Scottish Independence

In: Social Issues

Submitted By laurenprattx
Words 1117
Pages 5
Unit 3: Thinking Report
‘Scottish independence’
Lauren Pratt – 1200370

As the SNP came to authority four years ago there has been a surge of interest across the country. Becoming independent will mean the people who care most about Scotland will be taken the decision about our future.
A debate was presented by Stewart Hosie, a Member of Parliament for Dundee East, who was in favour of the motion besides Jenny Marra, who was the second presenter, who is a member of the Scottish Parliament for Dundee North East, Scottish Labour, was in opposition to the motion. Stewart Hosie gave an analytical, quantitative and fact driven argument. Jenny Marra gave a biographical, personal and historical argument. Both played a conception of their audience as largely conservative. In the debate ‘It is time for Scotland to become independent,’ presented on the 17th of September at University of Abertay, Stewart Hosie stated that for many countries, independence is taken for granted, and Scotland should be given that opportunity also. The biggest part of his argument was a number of statistics which he used to show the sustainability and competency to succeed of an independent Scottish nation by use of taxation, and by exploitation of the North Sea. He encouraged that large manufacturing plants should be returned to Scotland, and through these opportunities, this nation would thrive if no longer dependent on the rest of the UK.
On the other hand Jenny Marra took a less statistical approach, making it easier to follow her argument. She believed that Britain is able to achieve within many areas which would be impossible for one of the states alone. Furthermore the UK is one of the most effective political unions in the history of the world. Jenny repeated the phrase ‘Sharing together, stronger together ‘to establish the importance Scotland’s relationship is with the rest of…...

Similar Documents

An Introduction to the Scottish Nature

...Scotland Scotland. The place where thousands of nature-loving people are drawn to, just to breathe in the intoxicatingly clean Scottish air and to feel the heartbeats of the Highlands. It is an ancient and magical place, where beauty isn’t a description, but a fact. From the Highlands to the lochs and lakes brimming with crystal clear, icy cold water, the country seems to have a never-ending abundance of nature reserves, parks and woods. But what is it that makes the Scottish nature so special and loved? How does the nature affect the native Scottish people and the tourists? And also, how do they affect the Scottish nature, will it look the same for the future generations? To answer the first question, we have contacted a specialist on the subject. It’s (?....?), who has been doing research on the matter for almost half a decade: “….” If you have ever had the privilege of visiting Scotland, you will know just what an incredible wealth of natural treasures it possesses. The fine scenery is inspiring to live in and visit, and the imagery of an unspoilt landscape is important in the marketing of Scottish brands selling products such as whiskey. The nature is also important in the marketing of tourism, in fact some cities across the Scottish landscape rely almost entirely on the tourists coming there to experience the wildlife. One of those cities is Oban. Oban is a town known for its tasty whiskey; the city is actually built around the Oban Whiskey Distillery. Nowadays,......

Words: 490 - Pages: 2

Scottish Independence

...-------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3 Chapter I General information ---------------------------------------------------------------- 4 Chapter II Arguments for and against the Scottish independence Arguments for the independence ----------------------------------------------- 6 Arguments against the independence ----------------------------------------- 7 Conclusion --------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10 Bibliography ------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11 Introduction The subject I have analyzed in this research paper is the possible independence of Scotland. I chose this topic because the Scottish independence is a problem of great importance not only for the UK and Scotland, but also for the whole Europe. While doing my research I found very strong and opposing opinions about this recent topic. Scottish independence is a relevant and important matter that has been debated for many years but is now at the pinnacle of debate. Both public and politicians and opposing opinions about independence and throughout this work I will evaluate the most current and most emotive arguments for and against independence. First, I will speak about the historical background of this issue and about the parties “fighting” for independence. Next, I will represent for and against arguments, which will help to understand this complicated issue. Chapter......

Words: 2480 - Pages: 10

Independence or Is It..

