Free Essay

Nsa- Edward Snowden

In: Social Issues

Submitted By mekajay12
Words 946
Pages 4
In American History, whistle blowers have played a significant role in releasing information the government holds from the public eye but many are not sure whether to call this activity an act of kindness or an act of selfishness. Whistleblowers throughout the years, from the Rosenberg's to Julian Assange have revealed confidential information about the governent to give America some type of justice but instead for most of them this didn't turn out to be the case. It is debated whether some whistleblowers should be classified as heros or villans and if whistleblowing acts should be considered helpful or harmful. The whistleblower I will be talking about in this essay is Edward Snowden and how he released information about the NSA's spying program. In my opinion I believe Edward Snowden did way more harm than good to America by releasing secure information held by the NSA. A whistleblower is a person who exposes wrongful information that goes on in a organization. Mainly, whistleblowers reach out to parties that can publicize this new found information. These parties include the media, hotlines, members of politics, managers of organizations, other rival businesses and other sources. In most cases the information revealed by the whistleblower goes against a law and harms the public in one way or another. Edward Snowden is a former CIA technical assistant who has claimed responsibility for leaking headline-making information about the National Security Agency's (NSA) surveillance program. He revealed that the NSA has records of majority of calls made in America, including those who are making and receiving the calls phone number, conversations between people in emails, on Twitter, Facebook etc. They also have huge amounts of data on the internet including history in web searches and websites. There are many reasons why Edward Snowden’s actions were unethical. The first of these is that Edward Snowden took an oath of loyalty for holding information for the NSA to himself. Alot of people relied on him, Instead of being loyal he committed a crime. Any government employee is warned repeatedly that the disclosure of information without the government knowing is a crime. For him to accuse the government of doing illegal action while him himself is doing illegal actions is more than him contradicting himself. It's serious when person who works for an intelligence agency and signs documents agreeing to keep things secret reveals those secrets. He thought that giving out the government’s information would help the country when instead he hurt it. He gave the NSA a bad name when they are actually trying to help America. He also shared information about the NSA's plans with other countries like China & Russia. Another reason he shouldn't have revealed any information is because the NSA's actions were constitutional and didn't violate any individuals rights if they felt that that was case. The NSA claims authorities can only target people who are non-U.S. citizens and non-permanent residents, and those who are overseas. There was no straight forward violation of the constitution because the Fourth Amendment does not protect dialed phone numbers, because people automatically lose privacy over those numbers when they are given to the phone company. The Constitution protects the content of the communications, whether it be a phone call, e-mail, or old-fashioned letter. Also Congress approved a change to the FISA statute to allow collections of such sort. The last reason that I feel Edward Snowden should have kept this information to himself was because he set the NSA to make it look like they were not helping out America when in reality the NSA has prevented 50 potential terror attacks in 20 countries since 2001, including plots such as the case of Najibullah Zazi, who in 2009 plotted to bomb the New York subway system, a case involving David Headley, a man who helped plan the 2008 Mumbai terrorist attack, a case involving a purported plot to attack the New York Stock Exchange and the case of Basaaly Moalin, a man convicted of sending $8,500 to Somalia to support Al Shabab, the terrorist group that has taken responsibility for the attack on a Kenyan mall. Some have complained that these programs have given the government too much power to monitor people around the world. According to the NSA only certain people have access to the information, while said the courts have found people cannot have a reasonable expectation of privacy as to who and when they call. Other people may feel that the government should be spying on your call records when really they only collect information from those calling outside the US. Lastly some may argue that Edward Snowden went against his sworn oath the protect us but if a whistleblower like himself can't even be trusted to have a company such as the NSA's back who's to say that he can have millions of Americans backs. In conclusion, Edward Snowden had no business revealing information about the NSA that really made no change to America and the NSA's plans. Instead he angered a lot of people and he has to be kept in hiding for security reasons. If he would of kept things to himself he would still have a job and the NSA would have a better chance at preventing more terrorist attacks but the fact that millions of people now feel like they are being spied on it makes the task a bit more difficult since Americans now don't trust the NSA's actions even though the actions are all constitutional. Sometimes it's better to keep things to yourself for the sake of you and the others that can be affected by it tremendously.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Edward Snowden Case Study

...the people for their basic leadership. This paper represents the case study of Edward Snowden who is a defense contractor Booz Allen Hamilton, leaked very confidential information about the activities of USA’s National Security Agency (NSA). In June 2013, Snowden confessed to passing characterized records to columnists at The Guardian and The Washington Post—revealing the details of NSA observation programs that gather and perform information mining on a huge number of U.S. telephone calls and Internet...

