Comparing the Theme of Madness in “the Tell-Tale Heart” and “the Black Cat”

In: Novels

Submitted By qwert777
Words 1527
Pages 7
Comparing the Theme of Madness in “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat”


This Essay is going to compare theme of madness presented to reader in two short stories ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ and ‘The Black Cat’ both by Edgar Allan Poe.


One might argue that the theme of madness is presented quite differently in both short stories if compared to each other. ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ presents us a true madman; the main character kills the old man because of the look of the old mans eye. This is highlighted by the piece, which was extracted from the story itself “I loved the old man. He had never wrong me. He had never given me insult. For his gold I had no desire. I think it was his eye! Yes it was this” Furthermore it is clearly shown that the madman liked the old man and he didn’t want old mans money. Madman committed the most atrocious of crimes because of the old mans appearance. However the main character doesn’t think he is mad and strongly believes that the old mans eye was pure evil, and this is highlighted by the quotes from “The Tell-Tale Heart”. “You fancy me mad. Madmen know nothing. But you should have seen me. You should have seen how wisely I proceeded --with what caution --with what foresight --with what dissimulation I went to work! I was never kinder to the old man than during the whole week before I killed him”. The main character almost tries to compensate the murder by saying that he was nice to the old man before he killed him. Moreover, the main character still refused to believe in his madness “Ha! Would a madman been so wise as this”. The main character truly and faithfully believes that he is too clever, too cautious, too driven with his ideas to be mad and yet he still admits that he murdered the old man for the look of the old mans eye. “For it was not the old man who vexed me, but his evil eye”. On-going, the main character tries to…...

Similar Documents

Tell Tale Heart

...“It is the beating of his heart” -Discuss how the writer has employed the symbol of the heart to create an atmosphere of suspense & horror. Give textual evidence to support your response. Edgar Allan Poe has very effectively used the symbol of heart to evoke a mixture of uncomfortable suspense & terror in the readers. ‘The tell-tale heart’ The title itself employees the symbol of heart which has connotation to deception thus creating a feeling of apprehension in the reader. The title also comes across as very personal due to the use of ‘heart’ which effectively catches reader’s attention and evokes a feeling of suspense. The use of the symbol of heart appears again when the writer says “I knew what the old man felt & pitied him although I chuckled at heart” this makes the reader uncomfortable because of the ease by which writer has employed the evil deceptive role of killer’s heart here in the nerve wrecking situation & leaves the reader in uneasy suspense. “low, dull, quick sound –much such a sound as a watch makes when enveloped in cotton” this detailed description of the old man’s heart appeals to over aural senses hence giving a vivid impression which evokes the sense of terror in the reader. The narrator further heightens the reader’s horror by making a morbid comparison “such as a watch makes when enveloped in cotton” this strange comparison strikes the reader’s as ironic & chilling as this physiologically disturbing comparison foreshadows the...

Words: 453 - Pages: 2

Poe and the Tell Tale Heart

...Edgar Allen-Poe, born 1809 died 1849, is widely acclaimed as one of the first and greatest gothic writers. His output mostly consisted of short stories and poems for various American magazines in the 1840s. During his lifetime, he achieved fame and recognition however he lived a life of poverty. An alcoholic and an opium taker, his stories often display a surreal or dreamlike style. The world which Poe would have known was more superstitious and dangerous than what we know today. For example, in the 19th century having a coma could be mistaken for death, as a result, it was not uncommon to be buried alive, Poe included live burial in many of his works – to exploit public fears. One of the main assets of his work however is his ability to build intense suspense. By using a variety of techniques Poe was able to create tension and mystery in his (short) stories: Poe employs excessively detailed descriptions and repetition to delay the reader’s arrival at the final climax; Poe does this because he wanted to give time for the suspense to build up before arrival at the inevitably blood-curdling climax. For example, In tell-tale heart before the murderer kills the old man there is a substantial amount of repetition and more complex sentences : ” cautiously -- oh, so cautiously -- cautiously (for the hinges creaked), I undid it just so much that a single thin ray fell upon the vulture eye.” As a result of this delay, the reader becomes even more inquisitive over what events will...