...broadcasts what the Prime Minister's has to address the nation in the ramparts of Red Fort , when all you hear is Lata Mangeskar'r melodious voice serenading 'Vande Mataram' in the radio stations, and you see the tricolour in siphon flying up in the air with pride, I am sure, the world definitely is screaming at me, 'It's our nation 67th independence!' And believe me, I am chanting all the more from inside~ ' The Independence Day is marked as a red-letter day in India. It is celebrated on 15th august every year. On this day in 1947,India got its independence...' For the whole essay, you may refer to any 7th standard student. Trust me, he has just mugged it up fresh and can present before you in a much rhythmic manner than I did to you just now. Every general knowledge books in India finds a centimetre space for our Independence history. The very rejoice in the fact that we, Indians are freed from the regime of the British, agreed. But mind you, it is only the freedom from the tenure of the East India Company that we are celebrating. Freedom from poverty,disparity,racism,dangerous crime, this does not count on the list of Independence now? Where is the freedom of a girl at 12.00 am when she returning from her office on a deserted road? Where are the dreams and wishes cremated of the slum children on the way to Campus-15, when they beg us with their smiling faces,'Didi,chocolate dio!'? When is the eligibility criteria of importance, when a merititous general caste......

Words: 554 - Pages: 3

Scottish Newcastle vs the Parchim

...Read the two cases below and look up a response to the questions following each case. This forum is intended as a place for you to raise issues or questions which may arise when you are undertaking this exercise. This forum will be open until the end of the Christmas break.   1. Scottish & Newcastle International Ltd v Othon Ghalanos Ltd [2008] UKHL 11   Why was the contract considered to be an FOB contract in this case? Compare speeches of Rodger LJ and Mance LJ regarding time of delivery.   2. The Parchim [1918] AC 157
   Why was it so important to determine whether property had passed in this case? What considerations did the court take into account in making the determination? Do you consider that it would have made any difference had the contract been on FOB terms? ANSWERS:   1. Scottish & Newcastle International Ltd v Othon Ghalanos Ltd [2008] UKHL 11 => Why was the contract considered to be an FOB contract in this case? Compare speeches of Rodger LJ and Mance LJ regarding time of delivery. B, the buyer (Cyprus company), failed to pay the price of the goods shipped by the S, the seller (Scottish company), from Liverpool to Limassol, in a contract of sale governed by the law of England. The question was whether the English court had jurisdiction to entertain the action. It would have been the case if the goods were deemed delivered on shipment at Liverpool but not if the goods were deemed delivered in Limassol. This is the application of......

Words: 3218 - Pages: 13

Independence Day

...the right to do as we please, but as the opportunity to do what is right. Good morning everyone. I, Manal Khursheed am honored to have been given the privilege of being able to express my views about the most important day in our glorious country’s history, that is the 15th of August, our Independence Day. Independence literally means the freedom and opportunity to make our own decisions for our own betterment and well-being. Independence was not easy to gain. It is the reward of the culmination of the hard work and passion of thousands of our forefathers who dared to dream of an independent India and had the courage and determination to fight for it. The names of Jawaharlal Nehru, Subhash Chandra Bose, Maulana Azad and Bhagat Singh have been forever immortalized in the pages of our country’s history. They were common men but pride and respect for their nation led to them breaking the shackles which bound us. Their inspirational speeches and impassioned quotes still live on in our hearts and continue to inspire generation after generation of Indians. “Long years ago, we made a tryst with destiny”: Jawaharlal Nehru’s Independence Day speech delivered on the eve of Indian independence still roars loud within every Indian’s heart. The idealist and lover of non-violence, Gandhiji, whose policy of Satyagraha had an overwhelming number of skeptics and critics, continued to believe in goodwill and truth as two weapons with more power than the might of all the armies of the......