Words: 1308 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Who Is Edward Snowden?

...Who is Edward Snowden? Edward Snowden, 30, was a three-month employee of a government consulting firm Booz Allen Hamilton. At Booz Allen (he has since been terminated), he worked as a systems administrator at an NSA Threat Operations Center in Hawaii, one of several facilities detect threats against government computer systems. In other words, he was a low-level intelligence government contractor. Background: Edward Joseph Snowden was born June 21, 1983, he grew up in Wilmington, N.C., but later moved to Ellicott City, Md., he told The Guardian. His mother, Wendy, is the chief deputy clerk for administration and information technology at the federal court in Baltimore, a court official told NBC News. His father, Lonnie, is a former Coast Guard officer who lives in Pennsylvania, the Allentown Morning Call reported. A neighbor said he has an older sister who is an attorney. Education: He did not complete high school. He told The Guardian that he studied computers at a community college and obtained a general equivalency degree. A spokesman for Anne Arundel Community College confirmed that a student with the same name and birth date took classes there, from 1999 to 2001 and again in 2004 and 2005. Military service: He spent four months in the Army reserves, from May to September 2004 as a special forces recruit to a 14-week training course, the Army said. "He did not complete any training or receive any awards," an Army statement said. No other details were......

Words: 1691 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Does Edward Snowden Deserve to Be Given Amnesty?

...Why Edward Snowden should be given amnesty In June 2013 the former NSA employee Edward Snowden, leaked a number of classified intelligence documents to journalists at The Washington Post and The Guardian and has been living in Russia ever since. Because of his decision to not take part in illegal surveillance practices, he has been labeled a traitor. However, everyone who has sworn to uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States, especially employees of the US intelligence community, should report any information that concerns breaking the law. Therefore, Snowden deserves to be given amnesty and the right to a fair trial without fear of being incarcerated for simply reporting crimes against the Constitution. Snowden caused a stir last year when he went public with a number of top secret reports about illegal government activity and was forced to seek asylum in Russia. The first major leak revealed evidence of the US government’s top-secret practice of eavesdropping on millions of domestic phone calls in America on a regular basis. Since then, various leaked documents have been continuously published by the media and the NSA has been losing its credibility among the public. The US authorities have charged Snowden under the Espionage Act and US intelligence officials have already condemned him without a trial, labeling him both guilty and a traitor. James Woolsey, a former head of the C.I.A., told Fox News, “[Snowden] should be prosecuted for treason. If convicted...

Words: 1048 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Study

...ashfaq 16020248 Junaid sirat Comparative law Edward Snowden. Born in North Carolina in 1983, Edward Snowden worked for the National Security Agency through subcontractor Booz Allen in the NSA's Oahu office. While working there, Snowden began noticing government programs involving the NSA spying on American citizens via phone calls and internet use. Before long, leaving his very comfortable life and $200,000 salary behind, in May 2013, Snowden began copying top-secret NSA documents while at work, building a record of practices that he found invasive and alarming. The documents contained enormous and pejorative information on the NSA's domestic surveillance practices, including spying on millions of American citizens under the name of programs such as PRISM. (Edward Snowden biography) Snowden later forwarded these documents to journalists, from where on June 5th Guardian newspaper released those secret documents about an American intelligence body (Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court) demanding that Verizon release information on a daily basis gathered from its American customers activities. Also the Guardian and the Washington Times released Snowden's leaked information on PRISM, a NSA program that allows real-time information collection, in this case, solely information on American citizens. Snowden now lives in Russia. One of his lawyers, Anatoly Kucherena, gave an interview with CBS News. Kucherena said that Snowden would seek temporary asylum in Russia and......

