Julian's racial viewpoint is similar to but much deeper than that of Wesley—a confirmed conception that looks down Native Americans.
Finally, what is worth mentioning is the potential influence of the three people' s racism on David, the narrator of the novel. David, before the main plot in the story, is strange about racism and Native Americans, and his caretaker, Marie, does not match the impression of Native
Americans; however, the elder members of his family affect David' s subjective norms. After
David hears the blatantly discriminatory comments from his father toward Native Americans, he starts to realizes the world is not bright as he once thought. Children are born innocent, and
David is not influenced by racism until he contacts the verbal and behavioral discrimination about Native Americans from his grandpa, father and uncle.

Hennessey 4
In conclusion, Frank's abusive behaviors to Indian girls are the main plot of the novel, and the discrimination of his brother and father fuel Frank's behavior and the tragedy of Marie.
Frank belongs to their family and Marie belongs to the group which they discriminate. Their discrimination distorts their justice, so their judgement deviates from the justice and they turn to support Frank. Racism has been confirmed deeply in the three main characters' minds, and is modeling David's mind. Native Americans face the situation of being treated unfairly, and they are forced to abandon their cultures and accept Western cultures, and this discrimination is inherited from the elders to the kids. 

Hennessey 5
Work Cited
Watson. Larry. Montana 1948. Misseaplonlism, MN: Milkweed Edition. 1993. Print

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Mcbride Financial Marketing Plan

...McBride Financial Marketing Plan University of Phoenix McBride Financial Marketing Plan McBride Financial Services is a mortgage lender that specializes in conventional, FHA, and VA loans for home purchasing and refinancing. The company is presently headquartered in Boise, Idaho and is looking to expand its operations into Wyoming, Montana, North Dakota and South Dakota. McBride Financial Services current mission is to be the preeminent provider of low cost mortgage services using state of the art technology in the five state areas of Idaho, Montana, Wyoming, North Dakota, and South Dakota. With the implementation of a successful marketing plan, these future goals of McBride Financial Services to expand and become a preeminent provider of low cost mortgage services should easily become easily attainable. Naturally, the first step in the marking plan would be to research. The primary interest of McBride Financial Services is to establish a new market of people in need of assistance with financial services. In order to achieve this, McBride Financial Services will need to perform research on the areas current market trends and market values. This information will provide a better understanding of what products to market and how to market the products. The company will also need to look at current internal marketing plans in place to determine strengths and weaknesses, so that a better picture is made as to what areas to improve. This research will also help......

Words: 451 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Cheif Joseph

...Lucas Abelar Professor Paul Hunter English 1301 8 October 2012 Several events in Chief Joseph’s term as chief of the Wallowa band show us he was more diplomat than warrior.The Voice of the West The first event happened in 1885 when, Isaac Stevens, governor of the Washington Territory, organized a council to designate separate areas for natives and settlers. Joseph the Elder (“Young Joseph’s” father) and the other Nez Perce chiefs signed a treaty with the United States establishing a Nez Perce reservation encompassing 7.7 million acres in present-day Idaho, Washington, and Oregon. The 1855 reservation maintained much of the traditional Nez Perce lands, including Josephs Wallowa Valley. The second event was an influx of new settlers caused by a gold rush led the government to call a second council in 1863.” Government commissioners asked the Nez Perce to accept a new, much smaller reservation of 780,000 acres (3,200 km2) situated around the village of Lapwai in Idaho, and excluding the Wallowa Valley.” In exchange, they were promised financial rewards and schools and a hospital for the reservation. One of the allied chiefs signed the treaty on behalf of the Nez Perce Nation, but Joseph the Elder and several other chiefs were opposed to selling their lands, and did not sign. Their refusal to sign caused a rift between the "non-treaty" and "treaty" bands of Nez Perce. The "treaty" Nez Perce moved within the new Idaho reservation's boundaries, while the "non-treaty"......