Words: 804 - Pages: 4

Comparing the Theme of Madness in “the Tell-Tale Heart” and “the Black Cat”

...Comparing the Theme of Madness in “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat” This Essay is going to compare theme of madness presented to reader in two short stories ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ and ‘The Black Cat’ both by Edgar Allan Poe. One might argue that the theme of madness is presented quite differently in both short stories if compared to each other. ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ presents us a true madman; the main character kills the old man because of the look of the old mans eye. This is highlighted by the piece, which was extracted from the story itself “I loved the old man. He had never wrong me. He had never given me insult. For his gold I had no desire. I think it was his eye! Yes it was this” Furthermore it is clearly shown that the madman liked the old man and he didn’t want old mans money. Madman committed the most atrocious of crimes because of the old mans appearance. However the main character doesn’t think he is mad and strongly believes that the old mans eye was pure evil, and this is highlighted by the quotes from “The Tell-Tale Heart”. “You fancy me mad. Madmen know nothing. But you should have seen me. You should have seen how wisely I proceeded --with what caution --with what foresight --with what dissimulation I went to work! I was never kinder to the old man than during the whole week before I killed him”. The main character almost tries to compensate the murder by saying that he was nice to the old man before he killed him. Moreover, the main...

Words: 1527 - Pages: 7

Tell Tale Heart

...------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- “The Tell-Tale Heart” 4. Old man – younger than this man. 5. He is trying to convince that he is not mad, he says all the time things like “here is the reason why I am not mad”, he is very angry because of the old man’s eye. 6. p. 155 l. 3-6 (Because he did the killing job so well) and p. 157 l. 9-10 (not mad because he took so good care of the dead body) 7. a. p. 157 l. 16-17 (Laughing and showing how good he is to cover the body) b. p. 156 l. 36-38 8. He thinks that he is not mad because he is planning the whole thing so well, he is doing everything so right and he keeps telling us that he is not mad because he is doing his plan so well. But we as a narrator think that being insane is to plan what he is planning. 9. a. p. 154 l. 9-10 (loves him) b. p. 155 l. 1-2 c. Good and fine d. He looks at the old man at night but he cannot do it because the “evil eye” of the old man is not open at the first seven days. e. He is there all night to hear f. Experience the feeling the old man feels and that is “funny” to him 10. a. p. 156 l. 2-3 and l. 5-8 Had been hearing the person every night, his fear grows and tries to calm himself with that it is just a mouse, but he is scared about what he is hearing. b. p. 154 l. 12 it is so disturbing that he decides to take the old man’s life c. A feeling of a desire to kill, angry and mad d. p...

Words: 638 - Pages: 3

The Tell-Tale Heart Essay

...The Tell-Tale Heart Edgar Allan Poe is the author of the short story, “the tell-tale heart”, which he wrote in 1842. The whole story takes place in an old man’s house, mainly in the bedroom, in approximately 1842 as that is when the story is written, perhaps a bit earlier. The story is written in first person and therefore making this narrator unreliable. A first person narrator cannot be omniscient. Another reason for the unreliability of the narrator is the fact that he is mad. He tries to deny this, even prove to us, the readers, that he is perfectly sane; this is in fact the reason why he ‘chose’ to tell us this story. In this story we are introduced to the owner – who is referred to as “the old man” by the narrator – of the house. This old man has a pale, blue eye, which the narrator thinks resembles that of a vulture. He calls it “the Evil Eye”. The short story starts with an introduction of the story we are about to be told and it is told in chronological order. The narrator wants us to know why he is not mad. Everything he tells us, though, leaves us with the impression that he really is mad – “It took me an hour to place my whole head within the opening […] Ha! – would a madman have been so wise as this?” – The way he brags about an accomplishment like this one makes him seem crazy and as the story progresses we can confirm that he is indeed mad. The theme in the story is horror and paranoia. Due to the fact it is written in the 19th century it...