Words: 533 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Technology and Privacy

...Technology and Privacy Jurgen Debooserie Accounting Information Systems 04/24/2015 Technology and Privacy Over the last few years, technology and privacy have been transformed in an encouraging and dangerous realm. Technology provides us with easy access to information anywhere, improves communication between entities, enhances efficiency and productivity, and introduces social networking. This whole new world opens a lot of opportunities for every industry, but it has also has its downfalls. Since entities are using technology to communicate with each other, we need to be aware of how private our conversations are. According to Oxford Dictionaries, privacy is the state or condition of being free from being observed or disturbed by other people or the state of being free from public attention. In today’s society, we have several social networking websites including Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn. The things we do and say online leave a trail behind of our personal information. Everyone can track us when users post pictures, click a hyperlink, send emails, turn on locations, and it gives companies the opportunity to public access and the ability to store it. Companies and the government collect information in ways that might could threaten our freedoms, because when corporations acquire our information they sell it back to the highest bidder, while the government introduces laws that allows them to monitor us like never before. It affects our freedom of speech,......

Words: 3015 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Snowden Traitor or Hero

...EDWARD SNOWDEN TRAITOR OR HERO Regarding the Edward Snowden case there is a an very interesting ethical problem. Just to give us a bit of background context ; Edward Snowden was an employee of the CIA and NSA, who revealed details of several monitoring programs and American mass britanniques. For some peolpe he was considered like a hero because he has brought to light confidential information that deserves to be in the public domain and for other a villainous traitor because those put in danger his country, it is important to ask whether his revelations comes under the ethical or the legal fact. Ethical : We know that most people would feel betrayed by Edward because he released personal information about them but it was in order to prove that the US Government is recording the communications of its citizens. But it is Ethic to help other isn’t it ? Ethics are moral principles that guide the way a behaves. It issued by a business is a particular kind of policy statement. A code of ethic issued by a company is some kind of policy statement. A properly framed code is, in effect, a form of binding legislation within the company for its employees, specific sanctions for breaches of the code. If these sanctions are absent, the code is just a list of piety. The heaviest sentence usually dismissal unless a crime has been committed. Focusing on ethics, for those who feel that Snowden did was morally acceptable, calculating almost everyone has to weigh the benefits......

Words: 1125 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Article

...PRISM whistleblower Edward Snowden: 'US has been hacking in Asia' Edward Snowden a whistleblower is saying that computer in Asia have been hacked by the United States government since 2009. Edward Snowden used to be a CIA technician is calming that the NSA and the FBI are collecting domestic phone and internet data. He also goes one to say the FBI and the NSA have access to systems in China and Hong Kong. "Snowden told the South China Morning Post that the US has been targeting public officials, businesses and students of the Chinese University of Hong Kong since 2009, citing unverified documents as evidence." Snowden claims the SNA has hacking operation all over the world with access to multiple systems. Instead of trying to hack ever computer one by one they would go after network backbones which will give them access to multiple workstations at once. Snowden fled to Hong Kong before blowing the whistle. Edward Snowden is still hiding and the Obama administration is still trying to apprehend him. They have revoked Snowden’s passport hoping that this will help in his capture. "What started as a dramatic escape story involving a self-described whistle-blower evolved into a diplomatic incident in which the United States faces an open rift with one major power and a tense standoff with another." Edward Snowden has caused a lot of trouble with the relationship of these countries. The United States government wants to be able to spy on other countries without them......

Words: 267 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Snowden Note

...1 Edward Joseph Snowden is a former National Security Agency (NSA) contractor who disclosed a global surveillance by the NSA, such as PRISM, XKeyscore, Tempora, and the interception of US and European telephone metadata. Page 2 1. In May 2013 Snowden took a leave of absence, telling his supervisors he was returning to the mainland for treatment, but instead left Hawaii for Hong Kong on May 20. 2. On June 22, US officials revoked Snowden's passport. Although Snowden had applied for political asylum to 20 countries, the US administration, specifically Vice President Joe Biden, had pressured the governments of these countries to refuse his petition for asylum. 3. On June 23, Snowden landed in Moscow's international airport. He remained in the transit zone for 39 days until being granted temporary asylum by the Russian government on August 1.Then he went to an undisclosed location kept secret for security reasons. HongKong In Hongkong, Snowden spoke very frankly about the US Government’s attempts to extradite him, so his intention is to ask the courts and people of Hongkong to decide his fate. As we can see in the pictures, On June 15, people in Hong Kong got together to support Edward Snowden. After Snowden had taken off, The HongKong government released a statement, saying that said the extradition request received from the U.S. “did not fully comply with the legal requirements under Hong Kong law.” so they had no legal reason to prevent Snowden......

