Free Essay

Traditional Fallacy


Submitted By zeeshanbabar
Words 1018
Pages 5
Zeeshan Babar
7 July, 2015 First Victimized, Now Victimizing History tells us about how hundreds of years ago all men and women except for the one with power were oppressed by emperors and kings. They were allowed to do only what the emperor allowed them to do, and he could make them do whatever he wanted them to de. Even the one with power in the empire were not allowed to deny or disagree with the emperor, or else they would suffer the same fate as every one else. However with time people revolted and revolution came after decades breaking this tradition of monarchy, and making every individual free with their rights. Now every individual is said to be a free human who has natural rights. But even in these modernized societies after all that human race has experienced, and has been through the fallacy of appeal to tradition still exists. Appeal to tradition is the fallacy that a standpoint, situation or action is right, proper, and correct simply because it has “always” been that way, because people have “always” thought that way, or because it continues to serve one particular group very well. It is the notion that if an idea has been around for a while than it should be followed and is true. This fallacy is one of the major reasons that have been recognized for the oppression of women all around the world. This is particularly the matter in less developed and modernized societies. The women of these societies are oppressed as they are not supported by their families for education, instead they are against it. They do not think it is necessary for a women to be educated, because according to the tradition women are obliged to support their families and raise children. Basically there duty is to perform well inside a household , and have nothing to do about what happens outside the house. This is a traditional fallacy, because a woman is not obliged to do anything anyone else thinks she should. They are also human beings like others, and have natural rights. But people still follow this tradition as going against it would be disrespectful to their ancestors or simply disrespectful towards men. Other reasons people follow this tradition is because following it makes their life easier and more pleasing. Some even follow this fallacy for the reason that they think the natural flow will be disrupted if this natural tradition is altered. Many women have stood against this fallacy, and some have been even supported by some men which has resulted some changes in some places. Some Decades ago you would not find any female in a western side university, however that has changed, and now in the western areas like the United States and in Europe universities are filled with females. But this change is still to take place in a lot of other nations, and societies. These traditional fallacies have cost a lot to women of different societies as many of these traditions lead women to be seen with lesser equality, respect, and a being close to slave for men.
In different tribes of Africa, different traditions are followed by people which are very disturbing.
There a tradition in a tribe in Africa that if the husband of a women dies, she has to sleep with his brother in order to lay the spirit of the deceased to rest no matter what circumstances. Afterwards the women have to go without washing herself for 40 days, and she would have little food as according to the tradition the food she receives will be only given by the family of the deceased. The food they get depends on the goodwill of the husband’s family. This is another form of traditional fallacy which is humiliation of the female race. These traditional fallacies have made women to have little value in society, making them targets of bad treatment, and physical abuse. ( MAILA) . Another tradition that came to light with financial crisis in Africa was that raping someone bounds you and the women to get married. Because men for marriage could not afford to provide a dowry for up to 1000$, they resorted to sexual violence. According to tribal customs, a man who rapes a virgin must then marry her, and does not have to pay a dowry in order to do so as someone who has lost her virginity loses the right to demand for that. (Maila) These absurd traditional fallacies is also a reason for many women who kill themselves in the middle east and Africa. This fallacy has only cost women pain and cruelty. When ever people are questioned about why this is happening, they would have only one answer that this is there cultural tradition. Not following these traditions or going against them is a big taboo for those people, and they can not even imagine stopping it by themselves. Instead they get frustrated if someone talks about how this is a fallacy which has to stop. Even though men fought and lost their lives for freedom, equality, and to get rid from the evil Emperors and Kings, they have corrupted themselves following these traditional fallacies which leaves them no different than those rulers. They might have freed themselves from the rules of unfair kings and authorities, but they have yet to free the curse that has been there in our societies forever. This curse is the evil which is oppressing are women leading to their sad lives and suicides. People now think that the world has modernized and prospered way more than before but in my opinion there is no point of this prosperity if everyone can not even live the way they want to. This fallacy should and has to be stopped or there would be more victims, and a sad history for the upcoming generation to read.