Words: 604 - Pages: 3

Declaration of Independence

...Paper 1 The Declaration of Independence was adopted by the Continental Congress on July 4, 1776 and announced the separation of the thirteen American colonies from British control. Thomas Jefferson wrote the first draft, and after several edits, it became the final document. Jefferson employed several key concepts and phrases in the introduction and preamble. The introduction paragraph sets up what the rest of the document is about. Jefferson states that when it is time for a people to separate from a country, it is necessary for them to “declare the causes which impel them to the separation.” This indicates that the rest of the Declaration will outline and highlight the reasons why the American colonists decided to sever ties with Great Britain. The first half of the preamble–the second paragraph of the Declaration of Independence–says that humans have certain rights, and the purpose of a government is to protect these rights. The first key phrase declares, “. . . all men are created equal.” This, however, is contradictory considering the existence of slavery in the colonies and the fact that the author, Thomas Jefferson, owned hundreds of slaves himself. Some argue that those who signed the Declaration thought of “the people” as male property owners, which would not include women or slaves as being equal. However, in the original draft, Jefferson did condemn King George for allowing the slave trade to flourish, but Congress voted against this because they did not want......

Words: 579 - Pages: 3


...Section B of the Interpretation of Rule 101-1 states that independence is impaired when “a partner or professional employee of the firm, his or her immediate family, or any group of such persons acting together own[s] more than 5 percent of a client's outstanding equity securities or other ownership interests” (ET 101.02). The Code of Conduct further defines an immediate family member as “a spouse, spousal equivalent, or dependent (whether or not related)” (ET 92.13). As far as issues of independence are concerned, married couples (or the equivalent) are of one mind, and something that is favorable to one spouse will be favorable to the other. Not only must the auditor meet all of the required guidelines to maintain independence, but his or her spouse must as well. This prevents auditors from purchasing stock in a client company under his or her child’s name, or encouraging his or her spouse to do so. Due to the fact that the family works as one unit, the entire family is required to be independent of any audit clients. The final section of the Interpretation of Rule 101-1, Section C, prohibits auditors on the engagement team from previously or currently being employed by the audit client. The requirement is that the attest engagement team member must not have served as director, officer, promoter, underwriter, or held any management position with the client company during the period of time the financial statements cover. Anyone with such an experience would know exactly......

Words: 625 - Pages: 3

Scottish Enlightenment Social Theory

...This essay seeks to define why the Scottish Enlightenment theorists rejected previous attempts at social theory and instead formulated their own social theory. It also seeks to define what was scientific about their approach compared to other theorists who formulated other social theories. Firstly the enlightenment will be defined and previous attempts at social theory outlined. Secondly the theorists social theory will be outlined and finally a discussion of why their approach could be considered scientific. This essay will argue that it was the theorists’ departure from conjecture and sermon which made their theory so radical for its time, and their application of the new framework of Newtonian science which allowed their application to be considered scientific. The enlightenment was a period of philosophical thought and intellectual development which began in the eighteenth century (Ritzer, 2010). The enlightenment theorists sought to combine empirical research with the developing model of Newtonian science. The theorists were convinced that the world around them could be understood using reason and research and that the institutions which governed social values and societal norms were rooted in irrationality and actually acted to inhibit human development (Ritzer, 2010). The theorist’s arguments clashed with the conjectural and traditionally espoused history of the social institutions such as the Church and the political regimes of the countries they operated in......

Words: 2447 - Pages: 10

Scottish Independence

...Scottish independence- pros and cons from the economical point of view Essay Recently the Scottish referendum and especially the economic consequences of Scottish independence became one of the most interesting and controversial world topics. The most common view is that Scotland needs the rest of the UK and the economic and social factors of independence would be too great to deal with. Many people think that going independent is an extremely large economic gamble and will lead to many unwanted consequences - lack of national resources, economic crisis because of investors’ uncertainty, higher tax and interest rates, currency problems, change in the economic and political relationships with European union and other countries. In its unity with the UK, Scotland is part of a very powerful, rich and influential state. This confers all kinds of useful economic benefits, including low interest rates, a seat at the UN Security Council, leadership in NATO and other multinational organizations. So becoming independent would significantly decrease Scotland's global presence and influence. The choice of currency will also lead to wide ranging economic implications. An independent Scotland would, in theory, have three main currency options: its own currency, using the Euro and continuing to use the pound. The European Union has ruled out Scotland joining the euro (or even the EU). So if an independent Scotland did not join a currency area with the rest of the UK, its main option......