Words: 910 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Global Economics and the Impact of Whistleblowing

...Whistleblowing and the global impact. Table of Contents ESSAY Introduction The importance and understanding of whistleblowing The notion of whistleblowing Whistleblowing – an act of good will Whistleblowing – an act of revenge The role of the government Government whistleblowing How Snowden formed society Introduction Whistleblowing, an act of certain controversy, has provided material for many a discussion. It has filled our newspapers, televisions and radios on a daily basis, since Wikileaks went public with its first act of exposing illegal activity. ‘Whistleblowing’ is a dynamic process involving at least three social actors; the wrongdoer, the whistleblower and the recipient, each of whom takes actions in response to the other’ (Near et al., p 509, 1996), while accepting the associated dangers and risks. Current events relating to Edward Snowden, Julian Assange and Bradley Manning have sparked intense debate throughout the world regarding policy changes, creation of new laws and the conduct of government and corporations. It is widely agreed that whistleblowing exists and happens on a daily basis. Scholars have examined the topic over the years narrowing it down to ethnical divergences or even to how the act of wrongdoing can impact a whistleblower. The importance and understanding of whistleblowing Age has a significant......

Words: 3369 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

The Pros And Cons Of Edward Snowden

... The individual who performs an act of hacktivism is said to be a hacktivist”. Edward Snowden is an “American computer professional, former CIA employee, and former government contractor who leaked classified information from the U.S. National Security Agency in 2013”. Hacktivism has been looked at from two separate points of view. Some individuals perceive it as positive, while others negative. Edward Snowden serves as a whistleblower...

Words: 938 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Edward Snowden Persuasive Essay

...During what is arguably the most difficult period in U.S. history, Honest Abe expressed his hopes that “government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.” The NSA surveillance program goes against this principle. It poses a substantial threat to the social contract and is illegal both domestically and globally. Edward Snowden’s revelations about these activities were done so in the public interest and set him apart from many other Americans charged with espionage by the U.S. government- he is a whistleblower. For this reason, in the eyes of the international community he has committed a non-violent political crime (under the assumption that he has committed a crime). Because of this and other reasons, granting Snowden political asylum is absolutely within Russia’s rights. One can witness a large effort on behalf of the US government, from the latter half of the 20th century...

Words: 2540 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Nsa: Surveillance Awareness Project Proposal

... A proposal prepared by Team Underachievers Shea Polansky Gabriela Cde Baca Jacob Nevarez Elliot Nicholas For Dr. Natasha Jones University of New Mexico 2014-10-21 Team Underachievers Memo TO:​​Dr. Natasha Jones FROM:​Team Underachievers DATE:​​2014-10-7 SUBJECT:​Proposal PURPOSE:​To acquaint you with our proposal Dear Dr. Jones, Edward Snowden’s leaks about the National Security Agency’s mass surveillance programs created a global debate about privacy, security, and safety. The NSA has the capability to read email, snoop on private social network conversations, observe phone call records, and track the physical locations of citizens not charged nor suspected of any crime, without so much as a warrant. Worse, the demographic most affected this level of snooping on our digital lives, the 18-24 year-old college crowd, is the least knowledgeable and most politically apathetic about the issue. This is a recipe for disaster, and this proposal seeks funding for an awareness campaign that will address it. This campaign will raise awareness about mass surveillance and the Snowden disclosures. We will use posters and flyers to dry attention to the issue. We will use the University of New Mexico as a testing ground, using before and after surveys to gauge effectiveness. If the campaign proves successful, we will recruit volunteers and raise a second round of funding to bring the campaign to college campuses across the nation. Team Underachievers......