Work Cited
MAILA, HERTIER. "War, Tradition Feeds Sexual Violence Against Women." Institute for War and Peace Reporting. 9 Oct. 2009. Web. 8 July 2015. <>.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Rhetorical Analysis of Charles Murray

...Rhetorical Analysis Are too many people going to college? This question has been contemplated over for years. The increased cost of college throughout the years has caused the question to become even more relevant. Charles Murray, an author from the American Enterprise Institute, wrote the essay entitled “Are Too Many People Going to College?” Murray’s essay sought ought to explain that universities are being filled with students who are either not prepared for higher education or who are compelled into attending college and are unable to succeed because the lack of inherent abilities. While Murray makes many pertinent points about America’s infatuation with the B.A as a standard into a class of intellectual elite the essay does not take into consideration the individual influences that may lead to a student’s success. This essay will analyze and critique Murray’s view of why the pursuit of a B.A can lead to more harm than good. Murray’s main argument throughout his essay is that the perceived reward of a college degree disseminates to those seeking higher education and inevitably does more harm than good. He argues that many students do not have the ability to enjoy and finish a four year degree. This leads the student to being stigmatized and in debt due to his or her failure. Murray further establishes his argument by saying that more people continue to go to college because they are programmed into believing, regardless of their abilities, to pursue college as an essential...

Words: 1299 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Essay 1

...MDIA2002: Views Journalism Notes 3 Question and analysis tasks are to be found inserted at several points in the following notes. Again, this work is compulsory and must be submitted to Moodle at least 24 hours in advance of your tutorial. When providing answers, ensure that you use full, grammatical and well-expressed sentences. Ensure you bring along a copy of your answers with you to the tutorial. The final task in this week’s work may be quite time consuming, and possibly quite challenging. Rest assured that the tute preparation load will be significantly lighter once we get to tutorial 5 (or soon after that if you are in a smaller tutorial group) and the tutorial presentations. Until then it’s necessary to do a bit of front loading, so to speak, to get you up and running with the text analysis methodologies which will stand you in good stead later in the semester. Once you have mastered these methodologies there will be significantly less theory and much more of an emphasis on actual journalistic coverage of events, people, issues and trends. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- A guide to analysing views journalism Part 1 – characterising arguments by reference to the how they are justified and supported In the first section of these notes we are going to look in a bit more detail at how supporting argumentation (justifications) works to justify primary claims. This material was dealt with in...

Words: 7920 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

The Interrupters Essay

...The Violence Interrupters The film “The Interrupters” by Steve James and Alex Kotlowitz is based on a group of individuals that are part of Ceasefire, a Chicago anti-violence program. Gary Slutkin, the founder of Ceasefire, believes that the spread of violence is very similar to the spread of disease, and so he believes that the treatment should be analogous. In order to stop the infection, one must go after the most infected, the source. The main goal of the violence interrupters is to simply stop killings and to save as many lives as possible. They make it very clear that they are not trying to dismantle gangs. The violence interrupters are made up of individuals who have had many years of jail time in the past, but now want to make a positive difference in their community rather than continue with their lives of crime. The interrupters use their own personal histories to intervene in conflicts before they go too far and turn into violent encounters. The Violence Interrupters Challenge the problems with the program: One of the main problems with the film is that “The Interrupters” are staged on the front lines in their fight to save lives in their communities. This fight is near to impossible to win because although they all put forth their best efforts and put their heart and soul into every individual they try to help, the problem cannot actually be solved, as it exists on a much larger scale. Although the film shows “The Interrupters” doing their best to make...

Words: 552 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Rhubarb Pie Is a Dessert. Therefore, Whoever Eats Rhubarb Pie Eats a Dessert.

...Fallacy Exercises, part 3 I. Identify the fallacies committed by the following arguments, giving a brief explanation for your answer. If no fallacy is committed, write "no fallacy."[1] NOTE: If an argument is followed by “IGNORE” it is an eample that we didn’t cover and you are not responsible for it. 1. Either we require forced sterilization of Third World peoples or world population will explode and all of us will die. We certainly don't want to die, so we must require forced sterilization. False Dichotomy. These aren’t the only two possibilities. People could control the population by other means. 2. James said that he saw a picture of a beautiful girl stashed in Stephen's locker. We can only conclude that Stephen has broken the rules, because girls are not allowed in the locker room. Accident – the rule applies to real girls, not pictures of girls. 3. Why is it so difficult for you to reach a decision? Complex Question. The thing being assumed is that it is difficult for the person to reach a decision. 4. People who lack humility have no sense of beauty because everyone who has a sense of beauty also has humility. Circular argument. The conclusion says nothing different than the premise. 5. Butane is combustible. Therefore, it burns. Circular argument. “Combustible” means “burns”. 6. Honey, this postcard just arrived, and it says we have won a free airline trip. All we have to do is call the toll-free number...