Words: 1567 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Mcbride Financial Services Marketing Plan

...McBride Financial Services Marketing Plan McBride Financial Services is a start-up regional company based away from Boise, Idaho and is working on becoming a premier mortgage lender. Their products and services target conventional, FHA, and VA loans for home acquiring or refinancing. As a new company, McBride Financial Services is planning to expand into its businesses into Montana, Wyoming, N . Dakota, and South Dakota with the use of effective marketing strategies. To effectively expand and turn into successful, McBride Financial will locate unique advertising means to capture its target audience and also to showcase its mortgage lending services. Some of the methods they will be employing are television, newspaper, billboard, and other ads. They will also utilize social media marketing campaigns on multiple outlets (such as Facebook, Twitter, and so forth). McBride Financial Services goal is to achieve early success and become the “preeminent provider of low cost mortgage services using state of the art technology in the five state area of Idaho, Montana, Wyoming, North Dakota, and South Dakota” (McBride). To do so, McBride Financial will have to focus on: • Financially achieving break-even within six months of beginning its financial operations. • Becoming a profitable company within a year of starting business. • Utilizing technology to minimize costs and maximize efficiencies for its individual and business customers who are applying for and trying to obtain......

Words: 467 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...Homeless in Missoula Kelsey Brandewie Homelessness in Missoula, Mt has been a tremendous issue that the community is trying very hard to eliminate. What people do not know, is that the people out on the streets downtown and around the city, only make up 11% of the homelessness (2.) Those are not the only people struggling with life. There are families that do not have a steady home that the community does not realize need help because most of them have jobs and seem normal but in reality they are struggling to make ends meet. That is what the community needs to come together and fix. There is a rough estimate of at least 200 people who are homeless in Missoula.(1) There are of course, the visible homeless but 25% of the homeless, the “chronically” homeless that seemed to be overlooked by the community. Most of the homeless, of that 25% are families. (1) Families in which have children in them, who are trying so hard to provide for them and give them a normal life. These children attend public school but for them they never know where they will be sleeping that night once they leave school. Some of them sleep in their cars or they go from house to house but none of those houses are their homes. That is not a healthy life style for anyone to live, especially children. The sad thing is though, of all the resources that are at their feet, they only seem to use 50% of them (1.) They feel like they do not need the help as much as others might, so they are too afraid to ask......

Words: 995 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Poetry Essay

...“The Truth Is” By: Linda Hogan The poem “The Truth Is” written by Linda Hogan manages to tell a story, her story of coming from a culture of mixed races or dual ancestry. With her father being a Chickasaw Indian and her mother of European descent, her internal struggle appears in this poem. While not easy to interpret, the voice of another person comes through when the writer uses the first person and later refers to herself by her own name “Linda, girl, I keep telling you” The use of the first person may also indicate that she suffers with her identity and who she is. Growing up in Oklahoma, and being a writer which focuses on feminist perspectives, and women’s lives and feelings, there is evidence of this dynamic in her writings for a constant hope that she should try to forget the past and live for today. Linda is clearly conflicted and this can be seen in the first stanza. She speaks often of hands and their lack of cooperation which points to her mixed race and an unsettled past. The left hand represents her father’s side of the Chickasaw tribe and her right hand represents that of her mother’s white background. The writer also speaks of falling in love too easily and sleeping in a twin bed which is a clear indication that she is single and alone. Along with her marital status, she writes as having no possessions or having empty pockets. However by the last line in the first verse we can see that having material possessions is not important to her as its......