Words: 551 - Pages: 3


...INDIAN ECONOMY: 1. Economic Development of India NCERT XI standard 2. Indian Economy – Mishra and Puri or Dutt and Sundaram 3. Indian Economy – PK Dhar 4. Economics – Samuel Son 5. India Year Book & Economic Survey (Government Pub.) 6. For the current aspects of Indian economy students have to depend on news papers and periodicals. II. INDIAN POLITY: 1. Our Constitution – Subhash Kashyap 2. Our Parliament - Subhash Kashyap 3. An Introduction to Indian Constitution – DD Basu 4. Perspectives on Indian Constitution – Subash Kashyap III INDIAN HISTORY: 1. NCERT History books for Classes XI & XII 2. Freedom Struggle – Bipan Chandra (NBT Publication) 3. India’s Struggle for Independence – Bipan Chandra and Others 4. The Gazetteer of India, Volume 2: History and Culture 5. Indian History for General Studies – K Krishna Reddy (Wizard Pub.) IV. GENERAL SCIENCE: 1. NCERT Books on Biology, Physics and Chemistry, Standard IX & X 2. Anatomy & Physiology for Nurses Courses – Evelyn Pearce 3. Know Your Body – Reader's Digest 4. For current S & T issues, latest Magazines and News Papers can be referred. V. INDIAN GEOGRAPHY: 1. NCERT Geography books for Classes XI & XII 2. Indian Geography 3. Principles of Geography 4. World Geography 5. Atlas of World and India. VI. MENTAL ABILITY: 1. Objective Arithmetic – R.S.Agarwal 2. Numerical Ability – Tyra VII. ......

Words: 633 - Pages: 3

Scottish Militiamen Chest Sizes

...Course code: STA-201-GS Course name: PRINCIPLES OF STATISTICS Written Assignment 8 The written assignment draws on case study discussion exercises at the end of chapter. When preparing your assignment, please identify each answer clearly by question and its number. Case Study: Chest Sizes of Scottish Militiamen (p. 295): Answer a, b, c, d. You must calculate results by hand (though you may use any technology of your choice to verify your answers). a. Construct a relative-frequency histogram for the chest circumference data, using classes based on a single value. Size | Frequency | | | | | | | | | | | | | 33 | 3 | | | | | | | | | | | | 34 | 19 | | | | | | | | | | | | 35 | 81 | | | | | | | | | | | | 36 | 189 | | | | | | | | | | | | 37 | 409 | | | | | | | | | | | | 38 | 753 | | | | | | | | | | | | 39 | 1062 | | | | | | | | | | | | 40 | 1082 | | | | | | | | | | | | 41 | 935 | | | | | | | | | | | | 42 | 646 | | | | | | | | | | | | 43 | 313 | | | | | | | | | | | | 44 | 168 | | | | | | | | | | | | 45 | 50 | | | | | | | | | | | | 46 | 18 | | | | | | | | | | | | 47 | 3 | | | | | | | | | | | | 48 | 1 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | ...

Words: 516 - Pages: 3

Scotland Independence Factors in Education

...PROS Childcare Benefits The Scottish government claim by the end of the first independent Scotland to have all children between 3-4 (and in some cases vulnerable 2 year olds) in full time childcare- equating to time spent at primary school Raising Attainment amongst disadvantaged children The Scottish government state, that the root of some educational problems, stem from children in severe poverty, who have messy home lives & poor diets. A hungry child cannot fulfill their education to the best of their ability and a child who is distracted at home cannot focus on learning. Their main aim is to change the tax & benefit system – tackling poverty will allow more parents to work and provide a better life for children who will then in turn have more time to focus on school and nursery Protecting free tuition in Universities The Scottish government claims to protect free tuition fees for Scottish students and still provide supports for living costs University is one the main focuses of the Scottish economy following independence. The proposal is to remain the same by charging students from other parts of the UK to study for Scotland. This policy recognizes the requirement to keep a mix of students so that the Scottish people benefit from a free education and the universities benefit from a contribution from Students from other parts of the UK and further Apprentiships ‘New Modern Apprenticeship’ would increase year by year with 30,000 modern......