Words: 3033 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Viewed as an Era as a Whole, Reconstruction Takes Place Between the Years 1865-1877 or Between the Civil War’s End and the Union Army’s Withdrawal from the South. Reconstruction’s Main Goals Were to Integrate Newly

..."The Morality of Birth Control" by Margaret Sanger, (1921) Margaret Sanger uses several method's within her speech, "The Morality of Birth Control", to convey her strong views on the topic. She uses a strong sense of bias, fallacies, and colorful rhetoric devices in her speech to not only get the attention of the audiences, but to relay a sense of urgency for the actions that need to be taken. One bias that Sanger uses is toward the idea of motherhood without birth control being a condition of ignorance and chance. This may perhaps be the case for a small number of women, but it is not accurate to categorize all women who do not use or believe in birth control in this manner. Margaret Sanger uses vivid examples of fallacies and rhetorical devices in her speech. She uses the words "religious scruples" to drive home the basic need for power and morality. When Sanger refers to the opposition to birth control she refers to them as "this group is diseased, feeble-minded, and is of the pauper element dependent entirely upon the normal and fit members of society for their support." Her vivid imagery evokes not only emotion, but the need for aggressive action. One way that the speaker addressers arguments and counterarguments is when she brings about the point of the two sexes "mixing together”. Sanger brings about the point that opponent to birth control are the same people that were opposed to women working outside the home and mixing with the opposite sex. Margaret Sanger...

Words: 438 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...Economic fallacies seem to surround us in the media, but few people take notice. The reason I believe this type of stray thinking is so common is that the media is often written not by economists by training, but by those who did not concentrate in business or finance in their studies. I want to focus on one of the most important and far-reaching economic fallacies - the Fallacy of Composition. Before knowing that there was a name for such an error in economic reasoning, I had considered the possibility that there are probably numerous examples of errors of part to whole relationships since samples taken are often not representative of the studied population. I will discuss two examples in finance to support why it is a problem. The Fallacy of Composition assumes that what is true and valid for an individual or segment of the population would necessarily be true for the larger group or whole (McConnell 16). There are ample examples of this problem in economics and finance. I have worked in the finance industry for three years now and as a perfect example, investment firms of various sizes want to make equity sales in the market. If a larger firm only wants to sell 1000 shares of a relatively liquid investment, they would have no problem and the price of each of those shares remains rather consistent. However, the same would no longer be true if that same firm wants to completely exit one of their existing positions by liquidating all of their 10 million shares, they...

Words: 781 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Eth125 Appendixa

...Appendix D Assumptions and Fallacies Nanette McDowell Hum 111/ week 8 Assignment April 13, 2013 Bethany Bigler • What are assumptions? How do you think assumptions might interfere with critical thinking? What might you do to avoid making assumptions in your thinking? An assumption is a thought or a way of someone’s thinking in which they believes are true without proof. For example, when I was young I thought that all white people did not like black people. As I became older to understand my thoughts and judgments, this assumption was not true at all. The assumption back then was perceived in my mind because of the kinds of people that I was around that influenced my judgment. I was overgeneralizing about white people not liking black people because of the environment at the time. We must identify inferences and assumptions in order to see what inferences are illogical when the assumptions that lead to them are not justifiable. Once you become skilled in identifying the inferences and assumptions you are in a better position to question the extent to which any of your assumptions are justified. The key is recognizing and questioning our inferences and assumptions. To avoid making false assumptions here are some tips that I follow: (eHow article), • “Be as objective as you can in making evaluative decisions. Whether you're at work, at home or with your friends, be as logical and fair as possible in your judgments. • Resist the urge to accept stereotypes. Even though...