Words: 1405 - Pages: 6

Free Essay


...MONTANA SMALL SCHOOLS ALLIANCE 2015 – 2016 WORKSHOP DATES AND SITES * Sites are tentative at this writing. All times are as follows: 8:30 registration with workshops beginning at 9:00 a.m. and complete by 4 p.m. A one hour lunch is provided. Snacks are provided in the morning and afternoon. * Renewal units and graduate credits are available. Consortium conferences reimburse mileage for one vehicle per district. * Standards and MAP workshops do not reimburse mileage or per diem. NWEA/MAPS TRAINING * Monday, August 10 - Dillon, U of M Western, Charles Swysgood Technology Center Lab. STANDARDS CONFERENCES * Thursday, August 13 – Miles City - (Miles Community College, 2715 Dickinson St, Miles City, MT 59301, Room 106). Library in the morning and guidance in the afternoon. * Friday, August 14 – Bozeman - (Comfort Inn, 1370 N. 7th Ave., Bozeman, MT, Madison Room.) Library in the morning and guidance in the afternoon. * Monday, August 17 – Helena – ( U of M Helena, 1115 North Roberts Street, Helena MT 59601, Lecture Hall) Library in the morning and guidance in the afternoon. * Tuesday, August 18 – Missoula (TBD). Library in the morning and guidance in the afternoon. CONSORTIUM CONFERENCES * Thursday, September 17 – Helena (U of M Helena, 1115 North Roberts Street, Helena, MT 59601, Lecture Hall) * Friday, September 18 – Lewistown (Yogo Inn, 211 East Main Street, Lewistown, MT 59457). * Friday, September 25 – Miles......

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Black Feet Indians

...Prof. Rains NAMS 2/8/11 Black Feet Siksika is translated in English to ‘black feet’. Black feet is thought to be their name because of the discoloring of their moccasins by the ashes of the prairie fires, or possibly because they painted their moccasins black. The Black Feet are a people of great spirit and confidence in their way of life. This is what allowed them to keep the black foot tribe alive to this day. The spirit of the ‘black feet’ is due to their rich heritage, customs, beliefs, art, and stories. They have been able to fend off non-stop attacks like in the late 1800’s with the official government policy of assimilation. Assimilation was the white people believing that their way of life was the best way of life and all Indians should become more like them. The Indians made it through the easterners’ restriction on their young people like speaking their first language and forcing them to dress like whites, cut their hair and go to English schools. The white peoples life style did not appeal to the Indians due to all of the genocide, disease, war, and religion. The Indians way of life is prosperous and has been successful for thousands of years in not making for themselves the problems the white people have. The Indians like being Indians, they want to be Indians, and they will always fight to remain Indians. The black feet religiously believed in medicine bundles. There were more then 50 of them and the most popular were the beaver bundles, medicine pipe......

Words: 836 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...Glacier National Park is a natural beauty located in Montana that draws tourist wanting to experience hard and soft ecotourism. It is also a location where tourist can seek out nature, wildlife, and adventure tourism. The vast area is home to 762 lakes, dozens of glaciers, waterfalls, and trails for hikers. The park has even been named the world’s first peace parks because of the tranquility (National Geographic, 2012). Glacier National Park has been untouched until mining, oil searching, housing, and logging projects have been proposed. The once undisturbed park now has a potential threat to its wildlife and natural and environment. Unless the projects are kept minimal or diminished altogether, Glacier National Park will lose its natural appeal for ecotourism. The persistence of mining and the search for oil is a hazard to the environment of the park and logging or housing depletes the nature of the park. It is extremely important for the park that these activities be limited to ensure the quality of the future for this park. The only way the park can maintain nature and the natural environment it possesses is to sustain the area so it remains untouched. The involvement of the U.S. Forest Service, government, and the Blackfeet Tribe are essential in protecting the park. The Blackfeet Tribe has controlled this area for the past two centuries and they are a key part in sustaining the park as well as the rich culture of the park (National Geographic, 2012). These entities are...

Words: 540 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Grizzly Bears

...A special park?! Grizzly bears cannot be reintroduced to Idaho. But the can live in a special park. Then they would not be a danger for the people and the people will not be a danger for the bears. The grizzly bears are extinguishing. 50,000 grizzly bears used to live in America before European settlement. Today, however, only about 1,100 grizzly bears remain in scattered populations in Montana, Idaho, Wyoming and Washington. It is good that we are reintroduced to the grizzly bears. But the best way is to reintroduce them is in a special park. The bears should first survive in zoos, then it is easier to keep them alive in the wild. The zoo can work with different sorts of breeding programs. Through these breeding programs, the reproduction will be stimulated. That will have many benefits to increase the number of grizzly bears. Also the might die sooner in the wild. Another important reason to have a zoo is education. The education about nature and most important about the grizzly bears. Will be another way to introduce people to the bears. Also we can be a danger for them. We, as humans are very alienated from nature. The saying says: unknown, unloved. This means that we can be dangerous for bears. Just as we were in the 1940s. The bears could be eliminated again and could be shot at. This is the main reason to place a special zoo. If we would live in an ideal world, where animals still occur in large numbers and they would not be threatened by man. Then a...