Words: 907 - Pages: 4

The Theme of Madness and of Love and Hate in the Tell Tale Heart

... to defend throughout the short story. The narrator’s sharpened senses, particularly his acute hearing, are what lead him to his downfall as he hears his own heartbeat filled with guilt, not the old man’s, at the end of the story displaying that his heartbeat is a manifestation of his guilt. Two of the recurring themes that appear within the “Tell Tale Heart” are madness and the tension between love and hate. The theme of madness is often found in many of Poe’s short stories but it is often revealed through the use of different literary devices or elements. The narrator’s characterization and his calm tone reveal the feeling of madness or insanity within the short story. It is because of his constant denial and delusion, that brings the audience into the conclusion that the narrator is simply lying to himself or is trying to prove to himself otherwise. The tension between love and hate is another contradictory element that further proves that the narrator is in fact insane. The narrator, at various points in the story, states that he shows no remorse towards the old man, that in fact he loves the old man and is neither interested in the old man’s money or wealth, but what propels his hate towards the old man is the old man’s pale blue vulture eye. The narrator loves the old man and hates him at the same time. He is in a very contradictory dilemma, as he cannot find himself killing the old man when his vulture eye is closed and is brought into a feeling of hatred when he lays...

Words: 809 - Pages: 4

The Tell Tale Heart

...Essay on The Tell Tale Heart The following essay is presented as a dialog in which a psychiatrist provides inside about the main protagonist in Edgar Alan Poe´s "The Tell Talel Heart" How would you describe the suspect’s mental state of mind? The suspects mind seems to be separating from reality. In my book he fits into the category of a pure sociopath. Through my ongoing therapy I have learned that the suspect suffers from unresolved childhood trauma, and long lasted antisocial behaviour. The suspect suffers from an identity crisis, and has a difficult time telling reality from his own thoughts. Throughout our conversations the suspect has refused any cooperation between him and me and has been hostile and rejectable throughout the whole experience. He knows who he is at this moment but that moment could pass at any time and then his traumatised mind dictates his action. Why do you think the suspect admitted to his crimes? An unbearable amount of guilt forced the suspect into admitting the murder. Just like his mind dictated his decision to murder the victim, his mind also forced him to admit it. At the arrival of the police the suspect told himself that his crime was already discovered and thus he felt he had no other choice but to surrender. If the suspect felt that large amount of guilt then why did he kill the victim? Like I mentioned earlier the suspect jumps in and out of his own subverted version of reality. In those moments the suspect speaks of him not...

Words: 397 - Pages: 2

The Tell-Tale Heart Analysis

...The story the tell tale heart by Edgar Allan Poe is one of his shorter stories but interesting one at that. The story is mysterious and equivocal at times. The most interesting thing in the story is the narrator. The narrator is trying to prove his sanity throughout the story. If the narrator is trying to prove a Saturday but only she confesses heinous crime he is all but insane. The narrator opens up the story by admitting he is "very very dreadfully nervous" type of person. He then states he is not mad, to reveal that he is a madman and capable of a heinous crime. The narrator speaks of his sensitivities that allow him to hear "all things in the heaven and the earth," also in hell. The sensitivities are part of the reason he became obsessed with the old man's eyes which in return murders the old man for his Vulture eye. The narrator starts his story off with the fact that he "loved the old man," adding "He never wronged me." This is when he leads into his obsession and the vulture eye. He goes into great detail about the eye "A pale blue eye, with a film over it." Only A madman would obsess that much over an eye to have no motivation to kill the old man but the obsession of the vulture eye. In this paragraph the narrator contradicts himself with his mental ability to love and hate at the same time. He then wants to prove to us his sanity by how "wisely" he would proceed with caution foresight and dissimulation he executes his deeds. He then goes into how every...