Words: 685 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How to Write a Critique

...Steps for Writing Critiques (from Behrens and Rosen’s Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum, 12th Edition) 1. Introduce. Introduce both the passage under analysis and the author. State the author’s main argument and the point(s) you intend to make about it. Provide background information to help readers understand the relevance of the passage. This background information may include one or more of the following: * an explanation of why the subject is of current interest * a reference to a possible controversy surrounding the subject of the passage or the passage itself * biographical information about the author * an account of the circumstances under which the passage was written * a reference to the intended audience of the passage 2. Summarize. Summarize the author’s main points, making sure to state the author’s purpose for writing. 3. Assess the presentation. Evaluate the validity of the author’s presentation, distinct from your points of agreement or disagreement. Comment on the author’s success in achieving his or her purpose, by reviewing three or four specific points. Base you review on one or more of the following criteria: * Is the information accurate? * Is the information significant? * Has the author defined terms clearly? * Has the author used and interpreted information fairly? * Has the author argued logically? 4. Respond to the presentation. NOW you can respond to the author’s views. With...

Words: 737 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

There Are Too Many Lawyers

...Paper 1: Argument Paper There are too many lawyers William E. Foster wrote this article entitled “There are Not Too Many lawyers.” It is an interesting piece, sharing a lot of information. The author pointed to all the benefits that can arise from being an attorney, while underlying several other important factors. He also tried to bring up few points to reinforce his statement. He argued that attorneys have deep working knowledge of the legal system, are skilled specialists and bring a noble value to society. The author focused solely on the abilities of attorneys in general without considering any counterclaim facts. Essential mistakes were made throughout his argument, such as poor formation of paragraphs, use of fallacies, lack of credible sources, absence of counterclaims and conclusion. Although the author may have presented crucial information, after a thorough analysis of the entire argument, the bad points prevailed over the good ones; hence, this argument is weak. A strong argument requires a good structure such as: a clear thesis statement, supporting facts, credible sources, counterclaims, coherence in paragraphs, a good structure, excellent grammar, good use of punctuation, clear introduction, body and conclusion, etc… The writer hardly satisfied any of these attributes. First, he included a thesis statement: “Although of the criticism of the present legal education environment are valid, I disagree that law schools are graduating too many JD’s.” (Paragraph...

Words: 1004 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Being Logcal

...Book Review of Being Logical: A Guide to Good Thinking Being Logical: A Guide to Good Thinking by D.Q. McInerny is an introduction to the science and art of thinking and living logically. The paperback version includes a preface and 137-pages that was published in 2005 by Random House in New Work and has a price tag of $12.95. The author, D.Q. McInerny, is a professor of philosophy and has taught logic at several institutes of higher learning before ending up at Our Lady of Guadalupe Seminary in Lincoln, Nebraska. He has written works on religious philosophy and has collaborated on three text books concerning philosophy and logic. McInerny has written with conviction but believes that logic must be exercised in the educational process (McInerny, 2005). In this particular work, McInerny attempts to make his readers understand logic by seeing their surroundings and environments in an objective and critical manner (McInerny, 2005). He is able to do so in lay-man’s terms that almost any reader would be able to comprehend. This piece was written as a handbook for presenting the very basic values of logic to people who have never had the chance to practice it before. Those that have been well versed in logic before may easily lose interest in a work this simplified. Summary Being Logical is organized into five parts: 1) Preparing the Mind for Logic; 2) The Basic Principles of Logic; 3) Argument: The Language of Logic; 4) The Sources of Illogical Thinking; and 5) The...

Words: 1616 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Marijuana Use Is Harmful

...actually be proven 100%. I do find this source to be credible based off of the information that is given. This article is broken up into sections that talk about the main effects of marijuana usage. It lists statistics throughout the article and studies that have been conducted. However, I do believe they are only taking one side where marijuana can be useful in a lot of cases not mentioned here. It isn’t all negatives when it comes to marijuana usage. I do not believe that any rhetorical devices were used by this author. The author stuck to simple details and studies, and did not go on exaggerating or relating marijuana use to anything other than the details. I think that the fallacy, hasty generalization was used throughout this article. Mainly because this fallacy makes the assumption that a whole group or idea is a certain way because of a small amount of sources. In this article they provide all negative effects of marijuana use, when we all know that there are medically proven studies that...