Words: 310 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Do Dinosaurs Take Care of Their Young?

...I believe that some dinosaurs definitely did take care of their young. One of the prime examples to suggest that dinosaurs took care of their young was the Maiasaura Peeblesorum. There are many pieces of evidence that suggest that these dinosaurs took care of their young. One of these examples is the fact that mothers would cover and stay close to their eggs until they were ready to hatch. This suggests that the mothers would protect their young before they were even born. Another piece of evidence that supports this theory is that there is wearing on the teeth of some baby Maiasaura Peeblesorum, this could mean that the babies were fed by their mothers until they were ready to go and find food all on their own. The third reason to support the idea that dinosaurs took care of their young is the fact that some baby Maiasaura Peeblesorum would stay in the nest for as long as two months, which meant that they would have to be getting food from their mothers, otherwise they would not be able to survive for two months in a nest. Another reason that I believe dinosaurs took care of their young is the fact that Maiasaura Peeblesorum were not able to walk when they are first hatched which would suggest that the babies would be completely dependent on their mothers. Lastly I believe that Maiasaura Peeblesorum dinosaurs support the theory that dinosaurs took care of their young because they laid their eggs close together. By laying their eggs close together it made it easier......

Words: 282 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The West

...Catherine Jones HST-143-D040/Professor Quirk The West January 21, 2016 Moving and settling on the Great Plains during the nineteenth century was no easy task. There were many hardships involved in the laborious task of the moving process and even more involved in building and maintaining a home. The fact that the settlers were moving to the Great Plains added even more difficulties to the task because of its climate and geography. One of the hardships that settlers faces was that there were few building materials on the Great Plains. They usually constructed their houses out of sod which was less than ideal. Sod houses allowed bugs and animals to easily dig through the walls and it also leaked water into the homes very easily. These sod homes also allowed very little light or even air to pass into them. Other hardships included their isolation from one another, the unfortunate use of manure as fuel for fire because of the lack of wood, the dry climate of the Great Plains, and as a result of the climate, the lack of water. Settlers could not plant crops because the ground was too dry and the climate was too humid, that and the fact that there was the lack of water. This forced the settlers to build windmills just so they could pump water. There was also the obstacle of having a lack of money. Since the settlers were so isolated from one another that meant there were no nearby businesses or places of work for settlers to earn money. This lack of money meant living in......

Words: 326 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...Date: April 19, 2013 No: 13-0240 Line of business: Auto States: Alabama, Arkansas, Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, North Dakota, Ohio, Oregon, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, Wisconsin, Wyoming To: Agents and district managers Subject: Reminder SR-22 New Business with prior insurance now acceptable in Bristol West Effective: Immediately Synopsis: Reminder that we now allow insureds that require an SR-22 (FR-44 in VA) with 6 months of continuous prior insurance to be quoted in the Bristol West system. Background: As mentioned in BNB 13-0098, we have revised the Bristol West prior insurance guidelines to allow insureds that require an SR-22 (FR-44 in VA) filing with 6 months of continuous prior insurance to be quoted and bound in Bristol West. A few reminders: Existing Farmers insureds that require SR-22 (FR-44 in VA) filing cannot be quoted in Bristol West. Only new business insureds that require an SR-22 (FR-44 in VA) filing with or without 6 months of continuous prior insurance can be quoted and bound in Bristol West. Bristol West system will not allow any other prior Farmers business with no lapse or with a one to 30-day (60-day in AR) lapse in coverage to be quoted. Bristol West system will not allow you to split spouses between Farmers and Bristol West. If you have questions about this bulletin, contact ServicePoint at (888) 888-0080. HEAD OF TERRITORY Have you read the Agency......