Words: 734 - Pages: 3

Enron: Independence

...Enron: Independence Investors, creditors and other users look at financial report in order to understand and analysis of companies’ financial performance. And auditors are the people who will perform and exanimate all the company financial records in order to make sure its accurate and reliable. Therefore, the auditors must maintain independence in audit process because they will have to express their opinions of fairness about the company’s financial position. According to GAAP, independence section states that all the auditor must maintain independence in mental attitude in all matters relating to audit. It’s also defined as independence in fact and appearance. In addition, independence standards for public companies are currently a strong combination of announcement by AICPA and the SEC and the legal requirements of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, as well as being enforced and interpreted by the PCAOB. Failing to perform independence audit services will brings many negative consequences to the firms because it affects the fairness of auditor’s opinion as well as considering as unethical act. This document will use Enron and Arthur Andersen independence case to discuss more about the important of being independence during audit process and its serious consequences if failure in providing in independence audit work, as well as auditors’ responsibilities. Enron Corporation was an American energy, commodities and services company, which filed bankruptcy at the end of......

Words: 1161 - Pages: 5

The Creative Industries and Scottish Film.

...The Creative Industries and Scottish Film. With its exquisite landscapes, monumental architecture, and breath-taking coastlines, it is no wonder Scotland has always been such a powerful draw to film makers and producers alike. The Scottish film industry has grown from strength to strength in recent years. Arguably putting itself on the map in the nineties with films such as Braveheart (1995) and Trainspotting (1996), Scotland now lends its locations to multimillion-pound productions such as Skyfall (2012), The Dark Knight Rises (2012), Sunshine on Leith (2013) and The Railway Man (2014) as well as TV productions including Game of Thrones (2011) and Outlander (2014). To what extent have Scottish films such as Braveheart and Trainspotting impacted on the tourism industry and given their contrasting portrayals of the Scots, does one hinder tourism more than the other? Can we say whether or not there is a distinct notion of ‘Scottish national identity’ and if such a concept exists to what level is it illustrated in Scottish film? Has the Scottish film industry had an impact on the political landscape in Scotland since it was devolved in 1998? Finally given the effects of Scottish film in Scotland, what has the government put in place in order to develop the industry further? Scotland has produced many world renowned films over the last two decades and has had a large impact on the creative industries in Scotland. It has long retained a certain romance which frequently......

Words: 5642 - Pages: 23

Susidies to Scottish Farmers

...With reference to figure 1, Extract 2 and your own knowledge, discuss the reason for subsidies being paid to Scottish farmers. A subsidy is a grant given by the government which lowers the price of a good, usually designed to encourage production or consumption of a good. Subsidies lower production costs, this comes from a decrease in unit cost, and this could possibly come from an investment in capital stock by Scottish farmers, which leads to more efficiency in production, which leads to a decrease in production cost. A decrease in production cost means an increase in supply which means a decrease in price, also a decrease in a price of a good leads to an increase in demand. The quantity supplied has increased due to lower production costs; this has lead to a decrease in price from P1 to P2. The quantity supplied has increased due to lower production costs; this has lead to a decrease in price from P1 to P2. The quantity demanded has increased from Q1 to Q2 due to the reduction in the cost of production, this has increased output. The quantity demanded has increased from Q1 to Q2 due to the reduction in the cost of production, this has increased output. Due to lower prices, from a decrease in production, goods from farms such as meat and vegetables have become more affordable for those who could not afford it before; this is mainly referring to the poor. Due to more people being able to afford goods like meat and vegetables, the consumption......

Words: 453 - Pages: 2