Words: 1033 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Edward Wilson

...People speak in a variety of ways across the globe, ranging from literal to sarcastic. For what is spoken to be understood, one must know how they are speaking, otherwise things will be confusing and misunderstood. In the book “The Future of Life”, written by Edward O. Wilson, the ways of how environmentalists and people-first debates are carried out are brought to the surface. These two sides ironically have similarities in format and childish manner, which are both seen throughout the satirical workings of Wilson. First off, Wilson implements a point that brings out the false, deceptive thinking of both groups on the problem at hand. For example, the people-first advocates claim that if a person “relaxes their guard” when the environmentalists would possibly be in power, their “property rights will go down the tube.” This shows that there is no applicability to environmentalist ideologies, nor any appeal to their true goals, which can be seen throughout the arguments against the environmentalists. The same exact method is used on the other side to show the back and forth way of argument without any real support. Wilson says that the people-first advocates’ idea of conservation is “planting trees around a golf course”, which of course, has no true support for it to be viewed as real. There is also no information or facts within the statements, just the truth about how both sides argue. These features alone provide little impact on the issue, but Wilson does so anyway by writing...

Words: 555 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

An Improper Proposal

...English 103 10 July 2014 An Improper Proposal “A Modest Proposal”, written by Johnathon Swift, is perhaps one of the greatest literary works in English history. It is an intelligently written satire that is set in 1729. In it Swift presents the idea of devouring one year old infants in an attempt to feed the hungry and ever growing population. The satire is set in Ireland and was aimed at Catholics, who were known for having a lot of kids and being too poor to care for them. Throughout his persuasive/argumentative satire he utilizes logic and reason, emotion, and character to argue why his proposal is a good solution to the excess population and to persuade others to follow his idea. One of the types of arguments Swift employs throughout his essay is logos. Logos are arguments that are based on fact and reason. In the beginning of his literary work Swift begins discussing how many children are born every year to poverty stricken parents. He uses specific numbers such as “. . . . One-hundred and twenty thousand children of the poor are born annually” to bring to light how much the population and hunger problems will continue to grow. Swift is using logos (logic and reason) when he uses statistics of children born to parents who cannot afford to care for them. He also uses logos to dehumanize the infants by comparing them to food already eaten. When Swift compares the children to roasting pigs he is using an analogy. Another logical analogy Swift uses is comparing...

Words: 1184 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Critical Thinking - Fallacies

...Title: Unit 5 Fallacies Kaplan University February 11, 2014 Unit 5 Fallacies Part I: Mom, you know how much I love animals, right? Well, yesterday I just happened to be passing by an animal shelter, and wanted to stop in and take a look at all of those poor dogs that are going to be put to sleep. I know you told me that I couldn’t have any more pets, but there was this one dog; his name is “Butterscotch," and he was scheduled to be executed that same day, and well; I just couldn’t let them stick those huge needles in him, hurting him, and killing him for no reason. Anyway, I hope you don’t mind, but I brought him home with me. You know; I remember you telling me when you were a kid; you did the same thing, so I can’t see how this would be any different from what you used to do. Besides, I’ll take care of him, feed him, and you won’t have to do anything; I promise. If you let me keep him, I will promise to do all of my chores and never argue with you again, please! You know; I was talking to my friend the other day, and she told me that shelters actually like killing dogs, they sell the dog remains to a company that makes dog food out of them. I’m not sure where she heard this, but she loves dogs, so I know she’s right. My friend said they make more money that way, so they really don’t care about these dogs at all; it’s always about people's greed and how much money they can make. If I can save at least one dog from becoming dog food, I would be happy. ...

Words: 1366 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Philosphy Unit 3

...Running Head: LOGIC 1 Terms of Logical Fallacy Phyllis Lovering AIU ONLINE LOGIC 2 Terms of Logical Fallacy Mere assertion is when in an argument or debate and you believe you are right even though you have no evidence or proof you are right. An argument would be, my niece went to a Lynard Skynard concert the previous night. She begin telling me all about this concert how great it was, but she could not produce a ticket or any proof she was actually there. Circular reasoning is when you begin with a premises and ends with a conclusion that are the same thing. We all know Emily Dickinson was a poet in the mid 1800’s. We know she wrote and published Poetry. Were those hers words or someone else’s words we do not know? All we know for sure is the poems were published under her name. Ad hominem is when someone speaks mean against someone else that has nothing to do with the argument at hand. My mom will get onto my sister and she will start telling...

Words: 473 - Pages: 2