Words: 963 - Pages: 4

The Tell Tale Heart Film to Literature

...When asked, most people would say the book is better than the movie but film brings a clearer image to a story. The Tell Tale Heart is a story about a man who claims he has a disease but implies that because it has not dulled his senses, he cannot be called mad. He also points out his mental disorder actually caused his senses to become more acute. When he claims that he has heard things from heaven and hell, it gives away that his super human sensory is an illusion. He seems insane, he talks about an old man who he loves, but he can’t stand his eye or his heart beat. Before the end of the story he kills the old man. In the film there are characteristics that add to this story. The visualization, since you don’t have to imagine it, gives a greater impact. Film has the ability to add a lot of emphasis that make certain scenes stick out from the rest. This grabs attention. Some elements in film can’t be put into literature, an obvious one is actual sound. There are many different similarities in film and literature adaptions, but film brings unique qualities to a story that literature cannot. Film adaptation provides a physical visual for the events in the story. The film begins with a scene of the killer standing in a dark room while in a straightjacket. It's an erie start for the film. The killer is breathing heavily and opens his eyes slowly. This scene gives evidence that he is mad mentally and emotionally. This also makes it seem like the killer has objective. The...

Words: 1702 - Pages: 7

The Tell Tale Heart

...The Tell-Tale Heart In Edgar Allan Poe's "The Tell-Tale Heart," the narrator who later proves himself morbidly insane by committing a gruesome murder spends his entire story trying to convince an unknown audience that he is not mad. The unreliableness of this narrator shows up in the very beginning of his story. He begins speaking to an audience that is unknown. This is revealed in his first words, "True!---nervous---very, very dreadfully nervous I had been and am; but why will you say that I am mad?" In this first sentence alone the narrator discredits his reliability several times. First, it is unknown to who he is telling his story. The reader can only guess. It is unknown if he is speaking to a psychiatrist, a prison warden, or himself. The fact that his audience is unknown makes the narrator in this story unreliable. Secondly, he states his nervousness. It shows here that he is unstable and cannot be trusted. Finally, the best example of the narrator's unreliability is in his continuous attempts from his first words, and to the end of his story to convince that he is not a madman. It is seen over and over in the following statements, "Now this is the point. You fancy me as mad. Madmen know nothing. But, you should have seen me. You should have seen how wisely I proceeded---with what caution---with what foresight---with what dissimulation I went to work!" and, "And now have I not told you that what you mistake for madness is but over-acuteness of the senses?" His...

Words: 407 - Pages: 2

Tell Tale Heart

...{A Case Study of Madness } Robert “Devin” Earl {Friday, February 5, 2016} Throughout Edgar Allen Poe’s work Tell Tale Heart several patterns, and symbolic elements are present. Each of these elements play respective roles in revealing the purpose of the work as a whole. Poe wants to convey a feeling of paranoia and mental illness. Its as if Poe wants his work to function as a summary of a case study about mental deterioration. He uses his diction purposefully and scarcely in order to have the main character convey a feeling of obsession with very specific entities of the old man. The main character has a unhealthy fixation on the old man’s eye, his heartbeat and even his claim to sanity. As the story progresses sever different psychological contradictions come to illumination that each contribute to the general profile of a murder. In example the narrator openly admits “to being dreadfully nervous”, however he is unable to comprehend why he is thought of as deranged He articulates his self-defense against madness in terms of increased sensory ability. Instead of of viewing this hypersensitivity as a clue to being mentally unwell the narrator uses it to prove to himself his possession of sanity and not a product of madness. Another symbolic element that proves Poe is conveying a study of the mentally unstable is the narrator’s detachment between emotional feelings such as love and hate. Poe uses his story to explore a psychological paradox between those who cannot...

Words: 420 - Pages: 2

Comparisons of Tell-Tale Heart and the Black Cat

...? Another theme in both stories is the murder of seemingly innocent victims and the obsession leading to the murders. In “The Black Cat” the obsession is a cat named Pluto. Although the narrator originally had no problem with Pluto, he would eventually be driven to cut out Pluto’s eye because Pluto angered him and all because the cat loved him. The narrator could not stop obsessing over the eye he removed and eventually killed the cat. He then found another cat, which also had a missing eye, and took it home with him. He could not harm the cat out of guilt for killing Pluto. Eventually he did try to kill it, however, his wife prevented him from doing so and for this he killed his wife. In “The Tell-Tale Heart” the obsession is with the old man’s “vulture eye”. The narrator had no problem with the old man, in fact he loved him, and it was his eye that the narrator was bothered by and because of this he was driven to kill the old man. In both stories you notice that eyes are an object of obsession, why might eyes be triggering for Poe? They say eyes are the window to the soul. Maybe Poe felt an obsession with eyes because he felt people would be able to see who he truly is? Maybe he feared he was a killer and his positive outlet is writing. Or maybe his writing is an admission of his guilt for his sins? Something else that is very similar, is the insanity of the each narrator. Each narrator began their stories by claiming that they are not insane and both feel they......