Words: 3481 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Evaluating an Argument

...editorial from The Washington Post titled “The NSA must disclose more to make it case”. This article touches on a sensitive topic which has spark out a debate across the country. The article says “the bulk collection of phone ‘metadata’ and call records is a potentially powerful tool that could reveal sensitive facts about nearly every American’s life if abused, and according to the article this practice was disclosed by the NSA’s former contractor Edward Snowden who demands extensive checks to guard against misuse (Washington Post, 2013). According to the article, a taskforce was formed and was to submit a report to President Obama, in their report they would like to see a higher legal standard applied in accessing phone records by government. The report proposed an end to the bulk collection of records, calling on the NSA to approach phone companies and ask for records as when investigators need them on a case-by-case basis. Government officials seemed to open in considering this arrangement but voiced concern that investigative speed may be lost in the interest of privacy protection (Washington Post, 2013) The article argued that for the NSA to make a strong case, it must demonstrate the national security benefit to the program. It further did mentioned of the U.S. District Judge Richard J. Leon who issued an injunction to prevent the bulk collection of the data. His actions gives the government a chance to appeal and he ruled that the NSA phone-records database......

Words: 900 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Internet Surveillance

...Contrary to what many people may think, online private data and cellphone meta-data is susceptible to snooping by not only government agencies and corporations, but also hackers willing to risk a prison sentence. In 2013, NSA whistle blower Edward Snowden revealed previously unknown details of global surveillance programs run by the United States' NSA in close cooperation with three partners: Australia, the United Kingdom, and Canada. The documents leaked by Mr. Snowden revealed details about the NSA secretly tapping into Yahoo and Google data centers to collect information from millions of accounts worldwide. The shocking evidenced released by Mr. Snowden reveals that lawmakers and politicians should take greater control over how and why they are using their surveillance technologies, and question whether or not the fight against terrorism justifies the use of these surveillance programs on citizens as well. Furthermore, it is important to ensure that there be continued innovation in internet security in order to create services and products which can counter-act the use of these programs on ordinary citizens who don’t want their data accessible to anyone but themselves. Spying agencies are able to cripple the civil liberties and the right to privacy of citizens, therefore it is imperative that the government protect the rights of citizens through reforms on Surveillance Acts, but it is also equally pertinent for citizens take initiative and push for new reforms and......

Words: 1527 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Nsa Dilemma

...NSA-Het dilemma Tot voor kort, en wellicht nog steeds, heeft de Verenigde Staten verscheidene apparaten ‘afgetapt’. Aftappen; door middel van het plaatsen van afluisterapparatuur informatie verkrijgen uit gesprekken die andere mensen voeren. Legaal of illegaal? Privacy schending of veiligheid? Er rijzen veel onbeantwoorde vragen na de openbaring van Edward Snowden over de vage zaakjes binnen zijn ex-baan, oftewel de afluisterpraktijken van de NSA. Velen onder ons hebben een negatief beeld bij het begrip spionage. Maar niet alle spionage is slecht Met het aftappen van telefoongesprekken kan de NSA namelijk wel grote rampen voorkomen. Pas op het moment dat het verzamelen van data ongelimiteerd wordt, wordt het gevaarlijk. Met terugwerkende kracht kunnen wij, de burgers, de activiteiten van de NSA reconstrueren. Klokkenluider Snowden heeft duidelijk gemaakt dat dit onbeperkt verzamelen van data nu gaande is. Sommigen zien hem als een persoon die codes verbroken heeft, die zijn land verraden heeft. ‘Hij heeft de Constitutie verraden. De VS zijn niet gesticht om een 29-jarige in zijn eentje te laten beslissen over wat openbaar moet worden gemaakt.’ Anderen zien hem als een held. ‘Snowden geeft alles op, staat voor zijn daad en beschermt zijn omgeving. Dan ben je een ware held.’ Waar hebben we het over? In plaats van nadenken over het daadwerkelijke probleem, de NSA en haar verzwegen feiten, hebben we het over Snowden, of hij het de wereld wel in had moeten brengen. We moeten......

Words: 417 - Pages: 2