Words: 266 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...Conservation is the appropriate use of land controlled by humans to ensure the elimination of potential waste of natural resources. Preservation is leaving land and the natural resources it has maintaining its natural state; protecting it from any harmful human manipulation. I believe humans can harvest forest resources in an environmentally friendly way. Although not left in its natural state managed to do away with misuse and make the most of the natural resources for future generations to benefit from. Watching the Bridger Teton video and soaking in the spellbinding and breath taking scenery of Yellowstone; I can clearly see where the debate can become heated. The beauty of Bridger Teton is one of a kind, and the idea it will one day be gone or in a state nowhere its current grander is a frightening notion. However, so is the energy crisis America will face in the coming years and generations to that will follow. If the lands of the Greater Yellowstone, will be used for their natural oil and gas resources this will entail the drilling, construction of roads and pipelines the possibility of maintaining its current state seems impossible. I am inclined to believe as stated in the Bridger Teton piece “I’m not against oil and gas exploration, per se, in Wyoming. I am against it in some of these areas that are unique.” If we can preserve “the heart” of Yellowstone and conserve additional lands in Wyoming it is possible to reap the benefits of these luscious lands. ...

Words: 290 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...Robyn Russell 711 11/14/11 Expedition of Lewis& Clark When Lewis and Clark started their journey they wanted to find a way across this continent, for the purposes of comerence.In order to make a film claim of discovery to the Pacific Northwest and compete with the British for the control of the land and the fur trade. Jefferson had the men follow the rivers, map them, and collect scientific data. He also placed special importance on declaring U.S. sovereignty over the Native American tribes along the Missouri River, and getting an accurate sense of the resources in the recently completed Louisiana Purchase. Mr.Phair made us a map to see how Lewis and Clark reached the Rocky Mountains. On May 14,1804 in Nebraska Lewis and Clark set out from camp river and proceed up the Missouris under sail to the first island in the Missouri they camped on the upper point opposite, a creek on the south side below a ledge of limestone rocks called colewater , the group consisted of two self one Frenchmen and 22 men on the boat of 20 ores, one serjt and seven French in a large Perogue, a Corp and 6 soldiers in a large Perogue, men in high spirits .  I determined to go as far as St. Charles a french village 7 Leags.*** up the Missourie, and wait at that place untill Cap. Lewis Could finish the business in which he was obliged to attend to at St. Louis and join me by land from that place 24 miles; by this movement I calculated that if any alterations in the loading of the......

Words: 287 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Lululemon Case Study

...From a strategic planning perspective, the well-known Canadian fitness retailer Lululemon has a lot of factors to consider when laying the foundation for a five year plan. There are many opportunities as well as challenges that the company encounters from its external environments. Each of these is outlined in the following paragraphs and must be embraced in order for Lululemon to position itself strategically and successfully in the market. Economical environment: The economical environment that circles around Lululemon Athletica shows a strong revenue growth. In September 2012 Lululemon posted a 33% increase in revenue to $282.6-million (U.S.) and an increase of 15% in same-store sales (refer to figure 2). Along with that we can observe the company’s stable financial position with reasonable debt levels by most measures, impressive record of earnings per share growth, net income growth and good cash flow from operations. Lululemon was pretty successful among many investors as it consistently raised quarterly profits and revenues in a struggling fitness retail industry (see figure 3). In reference to the article, “Lululemon athletica inc. Stock Quote & Summary Data”, unemployment rate made some effect on the company’s Gross Income as of in 2009 when the unemployment grew to the level of 8.5% company’s Gross Income was only 23.56% (see figure 1 and 2). But in 2011 when the unemployment growth was at a level of 7.2% company’s Gross Income became 77.04%. This also......

Words: 3451 - Pages: 14