Words: 861 - Pages: 4

Tell Tale Heart

...Rachel Murray B. Sumey, Instructor Comp. II, TTH 3:00 18 Feb. 2012 Insanity In the short story “The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe, the narrator is very insane and mentally ill. He is a murderer, does not sleep much, is very paranoid, and is unable to distinguish what is real and unreal. It is clear that Poe wants to create a character who is mad. First off, the narrator kills the old man. By doing so, he is considered a murderer. The death occurs “in an instant I dragged him to the floor, and pulled the heavy bed over him” (44). He is obviously not in his right mind to murder someone in such a manner. The narrator even claims to enjoy the event of murdering the old man. The narrator is crazy because he does not sleep much during the night. Instead of getting a good night’s rest, he takes the time to go and watch the old man sleep: “And every night, about midnight, I turned the latch of his door and opened it – oh, so gently!” (42). Staying up every night affects his judgement because he does this for one whole week. “. . . that every night, just at twelve, I looked upon him while he slept” (43). The reason he stays up and watches the old man is so that he can be ready for anything that can possibly go wrong during his murder plan. The character sounds like he is hysterical. In the very beginning of the short story, this is evident by his saying, “True! – nervous – very, very dreadfully nervous. . .” (42). The protagonist states that he can hear things...

Words: 531 - Pages: 3

The Tell Tale Heart

...The Tell-Tale Heart Q. Choose a novel or a short story in which the author creates a fascinating character. By referring to appropriate techniques, show how the author has created this character and why you found him/her so interesting. Among the many strange and complex short stories by Edgar Allen Poe, ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ has come to be known as one of the most mysterious and psychologically intriguing. The story contains a fascinating character in form of the narrator, which is explored through Poe’s use of word choice, irony, and alliteration, as well as many other thought provoking techniques. The story as a whole explores the themes of perception versus reality, and the question of whether the evil within is worse than the evil without, and Poe delves into these themes using the character he has created to narrate the story. The story follows the murder of an old man and its aftermath, the story told with what seems like dazzling clarity on behalf of the narrator, obscuring the meaning of the act and calling the emotional stability of the unnamed, assumed male, narrator into question. In the very first sentence of the story, Poe introduces irony to draw in the reader, and leaves the beginning purposefully ambiguous to cause intrigue towards the narrator. “TRUE! – nervous – very, very dreadfully nervous I had been, and am; but why will you say that I am mad?” By starting the sentence with the word ‘true’, Poe leads us to believe what we read next will be some...

Words: 1499 - Pages: 6

Tell-Tale Heart

...The story I chose to write this paper over was “The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe. In this story I think that the main character who is the narrator wants to be free from the power of the old man’s eye. The old man’s eye reminded him of a vulture’s eye and made the narrator very uncomfortable and “froze his blood” under his skin. I believe that it may have been hard for the narrator to leave the old man so killing him would be the only way to escape his eye. Even under these circumstances the narrator still seems abnormal and a tad bit frightening because he seems to take pleasure in spying on the old man which he did for eight nights prior to murdering him. “I could scarcely contain my feelings of triumph. To think that there I was, opening the door, little by little, and he did not even dream of my secret deeds or thoughts.” (4) I think that one of the obstacles that the man faces is the actual murder of the old man. He likes the old man and treats him well, the old man has never mistreated or insulted the man. He wasn’t after the old man’s gold or possessions either, he just hated the old man’s eye so in order to completely rid himself of the eye he had to murder the man. The murder was a very creepy and elaborate process. I think that another obstacle that the narrator faces is his “mad mind”. The man can’t think straight and has insanely good hearing. The night of the murder the narrator wakes up the old man accidentally and can hear everything he does...

Words: 486 - Pages: 2